News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Free electron laser – A fourth-generation synchrotron lig... by moritzsimon on Friday December 29, 2017 @06:27AM (#16028929)
I saw the talk live and the nerdism, physicians humor and the transfered knowledge was really mind blowing. It's an awesome insight into the foundation and building of a really large human made machine. Watch!
Re:Free electron laser – A fourth-generation synchrotron lig... by pasbesoin on Friday December 29, 2017 @09:16AM (#16029541)
I have a friend who worked on the construction of the CMS at CERN. Calibration, actually.

He has a similar ability to very clearly explain the technology and what it is trying to accomplish. And an innate curiosity or interest that causes him to learn that -- beyond just his specific technical area.

In other words, some engineers are very effective networkers and communicators.

When I stop to think about it, they have to be, to ever succeed in building such a large and complex device -- in the company and at the behest of so many other disciplines, both practical and theoretical.

P.S. I should add that he does this with everything that really interests him and/or that he is doing. It's not confined to one topic or things he formally works on.

P.P.S. This may be a "Captain Obvious" comment; nonetheless, the presentation reminded me of him.

And of how some comment science stereotypes really are far from the mark.

Re:Free electron laser – A fourth-generation synchrotron lig... by ethbro on Friday December 29, 2017 @09:56AM (#16029716)
My personal observation is that experimental physicists seem to be better (on average) at this than other disciplines.

Maybe something about having to deal with the physical world?

Re:Free electron laser – A fourth-generation synchrotron lig... by nine_k on Friday December 29, 2017 @04:46PM (#16032227)
Experimental physics require large teams, thus communicators are more probable to be seen.
Re:Free electron laser – A fourth-generation synchrotron lig... by QAPereo on Friday December 29, 2017 @11:07AM (#16030113)
It depends... Dirac is a counterexample, while Bohr is a supporting example. It may just be that experimentalist who can explain their ideas with clarity and passion are the ones we notice first/most?
Re:Free electron laser – A fourth-generation synchrotron lig... by stefco_ on Friday December 29, 2017 @04:02PM (#16031966)
Dirac and Bohr were both theorists, not experimentalists! But you're right that it varies within disciplines.

I'm an experimental physics Ph.D. student working on LIGO, and I have also found that experimental physicists are often very good at motivating engineering from top to bottom. I think having depth of knowledge is part of it. My advisor has told me that some of the best experimentalists have sufficient depth of expertise to be theorists. I can't comment on how this compares to other fields (since I haven't worked outside of academia) but I have been very satisfied with how eloquent and deeply informed experimental physicists usually are.

Re:Free electron laser – A fourth-generation synchrotron lig... by TrueTom on Friday December 29, 2017 @06:32AM (#16028953)
It would've been even better without the unnecessary political commentary.
Re:Free electron laser – A fourth-generation synchrotron lig... by ginko on Friday December 29, 2017 @06:58AM (#16029043)
I was at the talk. What political commentary are you even talking about?
Re:Free electron laser – A fourth-generation synchrotron lig... by simplyfantast on Friday December 29, 2017 @07:37AM (#16029172)
Not sure how the parent would respond, but early on, while discussing Rosalind Franklin's DNA diffraction findings, he makes an unnecessary comment about the Nobel prize going to "the two white men." It seemed out of place compared to the rest of his talk.

I didn't feel like the talk gave off an overtly political tone.

The New England Journal of Medicine on the other hand...cancelled my subscription due to how political it has become. Still has very good review articles, though.

Re:Free electron laser – A fourth-generation synchrotron lig... by frostburg on Friday December 29, 2017 @08:57AM (#16029471)
Silence is political too, you just don't notice because you agree with it.
Re:Free electron laser – A fourth-generation synchrotron lig... by pizza on Friday December 29, 2017 @08:39AM (#16029405)
the snubbing of rosalind franklin seems pretty apolitical to me - she had died, and there are no posthumous nobels. still a damn shame she isn't more of a household name, though.
Re:Free electron laser – A fourth-generation synchrotron lig... by epmaybe on Friday December 29, 2017 @08:20AM (#16029327)
What sort of political commentary on nejm are you referring to? I usually only read articles if I find them elsewhere, so I don't know much other than that it is a well respected journal in the medical community.