This is an extremely entitled comment.
Most people do not have the choice to work on whatever they want. For most people, it is more like "do 'that kind of job' or be unemployed". If those were your options, you'd take the job of truckdriver or miner or real estate agent.
Do you really think all those peoples' livelihoods are beneath human?
I assume that most people who have those kinds of jobs don’t want those jobs. Rather they need them given the way we’ve structured our society. Those without skills valued by the marked are essentially forced to exchange long hours of menial labor for their survival. Isn’t that more sad?
I think this is why so many folks on HN like the idea of the universal basic income.
Why do you assume that?
Three cases:
1. I know a bus driver for the local school district that doesn't necessarily like his job, but he does it. He looks forward to retiring with a pension.
2. My father wasn't necessarily passionate about his drafting job, but still worked that job as a means to an end--support his family and pay for and enjoy his hobbies. He now enjoys his retirement and travels the world with his wife.
3. A brother-in-law works at his local hardware store. He doesn't specifically like it but it helps him buy his man-toys and care for his family and horses.
I really don't know what each of their dream job is, but it's obvious to me they have different goals than I.
Honestly it was a bit of a shock to me to realize that people work jobs that aren't what they're passionate about, and it doesn't bother them. It's a means to an end.
It made me realize that a lot of us (myself included--as a software type) are (too?) emotionally involved in our jobs. We've basically turned our hobby into our job; the means has become the end, really, to the point that we can't fathom someone working a job they aren't passionate about.
My opinion (and my experience with others) is that people want to work so they can sustain their desired lifestyle; it often doesn't matter the job they have so long as it helps them reach their goals. In fact I've known some folks who pursued software (degree-based or otherwise) simply to achieve their goals and support their (non-software or whatever) hobbies.
Journalists are probably gonna be automated. Truck drivers as well.
I bet those two categories are not of people who consider their jobs meaningless.
Also, salesmen/saleswomen are being automated by websites. But their job is not beneath human dignity in any sense: it can be creative and highly social.
So this seems to be an over-generalization
Your work will continue to have value so long as you can do it better and/or cheaper than a machine can. I don't think anyone denies that the process of making a hamburger can be automated, but this certainly doesn't put chefs out of business because they do it better.
This is, say, in contrast with say a conveyor belt. No human will ever be able to do better in the task of moving and sorting large amounts of simple items over short distances.
That is disputable.
If the alternative is destitution, lots of people want those jobs
Nobody wants those jobs, they're a means to an end. We are overflowing with useful work that needs to be done and can only be done by humans. There's really no reason to have professional ditch diggers and fillers.
What evidence do you have to support such an implausible claim?
Regarding job satisfaction: Starvation is less satisfactory than a shitty job.
If you can imagine your job being replaced then perhaps you would be able to sympathesize.
(Of course, there are trade-offs. A human worker is more expensive, more complicated, and can do things like have a bad day, or be a vector for disease. But still, I'm in favor of more "bullshit jobs" like elevator operator, in lieu of universal income.)
This is literally throwing away money and human effort. Our country could be so much better than it currently is if only we had the drive and man hours to do it. The very idea that "bullshit jobs" are even necessary ignores all the real problems that that the hypothetical person could be tackling.
Yes, that is correct. This is essentially what Keynes, et al, suggested as reasonable stimulus during difficult times (although they used the example of digging a ditch and filling it in again, a job which has the benefit of getting people to exercise out of doors!)
>ignores all the real problems that that the hypothetical person could be tackling.
There are large classes of problems that cannot be touched by the population at large. War is literally the only human endeavor where more hands are almost always better (only almost because hands are attached to mouths which must be fed). I'd love it if millions of people worked at SpaceX, but what would they do? What could they do?
"Making capital more productive" is in your frame of reference neutral, not bad. And no, it doesn't "shift power from worker to capital" unless you actually think anybody wants the kind of job which is so tiresome it can be done with a machine instead. Don't confuse hard work for wages with job satisfaction -- you'd be doing one of those jobs yourself if you thought them as noble as this.