News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by bcherny on Monday December 18, 2017 @10:46PM (#15957575)
How do you structure + incentivize government orgs to prevent these sorts of issues?
Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by AnthonyMouse on Monday December 18, 2017 @11:46PM (#15957828)
> How do you structure + incentivize government orgs to prevent these sorts of issues?

The basic problem comes from making things too complicated.

For example, there are a million programs that provide subsidies to the poor. The poor can't afford housing, so we have housing vouchers. The poor can't afford food, so we have food stamps. Heat, school, medicine, the list goes on.

The problem with all of these programs is that they're bureaucratic nightmares to navigate and cause all kinds of perverse incentives, e.g. inflating the price of school/medicine/housing, forcing people to buy a specific amount of the subsidized thing instead of spending some of the money on something they might need even more.

And the programs are all trying to do the exact same thing, which is to give money to the poor. Which we could instead do directly with a universal basic income and erase all of that unnecessary complexity from existence.

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by andrewem on Monday December 18, 2017 @11:58PM (#15957880)
I'm not saying a universal basic income is good or bad, but notice the pivot you did there. You criticize programs that don't just spend all their money by giving it to the poor, then you say: "Which we could instead do directly with a universal basic income". That's a program which probably spends most of its money on something other than giving it to the poor, because lots of the money goes to people who aren't poor. Such a program could well have all kinds of perverse incentives too.
Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by Chathamization on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:19AM (#15957957)
With the right tax structures, it would end up focusing on giving money to lower income individuals. You have an increased progressive taxation structure such that for upper-middle income people the UBI is a wash (IE, someone making $100,000 a year is getting and additional $12,000 from UBI but paying $12,000 more than they would have before).

The reason why UBI works well is because it's a cash handout (like the other person said, you're not specifying the needs of the individual), it's a universal and not means tested program (you don't have to go through a bureaucratic maze every time you become eligible), and it's instantaneous for people who have sudden changes in fortune (IE, the income stream is already set up).

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:11AM (#15957926)
> That's a program which probably spends most of its money on something other than giving it to the poor, because lots of the money goes to people who aren't poor.

A UBI is pure redistribution. There is no money that doesn't go to the poor, because where else would it go? Taking money from the rich and then giving them some of it back is just the same thing as only taking the difference to begin with, and the entire difference goes to the poor.

It's equivalent to a government benefit with a phase out rate equal to the tax rate.

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by lucaspiller on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:24AM (#15957973)
Although I’m for universal income, one of my concerns is how do you prevent companies from abusing it, and inflating prices even more.

Drugs and medical treatments in the US are already very expensive compared to the same in other countries. If everyone suddenly has an extra $1k/mo, why wouldn’t the drug companies increase their prices even more?

To me (as a European) it seems like a better option is universal healthcare, to at least make life critical medicine and treatments available to everyone, no matter their financial status.

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:45AM (#15958061)
> Although I’m for universal income, one of my concerns is how do you prevent companies from abusing it, and inflating prices even more.

That's only how prices work for uncompetitive markets. In a competitive market anyone who raised prices would lose business to competitors.

Moreover, monopolies can raise prices in response to anything that causes the poor (or anyone else) to have more money. The problem isn't a UBI, it's the existence of uncompetitive markets.

> To me (as a European) it seems like a better option is universal healthcare, to at least make life critical medicine and treatments available to everyone, no matter their financial status.

Price controls are independent of single payer. If you had single payer and monopoly/patented suppliers without price controls then prices would be... high. So nobody does that. But you can also have price controls without having single payer.

The problem with price controls is econ 101 -- you get underproduction. And when the thing being produced is medicine and medical research, that isn't good.

The counties with single payer do it anyway, and thereby don't pay their share of the research cost and cause there to be less research than there would be. We could do the same thing, single payer or not, and pay less for medicine. But then there would be even less research.

A possible workaround is to subsidize medical research directly, but then you're not saving the money, you're just spending it on the same thing with different routing. Which method of funding research is more effective is open for debate, but you can't avoid paying for the research unless you don't want to have it.

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by kamaal on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:04AM (#15957894)
>>forcing people to buy a specific amount of the subsidized thing instead of spending some of the money on something they might need even more.

