News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by uptownfunk on Monday January 08, 2018 @12:50AM (#16094917)
I have to say, as someone who studied Sanskrit grammar in the paninian system, and also mathematics in University how mathematical the Paninian grammar is, incredibly algebraic. Prefixes and suffixes combine to change and modify words, words can be joined together to create new words. Though I’m sure these features are found in other languages.

Another interesting note is that Vedic mantras are sometimes traditionally learnt and recited in what is known as a Ghana patha. If i were to number the words in a sentence, “The cow jumped over the moon” as 1 2 3 4 5 6 and then if I were to recite the sentence now permuting the words as 1 2 2 1 1 2 3 3 2 1 1 2 3,, 2 3 3 2 2 3 4 4 3 2 2 3 4.... The complexity increases. This is because words can be joined together in Sanskrit. Furthermore each letter in Vedic Sanskrit has three ways of pronouncing it (similar to the Chinese four accents) and these can change as you permute and apply the sandhi rules as well.

I haven’t seen such complexity in other languages (though it’s possible it may exist) but such complexity is why it wouldn’t surprise me that the effect could possibly be specific to Sanskrit.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by murukesh_s on Monday January 08, 2018 @04:49AM (#16095701)
The study hasn't concluded it is specific to Sanskrit. As it is difficult to obtain a sample close to the number resembling people chanting and memorising verses from such a young age for several hours a day.

Previous studies involving other brain activities have shown improvement in grey matter before, for e.g. London Taxi driver in one study showed improvement in brain development.

https://www.wired.com/2011/12/london-taxi-driver-memory/

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by rnabel on Monday January 08, 2018 @08:36AM (#16096578)
A good book on this topic, which discusses this particular study is "Peak: Secrets from the New Science of Expertise" by Ericsson and Pool.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by satish-setty on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:15AM (#16094987)
> Vedic Sanskrit has three ways of pronouncing it (similar to the Chinese four accents)

Just a nitpick: Vedic Sanskrit has pitch accent, not tone. Chinese is tonal. And I'm a huge fan of ghana patha as well!

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by pen2l on Monday January 08, 2018 @03:43AM (#16095473)
I was really sad the article didn’t have a video of the hymns it spoke of, I’m similarly really interested now w in seeing an example of pitch accent you speak of in action, could you please link a video which you feel shows it well in play? Thanks!
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by tmp1029384756 on Monday January 08, 2018 @05:57AM (#16095944)
for something truly mindblowing, try sanskrit trance!

shanti people - tandava (david garry x dion 2017 club edit) https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=8w3R5yEBhcY

shanti people - mahishasura mardini (droplex remix) https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4em0Wh8ZgR0

it is a ukrainian group i believe, the singer gets very little pronounciation 'off', atleast in these two vids

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by uptownfunk on Monday January 08, 2018 @04:24AM (#16095628)
Sure, here is an example of the rudram chanted in ghanam mode, there is a brief example given in the beginning similar to what i explained in my above comment. This is from the yajur Veda I believe, some scholars date these chants close to 3000 years old. https://youtu.be/5VP-NTPEjGg
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by ing33k on Monday January 08, 2018 @12:10PM (#16098142)
Another video, 103 year old Ambattur Ganapadigal chanting ghanam:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=seCJU0zwHpY

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by uptownfunk on Monday January 08, 2018 @08:35PM (#16102731)
A ghanam of the famous “Tamaso ma jyotir gamaya” of the ancient brihadaranyaka.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by PavlikPaja on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @03:40PM (#16109831)
Some preserved forms of vedic sanskrit have three tones - high, low and falling, which makes it tonal.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by adrianratnapala on Monday January 08, 2018 @06:01PM (#16101705)
It would not surprise me if Sanskrit had some odd features, because Sanskrit as we know it is derived from the language of the ancient hymns.

For about 1000 years before writing starts in India, we have the language developing in the hands of bards singing for ritual reasons to audiences which increasingly could not understand the words. So for many centuries it was evolving under pressures very different from normal language.

