News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by romanovcode on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:28AM (#16203338)
So basically men and women prefer women to gain tenure in STEM fields as shown in this graph[0]? Can we now close the "no women in stem" meme finally?

[0] - http://www.pnas.org/content/112/17/5360/F1.expansion.html

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by Veen on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:59AM (#16203441)
The study shows that the gender bias at the point of tenure approval is the opposite of what is claimed by some interest groups. That doesn't prove that gender bias isn't a factor in the number of women in STEM fields.

Some fields are majority male, and some fields are majority female. There are two possible causes: that women and men have, on average, different preferences, or that there is a bias problem earlier in the process than the point at which tenure is considered.

There is evidence that men and women do have different preferences and so we'd expect to see a gender imbalance in some fields. But we should still try to ensure that anyone with the ability and the inclination is able to enter the career path of their choice — that means schools, families, and the media not discouraging girls and boys from entering "non-typical" fields, something these studies don't address.

They do, however, show that the way many ideologically motivated individuals go about achieving their aim of gender balance is based on misconceptions about the world and is therefore likely to be counter-productive.

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by tictacttoe on Monday January 22, 2018 @08:39AM (#16204213)
STEM positions have a long pipeline with appreciable attrition along the way. Any losses upstream propagate down stream so it's somewhat obvious that we'd have less women in physics national lab positions if we have less women studying physics in general.

People need to address the issue at each stage of the pipeline. I would argue that early stage imbalances are even more important than late stage imbalances (post-graduate) because upstream imbalances necessarily propagate downstream but not vice versa.

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by majos on Monday January 22, 2018 @08:38AM (#16204207)
I don't think so. I think the everyday experience for female academics still lags behind that of male academics. If you're an undergrad in an unfamiliar hard class it can be tricky to approach a male fellow student without risking misinterpretation of romantic interest; if you're applying to grad school, letter writers are conditioned to talk about women in different ways ("diligent", not "brilliant", maybe); if you're a grad student choosing an advisor, you never really know if the (probably guy) you're choosing has predatory instincts underneath (most don't but enough do); if you're presenting work at a conference, navigating after-conference social activities while being awkwardly hit on gets old fast.

This comes from me talking to friends who are women in CS. It made me realize that as a dude in CS I have an interesting advantage of not being noticed when I walk into a room.

The field has made progress but there are still real frictions that make the everyday experience worse for women, even if the balance has shifted during the big decisions. So it may shake out as an advantage when applying for faculty positions or grad schools, but it's probably not an advantage the rest of the time. I don't think the former compensates very well for the latter.

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by vim_wannabe on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:18AM (#16204464)
>romantic interest

Heh, I don't know about other STEM fields but I remember a lady attending a computer science freshman social event once. There were very few women there as the majority of women in CS are in HTI. After a while she said to my friend, "Why is everyone such a nerd."

She left the field, men were at fault.

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by ikeyany on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:56AM (#16204746)
I'm not sure she's blaming men as much as she's confirming the existence of the culture around tech that non-traditional students (women or blacks/Latinos) feel very alienated from. That doesn't mean she thinks anyone is "to blame".
Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by eli_gottlieb on Monday January 22, 2018 @10:26AM (#16205018)
I don't think we should downvote here. As much as none of us nerds like nerd-punching, we should admit that nerd culture is a distinct thing unto itself, which co-clusters with other demographic factors (especially being middle-class with time for hobbies when you're young), and frankly isn't very welcoming in the adult stages of acculturation.

If we expect people to "enter into" nerd culture to join "nerdy" professions, we're basically expecting people to learn a new language and move into a semi-foreign country just to enter a job field.

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by gaius on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:07AM (#16211625)
If we expect people to "enter into" nerd culture to join "nerdy" professions

You don’t think other professions have cultures?

Good luck with facial piercings and purple hair in Corporate Law, but in software no one would bat an eyelid. The culture you are complaining about is MORE tolerant than nearly all other professions!

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by peoplewindow on Monday January 22, 2018 @10:47AM (#16205223)
"Nerd" isn't a culture anymore than "geekyness" is a culture. It's a pejorative, an insult intended to shame the person it's applied to by suggesting they are slightly disgusting, socially disagreeable, ugly, uninteresting etc.

When the woman turned up to a social event and said, "why are the men such nerds" and walked away, that wasn't the men's fault or problem actually (unless they wanted to date her). That's her problem: she's the one lobbing insults against an entire group despite not knowing the individuals in question. They do not need to do anything to welcome such a person into their "culture" because she wasn't talking about a culture to begin with.

The story given above, assuming the last "men were at fault" statement is related to the first part, is sadly reflective of all the worst stereotypes of young women. The woman in question decided what career to pursue because she didn't want to be seen as hanging out with uncool people during her studies. Guess what - nerds would be happy to hang out with "non nerds" too, if they came to their events and didn't act all judgey and superior. This is not something unique to women, it's rather, that men seem more willing to either embrace it or tolerate it.

Presumably she is now in a field with fewer "nerds", but quite possibly earning less money than if she'd stuck with CS. Too bad for her.

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by cristianpascu on Monday January 22, 2018 @08:54AM (#16204300)
Have you ever considered things that men have to deal with and are not being able to put them in terms of 'being male in the X industry/community/field"?

This is not to minimize anything a woman has to go through, but let's, at least, not compare as if it's on equal terms. If we're able to talk about women issues at all, isn't that because women and men are different? Why compare it so easily and uni-dimensionally?

BTW, what about cases where a woman approaches a man about a technical matter, but with a _romantinc_ interest? Where's the real danger in that? We, as grown ups, should have the tools to dismiss politely romantic interests. It's the same case between men and men/women, as it is between women and women/men. It's part of life. The expression 'unwanted advances' is by far the craziest accusation one could make to a person. Man or woman.