Some of this is purposefully done for a reason. You want people to be buying more eggs, milk and bread. Not Candy and Jelly.

In some case this seems to be exactly what has happened.

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:17AM (#15957952)
> Some of this is purposefully done for a reason. You want people to be buying more eggs, milk and bread. Not Candy and Jelly.

Only it doesn't actually do that.

If someone has $5 from their job and $5 from the government and wants to buy $6 worth of bread and $4 worth of candy when you want them buying $10 worth of bread, saying they can only spend the government money on the bread changes nothing.

And is almost universally wrongheaded to begin with, because individuals know better than the government what they actually need. It's too easy to find the government telling a diabetic they can't buy a candy bar when they need it to avoid hypoglycemic shock.

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by kamaal on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @03:26AM (#15958633)
>>because individuals know better than the government what they actually need.

Responsible individuals do. Not every one.

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @10:20AM (#15960766)
> Responsible individuals do. Not every one.

People make their own bed. If someone eats too much candy and dies of a heart attack, it was their choice. The government is not your mother.

It makes no sense to punish all the responsible people with crushing bureaucracy just to save a few fools from themselves.

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by colechristensen on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @04:31AM (#15958940)
Someone close to me was in a housing program for homeless youth. They set them up with an apartment in the city, not "low income housing" but just a unit in a random apartment building, one of many around town. Sounds like a great deal. A place to live to get life on track.

Except if you had a job, you had to give half of your income back to the program until your income was above 2x the grant's value per month. (something like $800/mo, not in the bay area)

When you started a job you had to get your management to fill out a form and submit it to the local government.

When you stopped a job you had to get your management to fill out a form and submit it to the local government.

You had to fill out and get your management to sign time sheets showing how much you worked.

You had to save half of your income (and because homeless youth, that usually meant half of a likely barely above minimum wage job) to pay back to the program.

If any paperwork was submitted late you got threatened with getting kicked out of the program.

If you earned too much money you got kicked out of the program.

If your management failed to send in paperwork you got threatened with getting kicked out of the program.

If your case worker who was responsible for submitting your paperwork didn't submit it on time, you got threatened with getting kicked out of the program (this was often the case)

So literally every single month there was a new crisis and the threat of being homeless again. Not an idle threat but an actual "you're going to get kicked out unless..." ... in a program designed to help youth homeless as a result of abuse.

So on top of dealing with whatever severe personal problems, you have to keep down a job that already has a reason to stigmatize you under a program that put you in an apartment which at minimum wage would cost well over 50% of a full time income, but you also have to manage the constant crises of misplaced paperwork and new requirements and poorly understood and explained rules.

It's just a recipe for failure for the most vulnerable people who are the least capable of dealing with uncertainty and stress ... and the very real and constant threat of returning to living on the street, or in a shelter (they're horrible places), going back to the abusive situation you came from, or very likely getting taken advantage of by someone new.

... because a set of well intentioned people with no idea what it is like to be in anything like that situation couldn't come to terms which were simple and straightforward for giving aid to those in need.

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by GuiA on Monday December 18, 2017 @11:01PM (#15957634)
It's a hard problem, but I think it lies in great part with the "underpaid, incompetent [government] employees".

If you make sure that your government employees are educated, provided with good benefits, feel like they have an impact, etc., the outcomes will invariably be for the better.

A very good example of this is teachers. The OECD tells us:

"[...]in nearly all countries, when teachers perceive that appraisal and feedback lead to changes in their teaching practice, they also report greater job satisfaction. When teachers believe that appraisal and feedback is performed only for administrative purposes they report less job satisfaction. In addition, teachers who report that they participate in decision making at school also report greater job satisfaction. Indeed, although fewer than a third of teachers believe that teaching is a valued profession in their country, those teachers who report that they can contribute to school decisions are more likely to report that teaching is valued in their society."

http://www.oecd.org/edu/school/TALIS-2013-Executive-Summary....

And other sources tell us that satisfied teachers tend to lead to better outcomes.

"TN teachers’ job satisfaction linked to performance scores"

https://news.vanderbilt.edu/2017/02/01/tn-teachers-job-satis...