Eventually, it regained broader application, but still a an elite language and thus still had unusual evolutionary pressures.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by reallymental on Monday January 08, 2018 @03:31AM (#16095427)
I'm really curious to know, how you came about to study Sanskrit grammar in the Paninian system, that and how did you break from that into mathematics?. Can you expand on that?

My email is in my profile if you'd prefer to tell me more about this offline.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by dtornabene on Monday January 08, 2018 @03:51AM (#16095502)
from my own (limited!) understanding the first recorded instances of what we would now call combinatorics was Sanskrit linguistics. I don't have a reference handy but theres been a fair amount of historical scholarly work on this.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by QAPereo on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:33AM (#16095040)
That quality of a language is known as agglutination, and I wonder if other such languages would confer similar benefits?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agglutination

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by thro1237 on Sunday January 07, 2018 @08:22PM (#16093968)
Given that people who memorize sanskrit hymns typically come from a single caste (with limited intermarriage between castes), the control should just include the members of that caste (but who don't memorize hymns) - to account for genetic effects. And as another commenter pointed out, this doesn't prove anything about Sanksrit. To prove something like that, the authors should have compared brain sizes with people who memorize other non-sanskrit texts.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by DrBazza on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:24AM (#16095013)
How about London Black Cab drivers who learn "The Knowledge"? http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-16086233

"Earlier studies of the brain of the cabbie had already noted the increase in "grey matter" in the hippocampus, an area found at the base of the brain."

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by murukesh_s on Monday January 08, 2018 @04:49AM (#16095703)
Yea, exactly..
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by f42z on Sunday January 07, 2018 @09:25PM (#16094194)
A substantial group that memorizes a foreign-language (to many) text are Muslim huffaz, who commit the entire Koran to memory. They'd make a good comparison group, given their large numbers, ethnic heterogeneity and worldwide distribution.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by ketralnis on Sunday January 07, 2018 @09:36PM (#16094253)
Or The Knowledge, where London cab drivers have to memorise the whole of London’s streets
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by gumby on Sunday January 07, 2018 @10:15PM (#16094387)
It is well attested that licensed London taxicab drivers (those with “the knowledge”) do in fact end up with different brain structure.

I haven’t seen any studies of what they might give up in the process, though it does involve a lot of sitting.

Example: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/london-taxi-memor...

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by YeGoblynQueenne on Sunday January 07, 2018 @10:50PM (#16094516)
Wow. I didn't know about that.

Kind of casts the whole dispute with Uber thing into a whole different light, doesn't it?

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by gumby on Monday January 08, 2018 @12:04AM (#16094770)
Does it? A machine can indeed do a better job (in the sense of requiring negligible training) of knowing all the streets and democratized “the knowledge” which previously was the purview of a small guild.

I am sorry for their sunk cost, but really minicabs+gps and now uber/Lyft et al are as good, or would be if taxis didn’t have a pick up monopoly.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by Pamar on Monday January 08, 2018 @03:15AM (#16095368)
From previous articles on "the knowledge" I believe that no, a machine cannot really do "better" or not yet, at least.

IIRC at the exam you could get questions like "The passenger tells you that his cousin mentioned a building with a bas-relief of Holy Mary holding Jesus, it was right around the angle from his hotel, but he does not remember the hotel's name".

You are supposed to know the place and the best way to get there, based on just this (also, a good number of "knowledgeable" taxi drivers go for an official London Tour Guide exam soon after, with relatively little effort, considering they have already memorized thousands of places, monuments and architectural details).

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by eru on Monday January 08, 2018 @06:29AM (#16096062)
Untrained driver + Google Maps sits on a different point on the cost / benefit curve than Driver-with-the-Knowledge.

Different customers might prefer different total packages on different occasions.

