News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by maxxxxx on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @08:52AM (#15969444)
It's funny how they always vehemently advocate for states rights unless these states rights get in the way of their agenda.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:51AM (#15970567)
“States Rights”, since just before the Civil War, has consistently been a political code for protecting discrimination (including, originally, demanding other states be bound to treat escaped slaves as property not people through federal law.)

It has never meant what the words taken together would naively seem to mean.

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by e40 on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:16AM (#15969630)
Came here to say this. It shows the GOP doesn't really stand for anything. They just say what they need to say, in the moment, to get what they want.

If Clinton were POTUS and Russian ties like had been found to the Trump administration, she would have been impeached already. But it's their man, so let's look the other way. Same with State's rights.

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by ictoan on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:17AM (#15969644)
This! "They just say what they need to say, in the moment, to get what they want"

And Trump is the magnification of the GOP.

We need to hold them accountable!!!

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by jessaustin on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:19AM (#15969659)
OMG you're serious. Partisans are so cute.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by ictoan on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:01AM (#15970071)
Yes I am serious. And how is this partisanship when pointing out the need to hold politicians accountable for what they say vs what they do? Care to explain your comment? Why is accountability a sign of partisanship?
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by throwanem on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:33AM (#15971032)
I agree with the sentiment that there's nothing to choose between the parties when it comes to favoring intellectual and moral consistency in governance over whatever will keep a given party's officials, appointees, and elected representatives in their jobs. But cheap, contemptuous condescension adds nothing to the conversation. The temptation is strong at times, I know. But please try not to succumb to it.
[dead]
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by croon on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:47AM (#15969926)
I hope you aren't implying equivalence.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by deusum on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:13AM (#15970180)
Well said.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by davexunit on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:06AM (#15970114)
They most certainly are different.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by 24gttghh on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:16AM (#15970216)
Sure, they are evil in different ways, with money at the root of both sides. We've all seen how they (Dems) handled the primaries last year. If what they did doesn't scream fraud to you, what will?
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by fzeroracer on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:41AM (#15970457)
Whataboutism is fun.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by 24gttghh on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:00AM (#15970664)
So, it wasn't fraud then? Disclaimer: I am not registered with any political party. I find their political machines to be in bad taste.

The GP is probably right, they would probably have impeached Clinton already if she had Russian ties like Trump and his cronies appear to have. And if the Dems controlled the congress, he would probably be gone already also. Seems like some equivalence there...I'm not sure how that is a whataboutism when I am pointing out that neither party is perfect...

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by fzeroracer on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:07AM (#15970765)
I'm not saying it wasn't fraud. I'm saying that the argument has no place here when we're talking about a GOP-lead attempt to effectively destroy the internet as we know it. Any attempt to shift the debate towards 'both parties are bad' is the definition of Whataboutism and an attempt to avoid the actual topic at hand.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by 24gttghh on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:07PM (#15971434)
I was not attempting to avoid the topic at hand, as evidenced by my other comment ITT discussing the actual text of the bill. I'm sorry it came across that way. In my attempt to avoid partisanship I usually end up denouncing both "sides", as I think the money in the back room is what decides the law of the land, and which party happens to accept it for a given issue.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by croon on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @03:24PM (#15973442)
You don't have to like democrats to acknowledge the fact that while they have problems, they are orders of magnitude less horrible than republicans. In the current two party system, denouncing both is giving in to a ridiculous false equivalence, as there is a clear rational choice one could make.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by LyndsySimon on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @01:13PM (#15972164)
> Any attempt to shift the debate towards 'both parties are bad' is the definition of Whataboutism

I disagree. It's not deflection to look at your alternatives and comment on the fact that none are suitable.

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by Can_Not on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @01:40PM (#15972433)
Are you saying that Democrats unanimously voted in favor of the Republican tax bill and are also anticipated to for the Republican fake Net Neutrality bill?
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by LyndsySimon on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @04:21PM (#15973934)
No - I'm saying that for many people, a Democrat that would vote the way they'd like on this issue would also vote in a way that was opposed to their interests in other matters, some of which they might consider to be more important than NN.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by croon on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @04:55PM (#15974198)
Yeah, like keeping birth control from women, and blocking sane gun control regulation, and siphoning more money from the middle class to the rich, and keeping gay people from marrying, and scrapping health care safety nets.

I disagree that that's comparable.

