A lot of China's GDP growth is tied up in asset growth (e.g. appreciated real estate). So if/when that bubble pops, they will take a hit. Accordingly, in the Chinese news, they talk about supporting and nurturing what they call the "real economy" as a counter to that danger.
The numbers are insane. In the US, we move 11x in our lifetimes of ~80y aka 13% of our population moves each year. Apply that average to China and you're looking at 170m migrants annually. And unlike US (a lot of urban to urban), in China there's a gigantic one-way rural->urban traffic, i.e., two people aren't switching urban houses and calling it 'moving', two people are leaving behind a rural home and needing an entirely newly built urban home.
How do you accommodate that many people in new homes. Do you start building homes only after they're needed? Or do you build some capacity at a surplus, to cover expected growth?
Probably the latter. It isn't much different from any company stocking surplus inventory. That's not an immediate indication of a failure of economics and a bubble.
And do you only build in existing popular cities and just try to add to the periphery, or do you build-up new cities? Probably the latter, too.
Plenty of other countries do it as well. Incheon developed very much due to overdevelopment in Seoul. Or here in the Netherlands, we now have close 0.8m people living in so called Vinexwijken. They're a development centered on a new ordinance concerning housing development between 1995 and 2005. Since 1995 our population grew by 1.6m or so, apparently half our growth went to these new locations created out of nothing. And we always have discussions about structural emptiness, big malls being built and remaining 75% empty for years. But the scale is smaller, the country is 75x smaller than China. We had issues with structural vacancy rates at a new 100k 'village', scale that up to 75x and you have a similar story. Yet the biggest ghosttown in China ia Ordos, planned for 1 million people, scaled back and built for 'only' 300k, and currently houses more than 100k and climbing. That's what is consistently called the biggest ghost town in China. For Chinese, both the size of the project as well as the timeframe (10 years of vacancy) is a rounding error.
Don't get me wrong, there's definitely an asset bubble. But we've also been saying that for who knows how many years and I feel we tend to focus too much on symbolism of the ghost town narrative.
This comic describes it very well: https://goo.gl/GAn5fi
What has changed?[1] I would argue that this neither confirms nor refutes your defense of the "paper tiger" assertion.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Russia#/media/File:...
- that huge stack of nukes
- the ruthlessness of its mostly autocratic leader(s)
Neither of those bode well for their future... ("it's the economy, stupid", and all that).
But in recent years their government has started a program aimed at transferring some of the coastal activity inland.
How effective that will be is hard to tell, but there are already interesting stories of hotels that have entrances on multiple floors because the city was funded in a valley between multiple hills. End result is that new roads go between the hills on bridges, passing right by the hotel. Sounds like one crazy place to live.
BTW, i believe the city in question is Chongqing. But sadly i didn't keep a bookmark of the story itself.
https://www.mhprofessional.com/9781259644580-usa-chinas-guar...
His blog is still up, but unfortunately he switched from blogging to Tweeting in 2013 and it's been impossible to follow his train of thought since then. It's a pretty fascinating read (assuming you find dry economic posts fascinating) if you start sometime around the 2009 entries and go from there: https://chovanec.wordpress.com/
Some of the ones I found most interesting:
Beijing’s Bad Debt Bailout: Problem Solved? https://chovanec.wordpress.com/2011/06/02/beijings-bad-debt-...
Big Losses Hidden on China’s Bank Balance Sheets: https://chovanec.wordpress.com/2009/09/23/big-losses-hidden-...
Even though they're almost a decade old they still give you an interesting look into how things work in China.