I for one rarely need the more expensive Driver-with-the-Knowledge option, especially when I can ask Google many of the same questions.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by Pamar on Monday January 08, 2018 @09:02AM (#16096741)
I may concede that it can perform “adequately at a lower price point” (I use Google myself when I am not in my hometown), but the parent wasn’t talking about price.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by eru on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:18AM (#16105913)
I went off the phrase "A machine can indeed do a better job [..]" and was seeing the price as a big part of that package.

Looks we agree about everything that we actually made explicit. The disagreement was about the implicit meaning of whether price was included in the meaning of 'better job'.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by jdietrich on Monday January 08, 2018 @08:30AM (#16096541)
The Knowledge has a very important secondary effect - it creates a huge sunk cost, vastly increasing the downside of losing your license. Getting a green badge takes three to four years of full-time study. You can lose it for relatively minor offences like short-changing a passenger or taking a tourist on the scenic route. Hackney cab drivers with a green badge have a far stronger incentive to do business honestly than a minicab or Uber driver.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by YeGoblynQueenne on Monday January 08, 2018 @06:21AM (#16096028)
>> Does it? A machine can indeed do a better job (in the sense of requiring negligible training) of knowing all the streets and democratized “the knowledge” which previously was the purview of a small guild.

A theoretical machine could do a better job. In practice, we can't build anything that can reason about routes anywhere near as well as London cabbies do. And I'd say that even without knowing about The Knowledge.

Pamar's comment above has a very good example of the kind of thing "a machine" is still very, very far from achieving.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by jacobush on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:56AM (#16095117)
It certainly CAN but a regular GPS just sucks compared to the Knowledge.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by carlmr on Monday January 08, 2018 @03:16AM (#16095373)
With enough driving experience even with GPS you'll learn enough about some of the cases where you can know better.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by jacobush on Monday January 08, 2018 @04:20AM (#16095615)
People can learn, of course. I'm just saying that a an ever changing score of Uber drivers will not be comparable to drivers with "the Knowledge". Any other claim feels preposterous to me.

This can of course be replicated with a computer, but a simple GPS is not going to cut it. Advanced machine learning, voice recognition like nothing I have ever seen, very good A.I. to resolve misunderstandings about where tourists and other non frequent travellers might really want to go instead of where they actually said. And so on and so on. We can get there. An underpaid, recently started and soon to be replaced, stressed uber driver in his uncles car armed with a GPS app is just not going to cut it. Yet.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by eru on Monday January 08, 2018 @06:30AM (#16096066)
Forcing people to pay for the gold-plated service of the Knowledge seems like a bit trade-off though.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by DanBC on Monday January 08, 2018 @06:34AM (#16096082)
They're not forced to pay for it. They can use other private hire cabs if they don't want a taxi with a driver with the knowledge.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by eru on Monday January 08, 2018 @06:49AM (#16096125)
Are they allowed to hail from the street?
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by DanBC on Monday January 08, 2018 @07:16AM (#16096217)
No, if you want to hail from the street you need a taxi.

Uber doesn't allow hailing from the street either.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by vageli on Monday January 08, 2018 @08:11AM (#16096441)
How dissimilar is roadside hailing from hailing a cab in-app to your exact location?
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by eru on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:15AM (#16105891)
Thanks to ubiquitous smart phones these days, they are near substitutes. It didn't use to be that way.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by afsina on Monday January 08, 2018 @02:41AM (#16095263)
When I was young I had a chance to meet two very young huffaz (we say hafız) candidate. They were probably around 10 to 12 years old. What fascinating was, they did not know any Arabic and memorize almost more than a full page a day continuously. I remember them as very calm and nice kids. Also for the context, there are around 77.000 words in Koran.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by Ar-Curunir on Monday January 08, 2018 @12:03AM (#16094764)
While it's traditionally the Brahmin caste that memorizes Vedic hymns, there's plenty of genetic diversity even within the caste, which is spread across 10s of millions of people in very different parts of India.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by thro1237 on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:35AM (#16095047)
May be, but there might be enough differences between castes as opposed to within a caste. The control should be as close to the experimental group as possible. Finding a control group from the same caste is inexpensive.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by subroutine on Sunday January 07, 2018 @11:13PM (#16094594)
This is precisely what I was thinking. Something interesting that I hadn't thought of before is that we now actually live in a time where genome sequencing has become cheap enough that low-N studies (like those in MRI/fMRI-based studies) can actually begin to participant-match based on genetic background. This might become the new gold standard!
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by adrianN on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:16AM (#16094991)
Sequencing might become cheap enough to do that, but our understanding of the functions of the different genes is so lacking that I don't think a lot of meaningful data can be extracted for most studies' subjects.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by subroutine on Monday January 08, 2018 @07:48AM (#16096336)
I don't think we necessarily need to know the function of the genes in order to create a participant matching paradigm that is better than what is being employed currently. For example we can get a more precise snapshot of ancestry using sequencing than simply relying on self-reported 'race'. Also I don't think it needs to be a perfect match; simply stating that controls matched case participants within X percent ancestry would be a useful statistic to report in the methods.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by jdietrich on Monday January 08, 2018 @08:35AM (#16096569)
We don't necessarily understand the functions of genes, but we're starting to establish strong correlations through genome-wide association studies.

