News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by sharpercoder on Thursday January 04, 2018 @07:53PM (#16075565)
I still don't get why no commercial hardware vendor offers products specifically designed for this software. OSS router software for home seems to be far superior then all the proprietary stuff that's out there.
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by moondev on Thursday January 04, 2018 @08:39PM (#16075794)
I bought this mini router recently that comes with OpenWRT pre-installed. It's an awesome little device!

http://www.gl-inet.com/mt300n-v2/

Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by pingec on Friday January 05, 2018 @02:21AM (#16077140)
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by IgorPartola on Thursday January 04, 2018 @08:47PM (#16075833)
Whoa. That looks great! Is it stock OpenWRT? Does it auto-update? Do you get root on it?
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by gsich on Thursday January 04, 2018 @10:25PM (#16076240)
No gigabit port.
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by IgorPartola on Thursday January 04, 2018 @11:13PM (#16076475)
Poo. My current ISP (Cox) does offer 130Mbps. But for $20 this seems like a great replacement for my TP-Link that I put OpenWRT on.
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by jrrrr on Thursday January 04, 2018 @10:38PM (#16076307)
You must have a really fast internet connection.
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by gsich on Friday January 05, 2018 @03:34AM (#16077368)
Slightly more then 100 Mbit/s Downlink. But this also makes the 300 Mbit/s for Wlan useless. So maybe for some small stuff it is usable. But then again, it is not very cheap either.
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by snaky on Friday January 05, 2018 @12:26AM (#16076761)
There are many places (outside US) where you can get 200MBit for $10 or so.
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by fyfy18 on Friday January 05, 2018 @09:13AM (#16078648)
1 gigabit symmetric for €20/mo here in Lithuania. Assuming you like cold winters :-)

Back on topic, what hardware are people with these sort of speeds running? It seems most consumer routers usually top out around 500mbit for NATing. I’m currnetly using a Mikrotik Hex with RouterOS, but prefer OpenWRT/LEDE.

Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by keeperofdakeys on Thursday January 04, 2018 @10:52PM (#16076368)
I have an older one of these, and you can get full root on them. They are basically stock IIRC, if they aren't they can at least run stock openwrt. By default they have a simplified second web interface, with an "advanced" button that loads the openwrt luci web interface.
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by avtar on Thursday January 04, 2018 @10:28PM (#16076249)
This thing looks great! What's the wireless performance like?
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by Integer on Friday January 05, 2018 @03:21AM (#16077329)
The Turris Omnia [1] is an open-source router which uses a fork of OpenWRT as it's OS, and has auto-update. Kinda pricey, but the hardware is good.

[1] https://omnia.turris.cz/en/

Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by mcbridematt on Thursday January 04, 2018 @08:43PM (#16075813)
OpenWRT has been the base for some chip and router vendor SDKs for a while now - Qualcomm/Atheros SoCs and Technicolor gateways for example. So your ISP router may already be running OpenWRT underneath.

However, most home level routers usually rely on (proprietary) hardware traffic offload which is why the code doesn't float back upstream.

Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by freestockoption on Thursday January 04, 2018 @08:12PM (#16075668)
Could it be that most hardware vendors feel that their value-add is in software? Or they feel offering something like OpenWRT would cannibalize sales of their higher end offerings like VPN routers?

I will not buy a router if I can't flash OpenWRT on it. It's a requirement for me now.

Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by dboreham on Thursday January 04, 2018 @08:09PM (#16075651)
Some reasons:

If it has wireless then you enter a minefield of regulatory and approvals pain. I suspect that under the current fcc rules you can't sell hardware that isn't locked to its firmware (because if you did users would be able to freeband).

There already exist some products that pretty much meet the requirement so the niche for pure play OSS is even smaller than you might imagine. e.g. Mikrotik sells a huge line of products running Linux under the hood. If you are familiar with kernel networking you can easily work with their CLI and UI. Very low cost. Does everything Linux does and is fcc approved.

One you get beyond super-low cost (e.g. into 10G NICs and wire-speed 1G routing) customers expect stuff to work, and with an OSS kernel plonked onto someone else's hardware it probably won't 100% work. This again constrains the niche within which pure OSS is viable.

Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by burnte on Thursday January 04, 2018 @09:08PM (#16075922)
> I suspect that under the current fcc rules you can't sell hardware that isn't locked to its firmware (because if you did users would be able to freeband).

You absolutely can and most companies do not lock their firmware. There are companies that commercially sell routers with DD-WRT and other OSS firmwares by default, like Buffalo. http://www.buffalotech.com/news/dd-wrt-nxt-routers

End users are expected to adhere to FCC rules even if they have the technical ability to violate them.

Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by boomboomsubban on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:02AM (#16078098)
>End users are expected to adhere to FCC rules even if they have the technical ability to violate them.

