It's like saying nobody should start a new company cause "best case they'll be another evil surveillance company like Google/Facebook/Microsoft/Amazon, worst case they'll lose all their money."
Think of it as the full-employment theorem for entrepreneurs, or the social-mobility conveyor belt, or the way in which society stays dynamic & responsive. At least savvy customers get a decade of decent service at reasonable prices, and people (from all backgrounds!) with chutzpah and persistence have a shot at becoming fabulously wealthy.
> people (from all backgrounds!) with chutzpah and persistence have a shot
Economic mobility is lower that what most people think across developed countries and it's decreasing.
There's so little benefit to competition with generics, you may as well have that vertical integration to at least provide what hospitals need.
It's not quite the same as manufacturing it themselves, but the bulk buying does bring the price down quite substantially.
Look up the 340B program and mandatory Medicaid rebates. They add up to huge discounts.
In most cases Medicaid pays the lowest price of any customer and Medicare often pays the same as private insurers.
It's a fallacy to say the gov't is getting screwed over by not negotiating over drug prices.
As for a proper analysis of your question, I'm not sure that data is available. Net prices in the US are confidential.
>Country-owned means of production have usually not fared well vs competitive forces in the past
Currently in the exact markets being discussed ISP markets are in a similar situation. If you look at municipal broadband providers, they has fared very well - providing better service (fiber) for lower costs while protecting the public interest by opting in to net neutrality. Outside of ideological concerns it's hard for me to the problem with the government intervening in stagnant markets by competing directly.
If my town wants to have its own fire department, it’s not “unfair” to privately owned fire departments anymore than working on my own car is “unfair” to professional mechanics.
The root of the problem with American drug companies is that they're insulated from open market competition by a government approvals process that costs billions--only a few companies have enough money to take a new drug to market. The government could reform this process but chooses not to, claiming it's necessary for consumer safety (certainly some kind of approvals process is).
Now if you wanted to setup a nationalized producer, put a "chinese wall" between it and the State and force it to compete without subsidies or special (favourable) regulations, sure, go for it. But then what's the advantage of it being nationalized to begin with? Anybody could start a non-profit corporation and do the same thing.