https://www.biorxiv.org/content/early/2017/09/06/184853.1

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by tmp1029384756 on Monday January 08, 2018 @06:27AM (#16096053)
since the book 'battle for sanskrit' by rajiv malhotra came out more hindus are now aware of efforts by various groups to denigrate sanskrit as an 'oppressive' language used to control the masses

this is funny because the British actually did that exactly with imposition of english education to create the obedient clerk class for their colony, and claimed it was in fact liberation

and then the germans claimed sanskrit was theirs and could not possibly be of indian local origin and nazi-fied the 'aryan' language

and of course no european scholar could countenance the possibility of hindu epics like the ramayana and mahabharata let alone the vedas could be older than the homeric epics of greek civilization and conveniently 'dated' all indian history to preserve their superiority

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by newen on Monday January 08, 2018 @10:01AM (#16097132)
That's probably people pissed off that they have to learn their mother tongue, english, and hindi to get around in india.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by svat on Monday January 08, 2018 @02:00AM (#16095126)
The article is about “India's Vedic Sanskrit pandits [who] train for years”. For anyone who wants a glimpse of what this training (or the result of the training) looks like, there are some great videos on YouTube:

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ALEHkgOx8EE “Embodying the Vedas - A day in the Śrī Kṛṣṇayajurveda Pāṭhaśālā” (The article mentions the closely related Shukla Yajurveda.) (Examples of the training are from 00:00 to 00:55, from 04:59 to 05:35, from 08:00 to 09:08, from 11:15 to 13:40.)

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ruuPbvViOe4 “Glimpses of the current status of Vedic tradition in Kerala” (Examples of the training are from 00:00 to 03:44, from 08:45 to 12:57, from 13:15 to 14:46)

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CZbpPAjukHI “Champakaapura Veda Paathashale” (Examples are from 06:35 to 07:43, etc.)

(These three from this playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL63uIhJxWbgjpQhSwfAmS... ; click around for more.)

If you look at the age at which students start, theories like “people with strong verbal memories will choose to memorize mantras” (proposed in another comment) are easy to discard. Of course, other statistical effects are still possible, such as selection bias (people who do not have or develop the needed memory may abandon training, etc).

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by dude01 on Sunday January 07, 2018 @08:25PM (#16093982)
I just recently learned that Sanskrit was the first language to have its grammar formally specified. Pāṇini in the 4th century BCE wrote down the complete one. I couldn't find a good translation of it online. I suppose translating a grammar written in the language itself is tough.

I was curious because I want to know how much of BNF grammar functionality is represented in it. Perhaps BNF is just a rediscovering/reformatting of the Sanskrit grammar?

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by thaumasiotes on Sunday January 07, 2018 @11:08PM (#16094579)
> I just recently learned that Sanskrit was the first language to have its grammar formally specified. Pāṇini in the 4th century BCE wrote down the complete one.

