News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by derefr on Thursday January 18, 2018 @02:49PM (#16180669)
Even old computer chips were magic. Really, photolithography is magic—it jumped us way ahead in our ability to miniaturize. It really seems like the kind of thing that, in fiction, would be introduced to a culture by aliens.

I've always wondered: could we have discovered/invented photolithography earlier, and thereby started the integrated-circuit revolution earlier? As far as I can tell, there was nothing holding someone back from inventing it in the 1800s, even: they had access to all the relevant chemicals, and (in some countries) lenses were already precision-ground enough to serve the purpose down to some pretty tiny process-nodes. We wouldn't have had digital logic (no transistors), but we could have been making "electronic" watches, tiny AC-to-DC power converters, and other analogue ICs even back then.

But heck: suppose we had known the principles behind semiconductive materials back then, too. We could have passed right by the vacuum-tube era and started in on inventing digital ICs (and boolean algebra.) What could the 1800s have looked like then?

(Is there any well-known science-fiction story exploring this premise? I might give a shot to writing it, if not...)

Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by jabl on Thursday January 18, 2018 @04:04PM (#16181434)
Well, in the 1800s steam locomotives were considered to be awesome high-tech. The famous HMS Rattler vs. Alecto trial which proved the superiority of propellers over paddles for ship propulsion was in 1845.

Even on the basic science level, Maxwell published his seminal treatise on classical electromagnetism in 1873, and it wasn't until 1881 that Heaviside published them in the form we know them today and that sort-of made people understand them. Semiconductors were sort-of known already in the early 1800s, but it wasn't until the, say, first half of the 20th century when we really started to understand them with the development of solid state physics (both theoy and experimental methods such as x-ray diffraction etc.).

So yes, while some aspects of lithography could have been developed in the 1800s, I think there was quite a huge gap between that and a whole lot of other things needed.

Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday January 18, 2018 @06:52PM (#16182772)
We didn't have the semiconductor science needed to make effective ICs until we started building them.

The logic is relatively easy, but the materials science needed to decide what to lithograph, using which materials, and in what order, is post-WWII, and probably couldn't have been invented much earlier.

It takes a lot of work to work out ideal doping factors and diffusion rates, estimate charge distributions across junctions, calculate propagation speeds, and eliminate leakage.

But more - the chemistry of semiconductor doping and deposition is often rather nasty, and it would have been a huge challenge to industrialise it before WWII.

Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by avs733 on Thursday January 18, 2018 @10:15PM (#16183879)
I think this is a pretty reasonable answer...summed up, you could have all the steps but you were missing two things:

1) the theoretical knowledge of how the devices worked, which enabled the creation of steps in the process that resulted in fully working devices

2) the ability do do each step repeatably and precisely and reliably.

Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by Taniwha on Friday January 19, 2018 @12:55AM (#16184405)
well most chips these days are done with FETs which don't really need semiconductors in the way we usually think about them ... and FETs were invented (and largely forgotten) before bipolar transistors ... but doped semiconductors does make it easy to make FETs
Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by sehugg on Friday January 19, 2018 @12:45AM (#16184377)
We didn't even have a practical vacuum tube AND gate until 1930, and a formal treatment of logic design until 1936-1937. It's doubtful the need for ICs was well understood. And they would be expensive until there was a big enough market to produce them at scale.
Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by philipkglass on Thursday January 18, 2018 @08:14PM (#16183249)
IMO there were enough critical precursor technologies to start making discrete semiconductor devices from silicon by about the late 1920s, had a large industrial backer known the useful properties of such devices. They had most of the pieces for "how" by then but didn't discover the "why" until a generation later. And of course people spent a lot of time pursuing dead ends before discovering which industrial techniques would successfully combine to make silicon suitable for semiconductor devices, with properties surprisingly different from silicon of only 99.5% purity.

- The electric arc furnace, from the late 19th century, enabled the large scale production of crude silicon.

