News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by scotty79 on Monday August 16, 2010 @06:43AM (#1607377)
>> I’m not thinking the way I used to think. I feel it most strongly when I’m reading. I used to find it easy to immerse myself in a book or a lengthy article. [...] Now my concentration starts to drift after a page or two. I get fidgety, lose the thread, begin looking for something else to do. I feel as though I’m always dragging my wayward brain back to the text. The deep reading that used to come naturally has become a struggle.

> The author is Nicholas Carr. According to Wikipedia Mr Carr was both in 1959 and thus is now 51. Like me, Mr Carr is aging, unlike me Mr Carr seems to be blaming changes in the operation of his mind on the Internet.

I'm 31 and I feel same change in how my mind works when confronted with a book as Nicolas Carr does. I can't blame aging and I've spent most of my time for last few years reading the internet so there might be something to it.

It might not necessarily be bad. I was always impatient with books that had low ideas/wordcount quotient. I couldn't force myself to read Hobbit and I fell asleep on Bladerunner at the same time immensly enjoying short stories by Henry Kuttner. I think that internet just brought down my tolerance to level I never expeirenced before.

I can't even imagine what would happen to my brain if I fed myself with TV or The Times at the same rate as I'm feeding myself with internet.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by barrkel on Monday August 16, 2010 @07:34AM (#1607448)
I'm 30 and I have no difficulty reading long books, nor watching Bladerunner. Actually I prefer long, slow-paced movies, especially the kind Sergio Leone made. And I've been doing this computer business since at least the age of 11.

There's a risk of bias confirmation here. Seek and ye shall find: you look for what you agree with, and you'll find it. You need to look for counterexamples too.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by scotty79 on Monday August 16, 2010 @08:15AM (#1607529)
Great so there are different kinds of people. You prefer slower pace, I need more ideas per absorbed data unit to keep being interested.

My expeiriences with computers started probably more or less as early as yours (although I can't with clear concience call them business) but It's not about computers. It's about internet content.

I was always impatient but I see my impatience significantly grown over the last few years as I read internet blogs and sites like digg, HN and similar. I reached the point when I can start reading Terry's Pratchett new book, stop after few pages and forget it for weeks or months.

Maybe you don't spend as much time reading internet as I do (I really can't imagine how could I read more of it) or it has less (or no) effect on you but that doesn't change the probability of such correlation occur at least for some people.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by jleyank on Monday August 16, 2010 @08:34AM (#1607569)
I've always blamed TV for the loss of attention span - passive consumption. The internet, usually, is (more) active consumption, although you can make the point that it delivers in small packets.

Might be symptomatic of life in general, as people put out less effort to do anything - serious reading, like serious anything, requires some effort.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by sesqu on Monday August 16, 2010 @10:47AM (#1607899)
Internet consumption isn't, at present, very active; it's voluminous. There's so ridiculously much to consume, I find I'm growing impatient merely because I must demand density to get through the mass. This is a problem for me, since I'm not convinced dense stuff sticks.

There are also happiness implications.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by matwood on Monday August 16, 2010 @09:53AM (#1607766)
I'm roughly your same age and have similar exposure to the internet, but have no problems reading a GOOD book or watching a GOOD long movie.

Content used to be hard to find. Either you had to get a recommendation from someone for a book or watch whatever happened to be on TV. This led to a lot of mindless consuming of stuff that people simply did not enjoy, but it was all they had. The internet has made me (and many others) acutely aware of the back button. If you don't like the content you can move on since there is so much else out there to pick from.

I now view books and movies the same way. If I don't like a movie I simply turn it off and pick another or go do something else. I do the same thing with books. If I'm not into it after 50 or so pages then I put it down and try something else. Why force myself through content that I don't enjoy?

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by X-Istence on Monday August 16, 2010 @09:34AM (#1607716)
Meh, I am 22, have been browsing the web since I was 10 years old, and have a hard time when I am away from it, but I can still sit down with a good book and read the entire thing cover to cover in no time flat. The last book I did that with was a re-read, Cryptonomicon. I sat down at 8 in the morning, finished it by 3 in the after noon with a couple of limited breaks to do some bodily business and get some food.

I can honestly say that with the Internet I have more of an appreciation for books because there are no distractions. Now maybe at age 22 I am still too young to really have felt the change that the Internet is supposedly to bring, maybe I have to give it more time, we shall see.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by sesqu on Monday August 16, 2010 @10:53AM (#1607921)
I've never understood how people can read that fast. Cryptonomicon is 918 pages; you read it at maybe 30 seconds a page. I've been reading for a long time (though I didn't get into books until my late teens), and I still read English at about 5 minutes per page. It took me weeks to get through Cryptonomicon.
Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by hugh3 on Monday August 16, 2010 @12:08PM (#1608191)
30 seconds a page is pretty fast (especially for a book like Cryptonomicon, where you'd want to stop and think every now and then) but five minutes a page would be really slow. You could read it out loud faster than that. Hell, most people could type it faster than that.

It might be worth your while spending a few hours every day for a week learning to speed-read. You can probably get instructions elsewhere, but it just involves a metronome and dragging your finger across the page in time with it. You can get reasonably fast (~1000wpm) pretty fast once you overcome the need to (a) sound it out in your head as you read and (b) point your eyes directly at every word.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by cstross on Monday August 16, 2010 @02:01PM (#1608576)
Maximizing words-per-minute throughput is not a useful goal for reading; what about comprehension?

(I find I get distracted more easily these days; I suspect too much use of the internet has damaged my ability to focus for hours on end on a book. I catch myself looking away from the page and zoning out every couple of minutes. That is something to work on -- maintaining focus on the task at hand -- and so I'm trying to re-train myself to read books.)

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by Retric on Monday August 16, 2010 @04:09PM (#1609040)
Comprehension tends to increase as WPM increases up to 500 or so WMP. Above 500WPM the trend is less clear and probably depends on the individual and how redundant the text.

As I understand it the faster you read the more stuff you can keep in short term memory so the easier it is to make connections though different sections of text.

At the extreme consider how hard it would be to read one page of a book over the course of a year.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by niyazpk on Monday August 16, 2010 @11:18AM (#1608009)
I agree with you in that the internet has made me lose my concentration. I get easily distracted while I at my laptop, browsing the web. My solution was to go back to reading more books than before and I unlike you I am not distracted when I am away from my computer. Recently I documented my experience here: http://www.diovo.com/2010/08/books-vs-blogs/

At the same time, I can understand that this may not be the case with some other people (like jgc). Ultimately there is no point in fighting over this. What works for you, works for you.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by ww520 on Monday August 16, 2010 @05:08PM (#1609279)
I used to sit in front of the TV for a long time watching Saturday cartoons when I was young. Now I can't sit through one minute of them (unless if it's Simpsons or South Park).

People outgrow their tastes.