People can say this, but that won't make it true. There are unexaggerated 100% odds that what Pāṇini specified was not a complete description of the speech of his time or any other point in history, just as no complete description of any modern language exists today. It's not for lack of scholastic effort; the idea of completely specifying a human language isn't even well defined.

> I want to know how much of BNF grammar functionality is represented in it. Perhaps BNF is just a rediscovering/reformatting of the Sanskrit grammar?

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B003GUBIJ8/ describes the style in which Pāṇini's rules are written. (I'm not saying this is the best source to answer that question, just that it's a book I've read and its description is probably enough for your purposes.)

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by srean on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:03AM (#16094957)
> There are unexaggerated 100% odds that what Pāṇini specified was not a complete description of the speech of his time or any other point in history

That is an odd claim to make because Sanskrit was not a language of day to day speech. Those would be the vernaculars of the time. Sanskrit was very much a crafted language used for much more formal purposes.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by thaumasiotes on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:32AM (#16095038)
Formal languages are just the vernacular of far away or long ago. They're not invented for the purpose, they're preserved.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by throwaway312331 on Monday January 08, 2018 @02:35AM (#16095246)
> That is an odd claim to make because Sanskrit was not a language of day to day speech.

This is what many folk in Universities want us to believe, but having seen day-to-day language used and taught, I don't think it is, or was ever true. Apparently even the devadasis knew it extremely well back in the day, much as did people from many other 'backward' 'castes'.

It's almost as if a school of people want the tradition dead, because its staying alive is too... erm... worrying ? Lots of complicated power structures hang in the balance, as India's tortuously chooses between its past and the past its master want it to have / have had.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by srean on Monday January 08, 2018 @02:49AM (#16095285)
> ... or was ever true

This needs a reputable citation. What an anonymous user personally thinks about it is hardly relevant.

By the way, knowing a language is very different from use in day to day speech.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by throwaway312331 on Monday January 08, 2018 @03:21AM (#16095396)
> This needs a reputable citation. What an anonymous user personally thinks about it is hardly relevant.

Fair enough. Here's the interview with Shatavadhani R. Ganesh from where I get my tidbits.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xQ2EkrXBy4&list=PL54675312C...

> By the way, knowing a language is very different from use in day to day speech.

I know the difference. Have you ever visited Sanskrit universities/gurukulas in India ? It's simply magical. Sanskrit is taught in the language itself, and students chat with their teachers and amongst themselves in the language. This made me very happy!

This is even acknowledged on various Indology mailing lists, where the western scholars note this, often rather bitterly, often peppering the immediately following sentence with generic insults and racist disdain.

Apologies for getting political here, but I've never understood why the field is so hostile to India (British origins ?). East Asia departments by comparison are filled with Sinophiles/Japanophiles.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by srean on Monday January 08, 2018 @03:36AM (#16095446)
Thanks for the video, where is the claim that Sanskrit was a language for day to day speech made. A paper makes it easier than a video.

> I know the difference. Have you ever visited Sanskrit universities/gurukulas in India ?

A personal magical experience has little to do with the fact in contention here -- was Sanskrit a language for day to day conversation among the commons.

Very little in your comment speaks to that claim, nothing in fact, except may be some part of the video. Whether Sanskrit can be picked up as a spoken language by motivated people is not the point of contention. I can point you to many communities that speak in a language that was never used as a language of day to day speech by the commons.

On whether I have visited a Sanskrit university -- Does having a close family member as a Prof in Sanskrit count ?

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by throwaway312331 on Monday January 08, 2018 @04:33AM (#16095652)
> A paper makes it easier than a video.

Alas, most traditional scholars don't really bother writing papers (atleast, not in English AFAIK).

> Very little in your comment speaks to that claim, nothing in fact, except may be some part of the video.

You're correct. I don't work in the field, but a quick Google search threw this up.

https://books.google.co.jp/books?id=NDrqaELkKTEC&pg=PA38&lpg...

I'm sure if one were inclined, one could find more material.

