I recently watched a video of a Columbine survivor giving a TED talk about emotional pain and addiction, and he said something along the lines of: "If you want to heal it, you have to feel it." Basically this commonsense idea that the best way to heal from trauma is to face it.
It sounds right... but is it? The guy giving the talk had been addicted to opioids for 10 years before getting sober and confronting his emotional pain. The implication is that he could've saved himself 10 years of drug addiction if he had just confronted his pain after the shooting instead of medicating it. However, he doesn't seem to consider the possibility that he might've been unable to process his pain immediately after the shooting, and that he was only able to overcome his trauma after a certain amount of distance (time-wise) from the incident.
So this is the question: is it always the right move to confront one's emotional pain in full? Is there ever a circumstance where numbing pain via medication (at least temporarily) could lead to better outcomes?
I don't know the answers. I'd love to know if there have been scientific studies done on this issue... I actually asked this question on /r/AskScience a month or two ago but it didn't get much attention. Curious to see what the research says.
I think it's also a bit simplistic when we frame avoidance solely as a product of being unwilling to face pain. In some cases (certain forms of PTSD), substance abuse is used to numb because you've exceeded your local tolerance for the pain you've been facing, or because the only thing you've been experiencing/facing is pain and its exhausted your coping mechanisms. Learning at mid-life that you're no longer the person you knew, while also dealing with the traumatic source, compounds the process of processing the events.
Particularly when getting into how life altering traumas work, coping and accepting are processes that require different treatments/approaches at different times.
I used to have questions on migraines. Then I had the kind where you go blind for a bit before the headache. Yes, it is more painful than any normal headache.
In a sense, this is like asking why do we treat allergies? Maybe the body is reacting that way for a reason, after all.
But also often people's first response to pain at whatever level is to try to kill it without first trying to understand it.
Pain is incentive to change what is happening. We need it. Otherwise we wind up even worse off.
I think that's an invalid assumption. I don't like going to the doctor and I usually won't unless something really hurts. I don't know many people who enjoy doctor visits. I suspect it's inline with dentist visits.
I do note that opioids seem to be a particularly bad form of pain medication. You may start them to just fight some pain, but there are good chances you will get addicted. So, often it started to manage truly high levels of pain, but continues past necessity.
Similarly to most recreational risk taking of any kind. Social natures will move people beyond most risk heavy habits. This includes drugs. Addiction does exist, but it is not as simple as "this person is addicted."
Pain is indeed useful most of the time (to prevent damage to the organism) but like all warning systems, it has false positives or activates when the cause of activation cannot realistically be remediated.
Those are the cases where opioid or cannabinoid medication can be useful; because having protective mechanisms like pain activated chronically and for no good reason can be debilitating.
People are rightly pointing out that most societies didn't have the option, but I think you have a point even so.
My objection would be that other societies don't seem to have avoided painkillers by embracing pain; they seem to have actually felt less of it. Average health in the US is not good. Chronic ailments like inflammation, joint damage, and RSI are quite common, and even ostensibly healthy people are quite likely to report frequent pain or pain at work.
So I think it's true that our reliance on painkillers is an error in how we relate to pain, but I disagree that the answer is accepting pain. Rather, the mistake is in using painkillers as a way to mask issues with overall health. Fixing that is hardly easy, and I don't think opposing painkillers is the way to make it happen, but it is important.
BUT....
"And since pleasure is our first and native good, for that reason we do not choose every pleasure whatsoever, but will often pass over many pleasures when a greater annoyance ensues from them. And often we consider pains superior to pleasures when submission to the pains for a long time brings us as a consequence a greater pleasure. While therefore all pleasure because it is naturally akin to us is good, not all pleasure is should be chosen, just as all pain is an evil and yet not all pain is to be shunned. It is, however, by measuring one against another, and by looking at the conveniences and inconveniences, that all these matters must be judged. Sometimes we treat the good as an evil, and the evil, on the contrary, as a good." (Epicurus, letter to Menoeceus)
What about pain that teaches us to avoid harm? E.g., the pain from touching a hot stove?
Vaccinations either, but the child mortality rates used to be a lot higher than they are today.
Medicine used to do major surgery without anesthetic. It's not a world people would want to go back to.
There might be some mileage in a more integrated pain clinic approach to some kinds of milder chronic pain which could benefit from physiotherapy. But in the American context, what matters is what people can get on insurance (if any), not what's best for them.
Perhaps the pain doesn't need to go away. Perhaps it's there for a reason. Perhaps attitudes need to change. Perhaps embracing and examining pain (within reason) should be a more common reaction.
Just throwing out ideas. Slap 'em if you want to.
But I will note not every society has needed to use so many pain relievers.