News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by GunlogAlm on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:32PM (#15956449)
> The amount of negative press this received nearly cancels out all the positive news from Quantum's release barely a month ago.

Which is silly, IMO. What did this addon actually do, besides be installed without user consent? If this article is correct, the addon was installed automatically but was not 'activated'. Seems like a fuss over nothing, to me, but somebody correct me if I have the details wrong.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by whalesalad on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:35PM (#15956458)
It's not what the extension did or did-not do, it's the fact that Mozilla was originally a champion of privacy, open-source, and free software. The entire purpose of this browser was to escape the corporate bullshit of Netscape/AOL.

I switched from Chrome to the latest Firefox browser due to the awesome work the team has done on bringing it into the future. Then I find out that it comes pre-loaded with Pocket and this dumb ass game extension for a TV show promotion? Are you joking?! Fool me once...at least you can expect the level of integration you get within Google/Chrome.

This was completely incongruent with the ethos of Mozilla and Firefox. That is why this is a big deal. It's a huge slap in the face to those of us who choose to use this software because we know it WON'T do things like this.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Vinnl on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @01:29AM (#15958195)
The extension is open source and free software, and did not violate your privacy. The bad thing about it was that it was unclear that it was so, which really indeed is bad communication, but let's not pretend that Mozilla is not a champion of privacy, open source and free software. It's just that they're not perfect, which is a shame, but that's it.
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by blub on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @02:06AM (#15958337)
Ethical software development needs to be taught in schools, because the level of discourse here is dismaying.

It is NOT ok to force install marketing/advertising content on somebody's conputer. Not ok, can you understand that?

It does not matter if the content is open source, who developed it or where or how it was announced.

And in this matter they HAVE to be perfect. It's not hard. Someone should sign off on features and block any silly marketing or advertising stunts. Not rocket science.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by sbuk on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @09:00AM (#15960219)
"And in this matter they HAVE to be perfect. It's not hard."

How arrogant. It's seem that even you struggle with being perfect...

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by blub on Friday December 22, 2017 @03:03AM (#15985952)
When perfection means not collecting information about one's customers without their permission, that's a very low bar to pass...

One needs to invest significant design & development time in order to be "less than perfect" by adding tracking. Perfection would be easily within reach if corporate greed and lack of morals wouldn't be fighting it every step of the way.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Vinnl on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @05:22AM (#15959171)
This is correct, and I understand that, but that does not mean that it violates privacy or is somehow not open source or free software.

That said, I find the notion that being perfect is not hard rather ridiculous.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Paianni on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:24AM (#15960004)
No one is perfect.
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Paianni on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:23AM (#15959995)
Pocket can be disabled by setting extensions.pocket.enabled to false.

Mozilla has admitted the promotion extension was a mistake and is removing it. I cannot remember the last time this sort of episode ever occurred with Firefox, it should be passable as a one-off.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by qbaqbaqba on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @09:12AM (#15960284)
Pocket is still there, enabled by default.
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by endisukaj on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:49PM (#15956561)
What's wrong with Pocket?
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by TAForObvReasons on Monday December 18, 2017 @08:23PM (#15957038)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9667809 was contemporaneous with the introduction of pocket. The top comments are probably representative:

> It is so unlike Mozilla to introduce something like that, I ran a virus scan and checked what programs had been installed recently -- I assumed it had been put there in the same way that IE users used to get the Ask Toolbar installed.

> It says a lot about Mozilla when they decide to bundle fad features like these after spending years stripping existing features out of Firefox. During their effort to dumb-down Firefox, it was common to hear that removing those features didn't matter, as they should be provided by extensions instead. Apparently that cheap excuse is ignored when the feature when it is convenient to do so.

> Worst of all, there has been almost no communication on this. I subscribe to Planet Mozilla and read everything that seems interesting to me, and I still didn't know this was coming.

> They bundele it because they get payed for it. Same story with the new suggested site advertising. The alarming thing is that this way Mozilla is loosing it's independency.