> Whether Sanskrit can be picked up as a spoken language by motivated people is not the point of contention. I can point you to many communities that speak in a language that was never used as a language of day to day speech by the commons.

Fair enough. That said, what kind of evidence would 'prove' the said proposition ? Is there evidence to the contrary which would fit this standard ?

Latin for instance, may not have been spoken in its classical form, but the vulgar form is believed to have been widely spoken.

Similarly, if someone were given freedom to ontologically ground my words (say, 'common' == '> 1e4, of various diversities'; 'sanskrit' == 'paninian grammar'), merely to prove me wrong, the game is not worth playing (which circles back to my first point).

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by srean on Monday January 08, 2018 @05:16AM (#16095794)
Non English publication would be fine. Its the review process that matters.

I have no problems believing that a colloquial form of Sanskrit was spoken, that would be the very definition of a vernacular. A situation not different from the Latin example you gave.

Records of a direct quote of a protagonist who is commoner, in literature or preferably in royal records etc would be acceptable evidence. Otherwise how can one differentiate it from claims that humans rode dinosaurs with wings.

BTW I don't disagree with you when you state there is a bias against such subject matter (you can look up the issue of Taylor's expansion of trigonometric functions by the Kerala school of mathematicians much before Newton). The way to address this would be do counter that with proper research results and processes.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by dude01 on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:27PM (#16098664)
Thanks for the book recommendation. Too bad the reviews of the electronic version are terrible (apparently terribly scanned/converted, not content issues).
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by neel_k on Sunday January 07, 2018 @10:55PM (#16094541)
Panini's grammar is closest to an instance of a Post canonical system. It is basically a set of general rewriting rules, with features going beyond BNF in power.

This is for pretty much the same reason that the grammatical formalisms modern linguists use also go beyond BNF. Linguists are interested in issues of grammaticality that actually do need context (such as subject-verb agreement) and so obviously context-free grammars can't do the whole job!

(For a programming example, you can see type correctness as a case of how well-formedness of programs depends on context -- whether a variable can be used in an expression depends on its type.)

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by sriku on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:40AM (#16095068)
Panini covered both the grammar in the regular sense as well as the phonology of the language. "Optimality theory" attempts to model phonology as a collection of violable constraints operating with a least violation principle. It is supposed to be more generally applicable to what we normally know as grammar (dealings at the words/phrases level), but has seen most success with phonology.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by dude01 on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:31PM (#16098682)
Thank you, that makes sense.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by uptownfunk on Monday January 08, 2018 @12:36AM (#16094869)
Generally people don’t approach panini vyakaran directly but rather through a text such as the siddhanta kaumudi or laghu siddhanta kaumudi which are the panini sutras reordered with the ancient commentaries of patanjali and katyayan.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by formyread3 on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:37AM (#16095056)
As someone who read some of these scriptures mentioned here , they are always cited from memory. When we were taught , it is usually the teacher reciting once and the students reciting again with 2 repeats. Usually it starts with one word at a time , then by joining 2 together , then entire sentences and then entire chapters.An example here (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sCO1FIQzbQk) It is quite incidental that , many of these stick in memory quite a lot. When i chant these after a few years , i am quite surprised that i can recall this without much effort. P.S. Not glorifying, just stating the facts
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by sriram_malhar on Sunday January 07, 2018 @10:07PM (#16094356)
Hmm, interesting observation, but the causal link seems a bit tenuous.

Is it possible that only people with larger hippcampi and other cortical regions are good at memorizing large texts? (that is, the causal link is inverted)

Is it possible that people who learn or do something focussedly over a long stretch of time (practice music 4 hours a day) show larger development over those same areas than the average distracted person?

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by jhiska on Sunday January 07, 2018 @10:27PM (#16094430)
>Is it possible that people who learn or do something focussedly over a long stretch of time (practice music 4 hours a day) show larger development over those same areas than the average distracted person?

