Re:So Close
by rgbrenner on Monday January 01, 2018 @05:42PM
(#16048452)
Can someone fix the title? it's click bait. There's no way to tell what the article is about without clicking on it. At least mention the company. (Good article though.)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Guidelines say to not editorialize titles, and stick with original, but I agree. Putting short summary in parentheses would help (like "So Close (Otto postmortem)")
That guideline needs to go. HN submitters often summarize the content of an article more appropriately for other readers than the original writer does. Often the newsworthiness of an article isn't apparent for one reason or another.
It took me a couple of minutes to figure out that this was a story of a promising hardware startup that ran out of operating cash during acquisition negotiations.
I've never seen dang or other editors take action against any title expansion/clarification that was intellectually honest in its nature.
When authors or site editors choose titles for their presumed audience, they aren't necessarily considering clarity for deep-linking external sites like HN.
I think it just shouldn't be so strictly enforced, and allow for an objective summary, while still enforcing rules against clickbait/editorializing. On Reddit a headline that says "USD losing steam" would be changed to "Fiat crashing hard - Bitcoin is the salvation!" which is what the HN rule wants to prevent.
Originally it did, I guess it got moderated to the actual title of the article, as per rules?
Yes, I edited it but got changed either by bots or mods.
Was better when it mentioned the name of the company :-)
It's the title of the article though, seems fine to me.
Re:So Close
by yoodenvranx on Monday January 01, 2018 @05:53PM
(#16048501)
No, it is not fine. I know it is standard practice on HN but I really don't like it at all.
Just imagine every submitted article had a title like this: the HN frontpage would be full of links like "so close", "a look back", "introducing our most important features yet", "a statement regarding the events last weeks"...
HN would completely unusable like this because you would have to click on every single link to figure out what it is about.
Luckily, most writers pick better titles than this guy. If what you describe actually happened, the rules would change.
Re:So Close
by yoodenvranx on Monday January 01, 2018 @06:56PM
(#16048778)
The problem is that this guy did not select the title for HN but for his own personal/company blog. If you visit his blog then his title makes completely sense in this context but it loses its meaning in all other contexts.
Quite. Often our reasons for being interested in something are quite different from those of the audience it was written for.