News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by fortythirteen on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @03:52PM (#16064994)
Except that nationalization is part of the plan, under the guise of "affordable municipal broadband". A government owned near-monopoly replacing a private one.
Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by delinka on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @04:23PM (#16065315)
When has that ever been the case? The FCC doesn't build anything. If you're worried about the federal government paying private companies to build out such a thing, take a look at the first decade of the current century where taxpayers funded the telecoms to build out broadband infrastructure with pretty much zero regulation around, well, any of it. There was no specification that the network be nationalized or become government property or that some random government agency could coerce the telecoms into controlling information on the internet ...

So what are you talking about?

Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by wmf on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @04:35PM (#16065429)
It's local governments, not the federal government. In theory there is a concern that a municipal ISP could outcompete commercial ISPs due to lower cost of capital and such, but it's not clear if that has ever happened.
Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by stale2002 on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @09:08PM (#16067419)
Uhh, isn't that a GOOD thing though.

If the other companies can't compete because their prices are too high, well sucks to be them.

The only thing that matters is the consumers.

Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by rayiner on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @10:09PM (#16067720)
Artificially suppressed or subsidized prices are not a good thing and in fact are a huge problem in the infrastructure world. It kills infrastructure investment. Our electrical grids, water and sewer systems, transit systems, roads, etc., are all crumbling because short-sighted "pro consumer" types thought the most important thing was to keep prices low for consumers.
Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by eat_veggies on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @11:50PM (#16068126)
We're getting high prices and dogshit slow internet anyways due to laws that keep competition out. Even Google gave up on trying to deal with the telecoms. Your argument would be fine if our high prices actually resulted in innovation but we haven't had that in a decade. For a while my family was paying about fifty bucks a month for three megabits down.
Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by adventured on Thursday January 04, 2018 @12:17AM (#16068229)
High prices yes, slow internet no.

It's no longer true that the US lags behind on Internet access speeds.

The US is ranked #10 in the world in average Internet access speeds, just barely behind Denmark and Japan. The countries that rank in front of the US are mostly tiny population wise. We're far faster than eg France, or Australia. Competitively, US access speeds have improved substantially in the last ten years.

Here's who ranks in front of the US: South Korea, Denmark, Sweden, Norway, Hong Kong, Finland, Switzerland, Singapore, Japan.

Here is who the US ranks in front of: Canada, Australia, France, Germany, Russia, Brazil, China, Mexico, Taiwan, New Zealand, India, Indonesia, Netherlands, Romania, Britain, Czech, Belgium, Ireland, Spain, Portugal, Austria, Poland, Italy, Greece, Israel, Turkey, Saudi Arabia - and all of Africa + all of Latin America.

The US has 2x the average access speeds of Italy, and neary 2x the speeds of France.

Within 24 to 36 months, the US will likely pass Japan on average access speeds.

This is a massive improvement over where the US was ten years ago and it's getting better faster than most countries.

The US ranks #8 on percentage of connections above 15mbps (48%), just behind Sweden and in front of Denmark. The US ranks #10 on percentage above 25mbps, with dramatically faster growth in that segment than anyone else in the top 10. Between Q1 2016 and Q1 2017, the US saw a 65% leap in % of connections over 25mbps; Finland, ranked #9, by comparison saw a 31% improvement.

So not only is the US killing it on access speeds now, particularly for a massive country of 330 million people, it's improving far faster than most other comparable nations.

Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by jbclements on Thursday January 04, 2018 @12:35AM (#16068290)
Sounds like you have a good source of information; any chance you can share pointers? Thanks! Apologies if I missed this in upstream posts.
Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by adventured on Thursday January 04, 2018 @01:04AM (#16068383)
Akamai's State of the Internet quarterly reports are the only authoritative source I'm familiar with that confidently publishes at a global data scale. They have one of the only true global networks, that reach basically into every market. They're the only global network that I know that publishes routine detailed information like that. It's not perfect, I'm not aware of anything better however. They've been publishing it for a number of years, so there's a decent tracking history of trends over time.

Here's the Q12017 pdf:

https://www.akamai.com/fr/fr/multimedia/documents/state-of-t...

Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by stale2002 on Thursday January 04, 2018 @11:41AM (#16071695)
How can the government investing too much money into infrastructure cause a decrease in the total amount of money invested in infrastructure?

It is self contradictory logic.

Price controls, such as what happens in the electricy and water market might cause that. But the government getting into the game, and spending more money on infrastructure wouldn't....

Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by rayiner on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @04:51PM (#16065577)
> If you're worried about the federal government paying private companies to build out such a thing, take a look at the first decade of the current century where taxpayers funded the telecoms to build out broadband infrastructure with pretty much zero regulation around, well, any of it.

Except this isn't true. Almost all the existing broadband infrastructure was built with private money, not taxpayer money.

Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by s73ver_ on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @05:01PM (#16065681)
Except it absolutely is true. The incumbent ISPs were granted hundreds of billions of dollars to wire the country with fiber. They took the money, and did jack shit with it.

http://newnetworks.com/ShortSCANDALSummary.htm

Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by rayiner on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @05:19PM (#16065835)
The claim is FUD. No governments wrote $200 billion of checks to have broadband built. Look at the methodology used to derive that number: https://www.ntia.doc.gov/legacy/broadbandgrants/comments/61B... (starting on page 222).

$103 billion is "excess profits." I.e. if you pretend that telcos should receive the same profit margins as water companies, during a period of massive growth in demand for their product, then you can count any profits above that level as "taxpayer money paid to the telco." By that logic, taxpayers are giving Apple hundreds of billions of dollars in subsidies.

$78 billion in "excessive depreciation." If you assume that depreciation schedules during the POTS era should be the same as during a period where everyone was replacing their networks to build broadband, then you can count the "excessive depreciation" as "taxpayer money paid to telcos."

If you actually read the origin of the number, nowhere will you find reference to checks written. The gripe is about deregulation in and of itself--the very idea that the government should not be deciding what prices to charge for what services. That kind of thinking is totally outside the mainstream among telecom regulators in the developed world. Every major European country deregulated their telcos in the 1990s and 2000s. The government in Germany or France doesn't sit there and decide how much broadband service should cost, and call everything above that "excess profits."

Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by FireBeyond on Thursday January 04, 2018 @10:04PM (#16076164)
Ahh, TeleTruth, the New Networks Initiative, Bruce Kushnick and the "Irregulators", author of such things as "Not happy with your wireless service? Blame the FCC"? I'm sure this won't be biased, at all...
Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by sliverstorm on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @06:22PM (#16066453)
Given the choice between a government-owned monopoly and a private monopoly, why would you choose the latter?
Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by mattmcknight on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @09:56PM (#16067652)
That's a bit of a false dilemma though, as you don't need any monopoly. It is the local governments that granted the monopolies in the first place.
Re:After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with... by patmorgan23 on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @07:35PM (#16066901)
Because the latter can and will be displaced by a shift in the marketplace. The former can literally shut down its competitors with state power.