The FCC rules changed ~two years ago, you aren't allowed to sell devices capable of violating FCC rules. The original rule just banned third party firmware, but after some outrage it was changed so that the easiest way to comply was blocking third party firmware. They clearly wanted to ban them altogether, wouldn't be surprised if they were working on it right now

Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by burnte on Saturday January 06, 2018 @07:25PM (#16088299)
I disagree they wanted to ban firmware, they simply want to prevent interference. I doubt they actually CARE about the firmware. Regardless, nothing you mentioned changes what I said.

Yes, under the revised rules [1] manufacturers are required to ensure certain changes can't be made, such as disabling DFS and using non-standard channels. And as I said, the FCC explicitly does not ban third party firmware. The biggest reason is that it's cheaper to make adjustments to the radio chips to prevent certain changes than it is to swear to the FCC no one can hack in new firmware.

And as I stated and you quoted, users are still required to follow FCC rules. You can't hook up an external signal amp to boost transmit power past legal levels, use unapproved channels, etc, even if they find bypasses for the protections required by the FCC. You can't use a signal booster for a TV antenna that causes interference. You can't boost power on your CB radio. Etc.

[1] https://apps.fcc.gov/kdb/GetAttachment.html?id=zXtrctoj6zH7o...

Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by boomboomsubban on Sunday January 07, 2018 @05:16AM (#16090210)
I wasn't doubting what I quoted was true. You replied to a post about speculated ideas of FCC regulations on selling routers and didn't mention the actual regulation on selling routers. It seemed worth adding.

Their original proposal for the revised rules specifically banned third party firmware, mentioning DD-WRT by name, and the revised version decided not to ban it.

The rule also doesn't hold the company liable if someone manages to hack a third party firmware onto the device. Before selling it,you need an approved application showing either a chip unable to break the rules, or a way of preventing unauthorized code from running on the device. If the FCC approves the application and you've implemented it, you aren't at fault if a workaround is discovered. This makes locking the firmware a cheaper than producing two models or selling a limited model elsewhere.

To me, it seems like they wanted a hard ban on the firmwares, settled for a soft ban, and will likely revisit the issue when there's some political capital justifying a hard ban.

Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by gsich on Friday January 05, 2018 @03:35AM (#16077374)
What is "freeband"? Most chips have hardware limitations, so it does not matter what firmware you install. For most chips it is unrealistic that they can eg. use 1 W as output power.
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by vsl on Saturday January 06, 2018 @02:39AM (#16084309)
Mikrotik uses its own OS, not Linux. The CLI uses their own weird config language, it’s not a normal UNIX shell either.
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by kabes on Friday January 05, 2018 @05:07AM (#16077693)
They do. The Linksys WRT range is branded to be easy to put OpenWRT/DD-WRT on: https://www.linksys.com/us/wrt-performance-perfected
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by __david__ on Thursday January 04, 2018 @09:42PM (#16076079)
Maybe not quite specifically designed, but http://pcengines.ch has great little boards that I've been running OpenWRT on for years and years. I'd never buy a consumer router again.
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by wtallis on Thursday January 04, 2018 @08:24PM (#16075726)
The companies that sell routers are not the companies that design the chips and write the drivers. Even when eg. Linksys wants to make an open-source friendly router, they often have to choose between using the latest chips that don't have mature upstream drivers, or using the older chips that have solid support. They don't have the ability to create good open-source code on their own. But most of the time, they end up going with the cheaper Broadcom chipsets, or switching to them in a later product revision. (Broadcom's WiFi driver situation is about as Linux-unfriendly as NVidia's graphics drivers.)
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by xav0989 on Thursday January 04, 2018 @08:39PM (#16075796)
ASUS has ASUSWRT, but it's based on tomato, not openwrt.
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by dimensi0nal on Thursday January 04, 2018 @08:01PM (#16075603)
Someone who would buy hardware like that would probably choose a wired router with pfSense and separate access points instead.
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by toast0 on Thursday January 04, 2018 @08:13PM (#16075677)
'wireless routers' usually work fine as an access point + Ethernet switch when you disable dhcpd and don't use the wan port (nice ones let you use the wan port as another lan port). They're usually cheaper than a dedicated access point too.
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by alimbada on Friday January 05, 2018 @04:57AM (#16077661)
What's the advantage of disabling dhcpd?
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by BuildTheRobots on Friday January 05, 2018 @05:13AM (#16077724)
I think OPs point is that he's already got a router running DHCP on the network, but if you disable all the router-like services on a second device you can use it as a dedicated access point.
Re:Announcing the OpenWrt/LEDE merge by kabes on Friday January 05, 2018 @05:12AM (#16077716)
Well, he's talking about access points. You don't want multiple DHCP servers in your network.