It would be amazing if McDonalds fully automated their stores and allowed their current employees to work one day a week for the same pay they receive now, but we both know that's not how it would work out.
And it always will be until there is stimulus to change. Government - large systems in general - don't change the other way.
They were completely forgotten by society, government, and the private enterprise as the spoils went to the top 20%.
What about this particular shearing indicates a difference in the way "progress" is made?
Maybe because our society isn’t ready for such changes. The American system especially lacks safety nets and social security systems to support those without a job. The way things are now is that one needs to have a job to be able to “play”.
One solution would be to tax the robots that replace the working class. Otherwise the only ones to gain are the ones who own the robots.
Our society has been killing jobs with automation for the past 150 years or so. Think of all the jobs that don’t exist anymore because of your fridge, dishwasher, washing machine, car, etc. Before alarm clocks, people used to get paid to go yell in front of your house for 10 minutes until you got up. Before cars, there were tons of people living off horses as a transportation medium. Before automatic doors in the trains there was one employee in each coach to close them. Pretty much every complex object you touch nowadays has killed jobs when it first appeared.
So, now when people are all out there 'playing', the ones enabling the playing still have to work. Good luck encouraging people that is a good idea, when they could just quit and go play themselves.
because people lose jobs and then they elect people who promise to bring back jobs.
This sounds like a "Let them eat cake" response. What do you propose is the solution then for giving these people a viable lifestyle if they don't have any competitive skills? A lot of potential ideas, like basic income, have been discussed on HN, but this should be considered a pretty scary problem because there aren't any immediately obvious solutions.
How about a future where the masses live like Amish, but with more free time. Sure you can play... but exactly what does that mean is a different question. I imagine housing developments in rural areas that cost very little and very little economic activity takes place there. Like for instance say small houses for 1 or 2 people for $25k in the middle of nowhere which you can support on your 20k minimum income. Place provides very few municipal services as well to keep the costs down.
But it’s certainly being viewed as a costsaving measure by Amazon.
Why is this the knee-jerk response to technological progress?
True progress isn't forcing millions of people into low-wage routine work. True progress would emancipate people from this drudgery entirely.
Isaac Asimov questioned why the goal of both the left and the right is always "full employment":
"The goal of the future should be full unemployment, so we can play. That’s why we have to destroy the present politico-economic system."