(I'm not certain that the limiting factor is actually different, FWIW. Dissipating 100W from a laptop isn't easy. Macbook Pros limit at 80W AFAIK. If the power supply could keep up, I'd expect it to get too hot anyway.)
This needs to go one step further because consumers don't generally care about the design of the device until something goes wrong, at which point they get burned and lose their investment. Retailers then misinform them of their repair or replacement rights intentionally. Either the retailer should warranty it for the reasonable life of the device which has to be quoted on the front of the packaging with no questions asked or they have to meet certain repair criteria with a full refund no questions asked if they can't repair it under a certain amount of time (critically a short amount of time like 2 weeks)
Consumer Rights Act in the UK is the nearest thing to this and gives you a position to argue for fitness for purpose over the span of 6 years from purchase. But it doesn't go far enough.
With the above, the Surface Book wouldn't even make it to market which is how it should be. It's disposable and nothing in that price range should be disposable.
I literally got burned once when a badly designed laptop overheated (the plastic around the fan literally melted off), and I'm sure I'm not the only one to whom something like that has happened.
iPhone’s 100% is roughly around 97-98% of its measurement by the hardware. So why is that dishonest?
Am I confused here?
Apple (silently) changed the "failure mode" of batteries from reducing autonomy to lowering performances. Ars shows their power mode as "Recommended", I would guess the observation is a side-effect of that, with the laptop switching from "charged" to "charging" power mode (lowering components performances to charge faster). I saw no note about that, I'd like a re-do with a laptop configured for "best performances".
Of course Microsoft kinda shot themselves in the foot by limiting power input to 100W and designing a laptop with more peak draw than this.
> The 100-Watt AC adapter included with the Surface Book 2 is not quite powerful enough to keep the system fully charged under a high load such as this, so you can see there is some power draw from the battery (the green line in the chart) which is leveraged to make up the difference. Over time, the battery drops to about 95% charge, at which time the system drops the GPU clock a bit to prevent draining the battery any further. Not all games are going to run into this issue, but certain games will require more power from the GPU and CPU than the power input can handle. However, the battery will never completely be drained, as the system doesn’t let it get out of control.
Dishonest designs like this should be punished by consumers, in particular, considering that the Surface Book tablet battery is already a critical part of the laptop (it's comparatively small, and it's hard to replace).