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by linkmotif on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:24AM (#16204508)
A man worries a woman won’t like him. A woman worries a man will kill her.
Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by kentrado on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:31AM (#16204562)
Geez, men are a bunch killers. Why can they be more like women?
Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by megaman22 on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:29AM (#16204553)
The chances of that happening with your typical Dilbertian white male software engineer are vanishingly small.
Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by linkmotif on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:57AM (#16204752)
Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by LeifCarrotson on Monday January 22, 2018 @10:47AM (#16205222)
The parent said that the chances of that happening are vanishingly small. Your source (and your source's source: https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/66/wr/mm6628a1.htm) support that statement:

> The CDC analyzed the murders of women in 18 states from 2003 to 2014, finding a total of 10,018 deaths.

> The overall age-adjusted homicide rate was 2.0 per 100,000 women.

18 states, tens of millions of people, and an inconceivably small number of homicides in reality. The overwhelming majority of women are not murdered by men, but live a long life and die of heart disease, cancer, or other old-age diseases.

Even when you only consider the age range in question - call it 18-64 - the leading causes of death are still unintentional injuries, cancer, heart disease, and suicide: https://www.cdc.gov/women/lcod/2014/all-females/index.htm There is a spike in homicides up to a staggering 7% of all deaths for the 15-24 age group, but that's only because young women almost never die, there's little real danger but an awful lot of fear surrounding this topic.

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by linkmotif on Monday January 22, 2018 @11:51AM (#16205803)
Yes most people die of natural causes.
Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by troupe on Monday January 22, 2018 @12:30PM (#16206144)
Lisa Nowak
Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by romanovcode on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:00AM (#16204340)
People like you are given gold and they will whine it's too heavy.

The graph clearly shows that women are prefered in STEM, what more proof do you need?

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by dang on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:16PM (#16217213)
This crosses into personal attack, which is not allowed on HN. Neither is flamebait, which your comments elsewhere in the thread have crossed into by being handwavey and inflammatory. Would you please stop doing these things? As the site guidelines say: "Comments should get more civil and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive."

You've also posted a bunch of unsubstantive and even uncivil comments in the past, and we've warned you several times before. I don't think you're breaking the site rules on purpose, but we eventually ban accounts that repeatedly do this and don't change when we ask.

If you'd read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and take the spirit of this site more to heart when commenting here, we'd appreciate it.

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by majos on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:29AM (#16204550)
Imagine that you and your friend go to work for company X. You are put in a windowless room with an uncomfortable chair where every half hour a co-worker comes by to ask a brief technical question. Your friend gets a quiet, sunny office and is only interrupted by the meetings he organizes himself. However, management assures you that in light of your less amenable office situation, you will receive an extra 10 points out of 100 on your annual performance review, and your friend will not.

Would you conclude that you are truly "preferred"? Would you rather be in your friend's place? Would you stick around this company at all, even if the work appeals to you?

This is what I mean -- that having an advantage at one step in the process does not necessarily compensate for a negative experience at other steps in the process.

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by lumberjack on Monday January 22, 2018 @08:52AM (#16204288)
None of that stuff is because of bias though. That is just the result of being in a field dominated by the other gender.
Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by linkmotif on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:23AM (#16204496)
Sentence 1:

> None of that stuff is because of bias though.

Sentence 2:

> That is just the result of being in a field dominated by the other gender.

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by heavenlyblue on Monday January 22, 2018 @11:24AM (#16205561)
He's speaking about the boundary conditions, you're just parrotting something you have clearly misunderstood.
Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by linkmotif on Monday January 22, 2018 @08:01PM (#16209861)
Boundary conditions, exactly.
Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by learnstats2 on Monday January 22, 2018 @08:40AM (#16204217)
There are evidently few women in STEM and this data doesn't contradict that.

It's a consequence that hiring practices should favour women who are equally qualified on paper, because they have likely overcome more barriers in practice and, all other things being equal, are better hires.

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by golergka on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:18AM (#16204467)
> It's a consequence that hiring practices should favour women who are equally qualified on paper, because they have likely overcome more barriers in practice and, all other things being equal, are better hires.

I want to argue against this from a purely utilitarian standpoint, where we care about getting better hire, and don't care about any ethical implications. I think your logic is just bad math.

You're right, and women have more barriers to entry into STEM. And if some barriers are already removed (as this study suggest), I can assume that others still exist. Let's make the numbers simpler, and assume that these barriers make it 2 times harder for a given woman to get into some experience level (I don't know real numbers anyway, and they don't matter).

However, when we observe the effect of these barriers, we simply see that there are 2 times more men on that level than women. That's the whole effect. Statistically, if a woman had 2 times less chance of getting through, and there are already 2 times less women than men, then we already see the full effect of this barrier: there's no evidence that there should be some hidden variable to explain this barrier.

However, if we would know that women's barrier makes it 10 times as harder, and still, there are only 2 times as many men as women, then we would need some other data to explain this; namely, that these women are actually 5 times as good as the men.

But we don't know that. The whole knowledge about these barriers that we have comes from the outcome: we see that there are 2 times as many men as women, and that's how we assume (correctly, I think) that there is a barrier. But if we start from this outcome data, we can't through some magic come back to it and add a hidden variable - it's just a logic loop, and a strange one: we see data, make conclusions from observations, and from these conclusions change our observation of this very data to see it as incomplete, without help of any data points outside this original observation. How could such logic be correct?

Re:Experiments reveal faculty preference for women on STEM t... by romanovcode on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:00AM (#16204347)
> should favour women

This is sexism right here.