In other words, much like regular companies, governments with happier employees tend to have better outcomes. This should be hardly surprising to most HN readers.

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by rangibaby on Monday December 18, 2017 @11:49PM (#15957842)
Government employees in Japan have excellent hours, pay, and benefits compared to working in the private sector. Becoming one is very competitive and requires passing difficult exams.

In 10 years of various levels of being a model citizen (or not), all of my dealings with the local and national government have been satisfactory, even when they were in a position where they could make me have a very, very bad day if they felt like it.

My one negative interaction with the police (coerced into accepting a search of my bag) was because I was doing something else illegal, listening to music while riding my bicycle, and I am smart enough to know the difference between beating the rap and beating the ride.

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by kamaal on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:10AM (#15957922)
>>Becoming one is very competitive and requires passing difficult exams.

Same in India. Pay is very good(you also get to make a fortune through bribes), working hours are non-existent and you get other benefits like a lot of holidays, health care and fat pensions after retirement.

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by colechristensen on Monday December 18, 2017 @11:17PM (#15957712)
They aren't always government employees. For lots of programs the funding is awarded as a contract to a company to administer and fund the people in need.
Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by noahth on Monday December 18, 2017 @11:49PM (#15957841)
It's not a hard problem, and it certainly isn't the fault of the individuals tasked with administering a broken and underfunded system. America's elites just aren't interested in solving it. They'd rather pass on indescribable fortunes to their children while the wretched masses beg for insulin online.
Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by colechristensen on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:08AM (#15957911)
This really isn't it.

The American voting public has not the interest or attention span in tackling small complicated problems. The politicians they elect therefore has little interest or motivation to fix these small complicated problems because doing so usually involves spending political capital on compromises. Sometimes a few of them get big ideas about civic duty, but not very many people vote for that. They just vote for whomever yells the loudest about their set of pet issues which are usually red herrings erected to distract the population from actual issues. (abortion, gun control, immigration, etc. not that this issues are _unimportant_ but politicians use them to secure power on both sides and keep up the yelling because if they actually solved them, they would have to tackle the sorts of issues that threaten the powerful)

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by zghst on Monday December 18, 2017 @11:10PM (#15957664)
Higher paid employees means less reach especially without the use of good software.
Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by colechristensen on Monday December 18, 2017 @11:13PM (#15957679)
Do epidemiological studies on the benefits of different ways of doing things.

Share stories of what being in a program is like.

Focus on the cost of administering complex vs. simple programs.

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by guelo on Monday December 18, 2017 @11:50PM (#15957852)
Don't elect politicians that hate government and will do everything they can to undermine government agencies.
Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by colechristensen on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:02AM (#15957889)
Honestly, I've had these experiences with state and local programs in one of the most liberal and progressive places in the country.
Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by muglug on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:16AM (#15957945)
Yeah, but that's still incredibly relative to the rest of the world (assuming you're talking about America).

However liberal your locality, it's still hamstrung by a variety of state and federal laws that make building effective government systems much more challenging than in other developed nations.

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by zghst on Monday December 18, 2017 @11:07PM (#15957655)
I’d love any discussion around this if anyone has answers....
Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by flukus on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:55AM (#15958095)
Does it really need a discussion when you could look at examples from practically every other developed and many developing countries where the idea of starting a gofundme to pay for common medicine is an alien concept?
Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by dsfyu404ed on Monday December 18, 2017 @11:28PM (#15957759)
"You won't get more resources until you can demonstrate efficient usage of what you do have"
Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by DoreenMichele on Monday December 18, 2017 @11:50PM (#15957848)
Aka The beatings shall continue until morale improves.
Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @02:42PM (#15963457)
More like "you're not getting a bigger budget so rearrange what you do get to reflect your priorities"

Negative incentives work far better for organizations than they do for individuals.

Re:A friend of mine died and I didn't know because of algori... by DoreenMichele on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @03:00PM (#15963670)
I did consider trying to find a way to say actually, the beatings shall continue even if morale improves, but wasn't feeling witty enough to pull it off. I still don't feel that witty.

I spent some time homeless and on food stamps. When the lack of resources and lack of compassion for your plight can cause you to literally go hungry -- well, it felt to me like a "beating." It felt actively hostile. That is what I was trying to capture and convey.