- The crystal bar process, from 1925, is similar to the Siemens process developed in the 1950s for refining purified volatile silicon compounds to electronic-purity elemental silicon.

- The Czochralski process, from 1915, permitted the growth of large single crystals of purified silicon.

There's a great review article from 1981, available through sci-hub, if you want more details about the history of purified silicon electronic devices:

"Twenty Five Years of Semiconductor-Grade Silicon"

DOI: 10.1002/pssa.2210640102

Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by workthrowaway27 on Thursday January 18, 2018 @03:37PM (#16181149)
I don't think there was much incentive to make things smaller before the transistor was invented. Also, transistors are used in most analog electronics. You can't do much without them since they let you amplify signals and apply negative feedback.

But to answer your second question. I don't think we could have skipped the vacuum-tube era. It's because we already had applications for those sorts of electronics (and unreliable mechanical relays that were replaced with transistor switches) that researchers realized the potential for transistors in the first place. Even after the transistor was invented there was still a lot of research necessary to make them feasible in practice. The first one was germanium if I recall correctly and it took a while before silicon transistors were viable.

Edit: Also, sort of unrelated, non silicon semiconductors are still used a lot because they can switch faster, and different color LEDs use different semiconductors because they emit different colors of light, which is also related to why different color LEDs have different voltage drops.

Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by dfox on Thursday January 18, 2018 @03:48PM (#16181279)
One thing that everybody seems to glance over is that photolitography made manufacturing of discrete transistors practical and the step to integrated circuits is not that big from that.

Edit: what you buy as a typical discrete transistor is in fact integrated circuit which contains tens to thousands of parallel connected transistors.

Also I believe that photolitography-like processes were used before semiconductors (and I would not be too surprised if production of at least some mass manufactured valves involved photolitography).

Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by dmitrygr on Thursday January 18, 2018 @05:38PM (#16182271)
This is true for FETs but not for BJTs
Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by dfox on Thursday January 18, 2018 @05:48PM (#16182358)
I originally intended to use IRF640 as an example, as for HexFET it is painfully obvious that there are separate parallel connected transistors.

For typical BJTs it depends on how you define "separate transistor". The structure in typical BJT has one contiguos junction, but its geometry is non-trivial enough that you can well think of it as multiple paralleled transistors.

Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by jdietrich on Friday January 19, 2018 @12:06AM (#16184250)
I can highly recommend this documentary from 1943, which shows the manufacturing of piezoelectric quartz crystals. The amount of skilled manual labor involved in the process is quite staggering.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b--FKHCFjOM

Photolithography in general substantially pre-dates the development of the IC. We were using it to produce printing plates in the 19th century. Breakthroughs in chemistry made photolithographic PCB manufacture possible by the early 1940s. It took us another 20 years and a huge array of discoveries and inventions to finally start producing useful ICs.

Development of IC manufacturing required a very broad tech tree - better chemistry, better optics, better materials science, better process engineering and, most crucially, the invention of p-n junctions. Without the p-n junction, any effort to etch a practical integrated circuit is pretty much futile.

Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by amelius on Thursday January 18, 2018 @03:13PM (#16180898)
Don't know what you mean by analogue ICs without semiconductors.

Anyway, perhaps the problem was more that (almost) nobody back then saw the potential of this technology.

Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by InclinedPlane on Thursday January 18, 2018 @06:24PM (#16182590)
Think about a PCB except at micro-chip scale. If you don't have semi-conductor technology you can still lay down layers of metal using photolithography, and thus making tiny circuits. I'm not sure what the limits are of such technology but it seems interesting.
Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday January 18, 2018 @04:39PM (#16181746)
> What could the 1800s have looked like then?

If it happened before the Battle of Jena, we might have found ourselves in a world of technologically-ensconced monarchies.

Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by leggomylibro on Thursday January 18, 2018 @05:00PM (#16181913)
Hey now, we still might.
Re:Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Comput... by afandian on Friday January 19, 2018 @01:02PM (#16188269)
It's not exactly what you're looking for but in that vein The End of the World has a similar theme.