It's more than possible -- it's well-documented with some kinds of meditative practice. [1]

The only interesting question this article raises for a knowledgeable person is whether or not the Sanskrit language _itself_ would have an effect on cognition, but it never succeeds to prove it would or offer a mechanism for how it would work, and instead asks for funds for more studies.

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/meditationpapers/top/?sort=top&t=al...

https://www.reddit.com/r/MeditationNerds/top/?sort=top&t=all

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by 0xcde4c3db on Sunday January 07, 2018 @06:06PM (#16093285)
> Does the pandits’ substantial increase in the gray matter of critical verbal memory organs mean they are less prone to devastating memory pathologies such as Alzheimer's? We don't know yet, though anecdotal reports from India's Ayurvedic doctors suggest this may be the case.

If there is such an association, self-selection bias must be accounted for. It might be that dementia risk factors or subclinical pre-dementia pathology makes a person less likely to pursue training as a pandit.

Also, anecdotal reports from Ayurvedic doctors suggest a lot of things. For example, that the right sort of yoga practice leads to 80-year-olds who look and feel like teenagers.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by modi15 on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:09AM (#16094973)
80-year-olds looking and feeling like teenagers is stretching it, but Yoga is magical in making you look/feel younger.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by Ar-Curunir on Monday January 08, 2018 @12:06AM (#16094775)
I don't think the children involved in the training have a great deal of choice in the matter. Most priests then start their career almost immediately as adults.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by jessaustin on Sunday January 07, 2018 @09:44PM (#16094278)
I think Tom Brady is doing some of that yoga?
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by anthk_ on Sunday January 07, 2018 @07:57PM (#16093859)
Well, I've read Snow Crash yesterday.

How interesting...

(Anyone who read the book can relate...)

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by sideshowb on Sunday January 07, 2018 @08:35PM (#16094017)
Nam shub of enki indeed
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by bobosha on Sunday January 07, 2018 @05:52PM (#16093219)
while this is interesting, it would be good to know if the memorizing of other texts - say, the works of Shakespeare, or Encyclopedia britannica, would have a similar effect. It is perhaps not the mantras, but the act of memorization perhaps?
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by lr4444lr on Sunday January 07, 2018 @06:02PM (#16093265)
Strong oral traditions still exist, or did until recently, in the Balkans around their lengthy epics and wedding hymns. There may be some traditions in northern Europe clinging on for dear life as well. In the classical tradition, it was a hallmark of leaning to memorize long blocks if not whole works of Homer, Vergil, and various Elegiac poets.

Part of the problem in teasing out the effect is that there is an inherent selection bias in the type of people who receive this type of education (or any education, in the not too distant past) to conclude from population analyses to what degree the particular task of literary memorization confers this benefit. Someone's going to have to ferret out the mechanism or do controlled longitudinal studies, which will be costly and fraught with difficulty. Even Socrates (i.e. Plato) was attuned to the idea that memory was under attack with the advent of writing[0] and a culture that has other information retrieval technology, so it's debatable whether we could really plumb the depths of what human cognition could be under different pressures. It's also unclear how early this kind of training has to be started too in order to have an effect.

[0]https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/literally-psyched/on-wr...

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by kilpikaarna on Monday January 08, 2018 @02:22AM (#16095190)
In a pre-literate society these kinds of works (including much of Shakespeare) would've been composed in verse form to aid with memorization. So if you intend to recite from memory for six hours straight, like in the article, you probably want that rather than Britannica or the phone book.

I do find it plausible that certain (combinations of) language and verse metre might have mantra-like qualities, conducive to achieving trance states that could affect the brain. India has been on the case for a looong time, so it wouldn't surprise if Sanskrit + Vedic poetry present a particularly sophisticated example.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by spraak on Sunday January 07, 2018 @10:19PM (#16094402)
As a Hindu, it feels very much inherent in Sanskritam and the works themselves, but I recognize that it is just my opinion based in my world view.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by mannykannot on Sunday January 07, 2018 @10:32PM (#16094451)
I think there is some evidence that singing can help people with dementia, and also that recall is as much of an issue as memorization.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by FrozenVoid on Monday January 08, 2018 @02:25AM (#16095206)
The Sanskrit Effect is result of repeating specific mantra words that occur in the text. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3099099/ It will be much easier just to chant the specific "brainy" mantras(such as brim/aim) instead of hours of random text.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by jhiska on Sunday January 07, 2018 @10:17PM (#16094393)
>Although this initial research, focused on intergroup comparison of brain structure, could not directly address the Sanskrit effect question (that requires detailed functional studies with cross-language memorization comparisons, for which we are currently seeking funding), we found something specific about intensive verbal memory training.

