News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by guiomie on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:04PM (#16208396)
I was wondering about this, why do they sell them instead of mining them? They could sell the older model once the new chips they designed are ready no?
Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by wmf on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:07PM (#16208428)
The cynical answer is that customers are willing to pay more than the hardware will ever mine over its lifetime.

The non-cynical answer is that setting up gigawatts of data centers is not trivial and not Bitmain's core competency. Also, selling the hardware upfront locks in the profit even if the price of Bitcoin later crashes.

Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by baddox on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:36PM (#16208711)
Of course. That's the same non-cynical answer to the question "Why would TSMC sell the hardware instead of mine with it?"
Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by wmf on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:46PM (#16208806)
TSMC also gets some benefits from being neutral; they don't compete with any of their customers. Bitmain has never been neutral.
Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by twohlix_ on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:12PM (#16208480)
Because they can get more money faster by selling the mining units. Mining is not a guaranteed return but selling a unit is. Plus large scale mining requires a large capital risk (electricity), that is compounded with the large capital investment into the hardware.

Plus if they have significant BTC reserves (I believe they do) then selling mining equipment strengthens the BTC network and improves the value, maybe, of their current holdings.

Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by usrusr on Monday January 22, 2018 @08:50PM (#16210181)
This is even more interesting than I thought at first glance: by selling hardware to other miners (for conventional money, I suppose, as that's what they need to pay upstream suppliers like TSMC) they can fund large mining power bills without having to sell their cryptotokens to do so, which would depress the market, which would threaten their whole business. BTC will crash whenever the influx of money into the network is lower than the outflux to power suppliers. Miners can't "hodl" everything when they have power bills to pay. Selling chips to mining investors is a form of inviting new money into the network.
Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by icelancer on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:14PM (#16208496)
Diversification of assets is a real thing at that scale. They don't sell everything, but a balanced approach from conservative (selling mining equipment) to aggressive (mining as much BTC as possible.... and some other political stuff I won't get into) is how Bitmain runs their business. It's smart. You want to balance your ranges.
Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by TeMPOraL on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:30PM (#16208639)
They're literally the ones selling shovels in the Bitcoin gold rush. Seems like a very good strategy. Plus, all the rumors they mine with the hardware a bit before selling, which I tend to believe because it's the obvious thing to do (you earn some BTC plus do the burn-in, which lets you catch defective units early).
Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by tfha on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:49PM (#16208834)
A large percentage of the units shipped in January had clearly been in use for a while prior to shipping.

So to answer your question... they do mine their own hardware, and a lot of it.

Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by nimos on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:11PM (#16208467)
The % of the network they would control would be too high maybe? Fundamentally the value of their product is based on the price of bitcoin. A single miner that gets close to 50% might be seen a a huge risk and drive down the price.
Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by jen729w on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:50PM (#16208840)
Let’s say some party/group gets 51%. Now they “own” the blockchain. Doesn’t its value drop to 0, thereby making the whole effort pointless?

I’m not going to buy BTC (or whatever) from that system, therefore the owners take no cash from it. Yeah they have all the BTC, but so what?

Everyone loses. What am I missing?

Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by usrusr on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:07PM (#16210283)
> What am I missing?

Shorts? Conventional wisdom states that a 51% attack would destroy the very same value it would misappropriate, but when you can bet real money on BTC crumbling you get an entirely different playing field. Still very unlikely as everybody with that kind of hashrate is already rewarded far too handsomely, but if someone ever offers shorts on one of the smaller altcoins, I'd almost expect someone to state an at least cost-neutral attack just for kicks.

Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by nimos on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:56PM (#16209817)
That's my point exactly. They sell them to other people to ensure that doesn't happen.

Now I'm not actually sure if they produce enough for that to be relevant. But my understanding is they dominate the asic market and asics are the only thing that are profitable for mining bitcoin. It could be if they didn't sell and mined themselves they would have enough mining share to cause people to lose faith in the currency and crash the market.

Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by wmf on Monday January 22, 2018 @06:02PM (#16208952)
The movie plot here is to secretly get 51% of the hashrate, cash out a billion-dollar fraud, then walk away. In reality it's unlikely to happen.
Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by paulie_a on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:18PM (#16209559)
If that were possible, it would be a one time thing I am guessing. But it's possible to short bitcoin now I believe. So ruining the network/reputation could be profitable?

I am speculating and don't know for sure.

Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by wmf on Monday January 22, 2018 @08:11PM (#16209924)
You probably can't short a large enough amount to make it worthwhile. Also, due to Murphy's Law the price would probably go up.
Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by icelancer on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:13PM (#16208487)
This is already the de facto case with Jihan. The threat is enough.
Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by dane-pgp on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:56PM (#16209814)
This article from last May says he has influence over 16.4% of blocks:

https://www.investopedia.com/news/who-jihan-wu-and-does-he-b...

Do you have any more recent numbers that tell a different story?

Re:One Bitcoin miner is buying 20,000 16nm wafers from TSMC ... by jcomis on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:07PM (#16208418)
Rumor is they do exactly that...