Re:Microsoft Surface Book 2 15-inch Review
by barrkel on Friday December 22, 2017 @04:01AM
(#15986170)
Many, if not most, desktop-replacement laptops with 4+ cores are thermally limited on compute, and will throttle back under extended high load. I see it as a compromise of the form factor rather than dishonesty per se.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Microsoft Surface Book 2 15-inch Review
by nneonneo on Friday December 22, 2017 @04:15AM
(#15986225)
This isn't a case of thermal limiting - this is a case of the power supply being literally unable to supply enough power to run the system at its full capacity. If I can't use that 1060 at full power for more than 5% of the battery capacity, even while plugged into the wall, isn't that misleading?
Re:Microsoft Surface Book 2 15-inch Review
by barrkel on Friday December 22, 2017 @04:52AM
(#15986351)
The limiting factor might be different but the effect is the same. A rose by any other name would leave you just as disappointed.
(I'm not certain that the limiting factor is actually different, FWIW. Dissipating 100W from a laptop isn't easy. Macbook Pros limit at 80W AFAIK. If the power supply could keep up, I'd expect it to get too hot anyway.)
Re:Microsoft Surface Book 2 15-inch Review
by brudgers on Friday December 22, 2017 @11:04AM
(#15988390)
Dissipating lots of heat from a laptop isn't that hard, it's just that the tradeoffs take the form of gaming laptops because the laws of thermodynamics are not shaped by consumer preferences.
Re:Microsoft Surface Book 2 15-inch Review
by izacus on Friday December 22, 2017 @05:17AM
(#15986429)
Yep, my 2016 15" MBP (2.9 GHz version) will lock the CPU clock down to 1.2 GHz after about half a minute of running some compilation on all cores. It makes for a staggerng difference in comparison to even old i5 2500K desktop CPU, which can easily outperform the laptop.