This quote, coupled with a lack of a proposed mechanism as to how the Sanskrit language would itself have an influence on cognition, means that as far as we know right now there is no such thing as the Sanskrit Effect.

It makes for a catchy headline, though, and the other stuff in the article speaks to my own successful experiments in memory training -- if interested, look up the books from the World Memory Championship winner.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by tw1010 on Sunday January 07, 2018 @11:21PM (#16094626)
Funny, I just read Andre Weils biography, and one thing that stood out about it was that he spent a lot of time learning sanskrit. I wonder if there's a connection between this and his massive intellect.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by pacificleo11 on Monday January 08, 2018 @04:29AM (#16095642)
From the article "Our study was a first foray into imaging the brains of professionally trained Sanskrit pandits in India. Although this initial research, focused on intergroup comparison of brain structure, could not directly address the Sanskrit effect question (that requires detailed functional studies with cross-language memorization comparisons, for which we are currently seeking funding)," Is it just me who thinks that this disclaimer negate whole point of research ?
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by murukesh_s on Monday January 08, 2018 @04:46AM (#16095689)
I too don't think a language by itself don't have a certain effect on brain development. But Brahmins (who study vedas in India) starting learning Vedas at about 4 years of age, if am not wrong, chanting it daily morning from 4.am for couple of hours. That would definitely have an impact on your brain. Remember the study which showed London taxi drivers had bigger brains?

https://www.wired.com/2011/12/london-taxi-driver-memory/

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by tragomaskhalos on Monday January 08, 2018 @05:55AM (#16095937)
Does anyone have recommendations for a good Sanskrit book for the self-learner? Years ago I tried Coulson's "Teach Yourself Sanskrit" but found it too dense, and more recently have been considering Ruppel's "The Cambridge Introduction to Sanskrit" ?
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by svat on Monday January 08, 2018 @12:26PM (#16098256)
The best book I've found for self-study is the two-volume set by Thomas Egenes (Introduction to Sanskrit). It's very gently paced, though, so you need to have the motivation to stick through till the end (about 400 pages in Part 1 and about 450 in Part 2).

Other alternatives are to contact a local chapter of the volunteer organization Samskrita Bharati if there's one (or watch these videos produced by them: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLudSN7Po9muLeRM6545s6...), or to try http://www.learnsanskrit.org/ for something online. See more book reviews at https://sanskritstudio.wordpress.com/book-reviews/

If you say what your reasons are for learning Sanskrit, there may be other suggestions….

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by flatfilefan on Monday January 08, 2018 @10:59AM (#16097598)
What about the IQ of those people? Not that IQ were of any huge significance, but that's the first thing probably come to mind of any researcher.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by mushufasa on Sunday January 07, 2018 @11:21PM (#16094625)
wait why isn't this reverse causation?

people with strong verbal memories will choose to memorize mantras.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by sriram_malhar on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @01:55AM (#16104154)
Brahminical training starts when one is a kid, so choice doesn't come into play. I was exposed to it when I was 15 years old, and I still didn't have a choice. FML.

I'd like to see a similar study of people who remember hundreds of prime digits.

Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by Ar-Curunir on Monday January 08, 2018 @12:05AM (#16094771)
Because there isn't really a choice involved here.
Re:A Neuroscientist Explores the “Sanskrit Effect” by mushufasa on Monday January 08, 2018 @03:05AM (#16095339)
aspiring pandits who can't keep up won't graduate to the author's sample group