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by meri_dian on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:21AM (#15970261)
Just because the Republican party is traditionally associated with states' rights doesn't mean they should always have to give precedence to states.

The sway of ideologies should be balanced with a willingness to judge issues on their own merit.

Allowing states to enact their own regulations in this case would be incredibly burdensome to internet businesses looking to operate in multiple states (so all of them), there's a good reason for net neutrality laws to be uniform across the whole country.

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by maxxxxx on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:30AM (#15970367)
It's always burdensome to have different laws in different states. Different sales tax in different states is a major PITA for example. I don't think this is different from other laws.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by meri_dian on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:49AM (#15970551)
Which is why criticism of Republicans for this on the basis of the law not meshing with one of their supposed foundational ideologies is stupid.

We should not be ridiculing people for not being ideologues. We live in a time when we need people to not be ideologues.

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by haZard_OS on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:19AM (#15970903)
There is, I think most will agree, a difference between being an ideologue and being consistent.

Inconsistency in the application of one's proclaimed first principles should be criticized unless and until the inconsistency is justified with reason and evidence.

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by maxxxxx on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:18AM (#15970895)
They are endlessly repeating their ideology for everything else. I would have had more respect for them if they had said that it's up to the states whether they want net neutrality or not. The same way they are advocating with health care, environmental rules and everything else.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by wtallis on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:05AM (#15970725)
> incredibly burdensome to internet businesses looking to operate in multiple states (so all of them)

Not all of them. Just the ones that want to lay cable in that particular state. Most internet companies are only concerned with deploying physical infrastructure to a handful of data centers, and leaving the rest of the connectivity up to their ISPs. ISPs providing major backbone links would be subject to the hassle of different state regulations, but ISPs providing last-mile service only need to care about the laws of the states their particular customers reside in.

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by Spivak on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:18AM (#15969646)
This isn't very charitable. You should be happy that the GOP doesn't rotely apply their 'principles' even when it's idiotic to do so. Federal laws that create 'maximums' like this always come with preemption. Otherwise a different states are going to enact different versions of NN to score political points accomplishing one of two things: a rule that tries to simplify the regulatory environment will actually make it more complicated because now there's 50 separate policies, or ISPs will be forced to follow the rules of the state with the strictest rules which more-or-less invalidates the federal rule.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by Buttons840 on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:27AM (#15969732)
I don't think the FCC did, nor can they, create a new "federal law" though, right? The FCC removed a regulation. Do states not have the right to regulate in the absence of any federal regulation?
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by stult on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:52AM (#15969971)
>I don't think the FCC did, nor can they, create a new "federal law" though, right?

That's a tricky question. At a high school civics class level, no they cannot create new law because only Congress can. But the reality of the modern regulatory state is that Congress has delegated much of its law making powers to specialized experts in executive branch agencies, including independent agencies like the FCC. So they can adopt regulations that have the force of law but are not statutory, though only to the extent that Congress has authorized them to do so.

Those regulations are for all intents and purposes laws. However, a federal agency's regulations cannot preempt state law on their own; they can only preempt to the same extent that Congress preempted state law in the statute delegating authority to the agency.

And yes, states can regulate where their laws don't conflict with federal laws or regulations. But there's a limit. Congress can enact laws which implicitly preempt state regulation because the federal regulatory scheme is so complete that it "fully occupies the field" leaving no room for supplemental state regulation. In which case, states cannot regulate.

I would be surprised if a court held that the feds have field preempted internet regulation, given how much it ties into areas of traditional state primacy such as property law. But who knows these days.

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:00AM (#15970058)
> I don't think the FCC did, nor can they, create a new "federal law" though, right? The FCC removed a regulation.

The FCC being able to pass and remove regulations in an area means Congress has created federal law governing that area and assigned to the FCC regulatory authority in that area.

Further, even with no federal law, dormant commerce clause concerns come into play.

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by Spivak on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:33AM (#15969802)
The FCC, both under Wheeler and Pai, have had trouble preempting state laws but Congress has no such trouble. The FCC wields delegated congressional power, much like the FDA, and should have authority to preempt state laws as their rules carry the same force of law as bills in congress but the courts have given them a harder time then one might expect. The most notable case was when the courts blocked Wheeler from preventing states from blocking municipal broadband.

States in fact do not have that right if the federal law implicitly or explicitly preempts them. It's a corollary of the supremacy clause.