News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by tabeth on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:19PM (#16209562)
In theory, sure. In practice, they don't go any faster a car is capable of [1]

[1] https://ggwash.org/view/4524/average-schedule-speed-how-does...

Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by tim333 on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @12:04AM (#16211159)
In practice for the route I use most, Harpenden - Kings Cross London: Train 25min, Car 1hr -1.5hr depending on traffic. Regular local busses 2.5 hrs maybe but I've never done that and no one does. The train does 90 mph (max) and the express ones stop once. By car, many many stops.

I theory sure you could drive your porsche at 150mph down some superroad that doesn't exist.

Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by melling on Monday January 22, 2018 @08:00PM (#16209852)
You’re saying that a car on the highway is faster than a subway in midtown Manhattan?

How fast can you drive a car in Manhattan?

And you probably don’t realize this, but modern trains go about 200 mph. They just don’t go that fast in the United States.

China managed to build about 18,000 miles of these trains in about 10 years.

Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by burfog on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:18AM (#16211880)
Modern cars go about 200 mph as well. This happens in Germany.

So, that really doesn't favor the trains. Both trains and cars could theoretically they could go faster in the United States.

Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by Symbiote on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:01AM (#16212041)
This doesn't actually happen in Germany at any time you'd otherwise take the train to our from work. The road is too busy.

Additionally, driving that fast is stressful and dangerous.

Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by llukas on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:25PM (#16209628)
So you compare average speed (that includes all stops) with max speed of a car...?
Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by tabeth on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:28PM (#16209654)
Well, yeah. The MTA in particular apparently has a 55mph max speed (same link). A car can compete. Keep in mind I'm not counting traffic, but obviously is (currently) a huge advantage for a train. I'm talking more about greenfield projects.
Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by tych0 on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:37PM (#16209689)
Ok, so if we ignore one of the major advantages of trains, trains aren't competitive?
Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by chc on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:26PM (#16209629)
I don't think "how fast a car is capable of going" is the relevant comparison in speed of transport via rail vs. bus.
Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by tabeth on Monday January 22, 2018 @08:57PM (#16210221)
I used bus and car interchangeably there as per the link the top speed of the fastest rapid transit was 80 miles per hour. Even a school bus has a 70mph top speed.

Of course, I'm aware that things are much faster (literally) outside the US, but the OP was referencing the US.

Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by goerz on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:29PM (#16209659)
The train between Washington DC and New York City is (slightly) faster door-to-door than driving, without going particularly fast. It’s at least two hours faster than taking the bus. In addition, it’s infinitely more comfortable than either driving or the bus. Weekend commuting would be pretty stressful without it.
Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by btrettel on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:36PM (#16209678)
Worth noting that this depends a lot on the type of service. The DC area MARC commuter train is definitely faster than driving to DC from where my parents live. The train schedule says 96 minutes, compared against 90 to 150 minutes driving according to Google Maps if one leaves at the same time as the typical train I'd take from there. This neglects other factors of course like the comfort of sitting on a train vs. driving in heavy traffic.
Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by goerz on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:51PM (#16209786)
My impression is (for the US) that trains are the optimal way to connect major cities, while buses are good for connecting smaller cities. Ideally, of course, one would have a dense rail network connecting even small towns, as Germany does, but that's never going to happen in the US.
Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by ghaff on Monday January 22, 2018 @08:13PM (#16209941)
>optimal way to connect major cities

Major cities that are relatively close together. The Northeast Corridor works pretty well for the most part--at least the two ends of it do. The whole thing is a full day and probably costs more than a couple hour flight.

Various city pairs also work but anything longer haul has to be for the experience (or avoiding flying) even if everything goes according to schedule. NY to Chicago is about 20 hours for example. (And would be very hard to make fast because of the Appalachian Mountains.)

Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by wbl on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @12:06AM (#16211173)
We can go straight through them if we have to. Chicago to NYC is 800 miles, and at speeds the Nanjing to Jinan line hits daily that is about 4-5 hours.
Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by goerz on Monday January 22, 2018 @08:49PM (#16210172)
Sure, at some point the distances are just too great and flying is the only option
Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by sampo on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @01:44AM (#16211535)
5 hours in train is probably nicer than a 5 hour flight trip (1h to go to airport, 1h in the airport, 2h flight, 1h from airport to destination).
Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by Johnny555 on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:28PM (#16209650)
Depends on the traffic and the train -- during rush hour, a Caltrain express train from San Francisco to San Jose is almost always faster than driving. It can take 90 - 120 minutes to drive during commute hours (at 4:30pm, Google says 90 minutes), versus 65 minutes by train.
Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by tabeth on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:36PM (#16209680)
I don't disagree that a train is better in many situations. I'm more curious about situations where a city is prepared to make a 1B+ capital expenditure. For example boring a tunnel for a train vs. a dedicated bus lane on the highway + exit.
Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by sampo on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @01:49AM (#16211558)
One train can have a capacity of 1000 people. If you run these at 3 minutes interval, you have a throughput of 20,000 people per hour.

One bus takes less than 100 people, and you cannot run 200 buses per hour. Actually about 20 buses per hour is pretty much at the upper limits.

These are rough numbers, but if you need to move more than 2000 people per hour, trains can have the capacity but buses don't.

Re:Once seniors are too old to drive, our transportation sys... by Johnny555 on Monday January 22, 2018 @11:53PM (#16211103)
Is that dedicated lane cheaper? In many cities that are facing a traffic crunch, they've already made all of the "easy" road improvements -- for example, 101 in the SF Bay Area is pretty much all built in to the center median, so adding new lanes means adding outside lanes (which requires rebuilding every bridge and intersection).

It'd be cheaper, of course, to take an existing lane and convert it to a bus-only lane, but that's politically infeasible.