> I didn't know I ever had to read the fine print with anything from Mozilla, and it turns out I was wrong.

(These are remarkably similar to the criticisms leveled against the current situation)

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by yarrel on Monday December 18, 2017 @08:22PM (#15957030)
What's right with it? If I want to install it I will. I don't, but Mozilla feel that is their choice to make, not mine.

You can't remove it (and disabling it is hard enough), so you cannot reduce the attack surface of your browser if you don't use it.

It's also really badly integrated into the new mobile version.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by r3bl on Monday December 18, 2017 @09:43PM (#15957320)
> and disabling it is hard enough

There's no need to disable it since nothing happens until you click the button. Removing the button itself is as simple as right-clicking it and clicking on the (only) available option: Remove from Address Bar.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Hello71 on Monday December 18, 2017 @11:19PM (#15957724)
but... why do I have to?

"there's no need to remove the crapware bundled with [pick one: Android, Windows, Ubuntu] since nothing happens until you click the button. Removing the button itself is as simple as [opening the Settings, opening Control Panel, apt-get remove]." mozilla is in a seriously bad spot if it's lowering itself to the level of Acer, HP & co bundling crapware to the brim.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by zipppy on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:52PM (#15956592)
It's not about what's right or wrong about Pocket.
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by DonHopkins on Monday December 18, 2017 @07:47PM (#15956870)
The point is that Mozilla prides themselves on transparency, but the name of the config option was "extensions.pug.lookingglass" -- meaningless buzz words with no reference to Mr. Robot -- and the description was just "MY REALITY IS DIFFERENT THAN YOURS" -- an enigmatic Alice in Wonderland quote.

It's actively trying to be opaque. That's the opposite of transparency.

Curious adventurous people install the test build because they want to try out new features and extensions. Those are the users who are most likely to know about and use "about:config". The config option and description of the plugin are mysterious and enigmatic, which tempts your curiosity into turning it on to see what it does, because you presumably trust that Mozilla wouldn't distribute just any old extension that didn't have a purpose other than scanning and modifying the content of every web page, inserting dynamic content adjacent to keywords, and advertising a TV show.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Yoric on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @01:58AM (#15958308)
To be fair, this was part of a hint in a scavenger hunt, so being opaque is pretty much required in that context.

Did it actually display an ad? I didn't see anything such on my Firefox.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by DonHopkins on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @03:14AM (#15958586)
If being opaque is pretty much required, then Firefox is absolutely the wrong context for that extension, whose whole point is transparency.

It's not that it displays an ad, it's that it IS an ad.

Not only that, but it also parasitically hooks in and wastes resources (memory, cpu time, battery life) in each and every tab visiting each and every web page.

That's yet another reason it's totally inappropriate in the context of Firefox, which is trying to dig itself out of the hole of being slow and bloated.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Yoric on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @04:34AM (#15958954)
> If being opaque is pretty much required, then Firefox is absolutely the wrong context for that extension, whose whole point is transparency.

Fair point.

> It's not that it displays an ad, it's that it IS an ad.

If it's an add, it's the most well-hidden ad in history, since you need to find both a hidden preference to turn it on and a specific and non-documented website to let it display anything.

> Not only that, but it also parasitically hooks in and wastes resources (memory, cpu time, battery life) in each and every tab visiting each and every web page.

No, it doesn't.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Crespyl on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @11:26AM (#15961285)
Advertisement or not, it is software created for the purpose of marketing, increasing brand awareness/engagement.

More importantly, it is software that has nothing to do with improving FireFox, collecting telemetry, error reports, running tests, experimental features, or anything else the Shield Studies program is ostensibly to be used for.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Yoric on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @01:56PM (#15962922)
> More importantly, it is software that has nothing to do with improving FireFox, collecting telemetry, error reports, running tests, experimental features, or anything else the Shield Studies program is ostensibly to be used for.

I agree that delivering it through Shield was not a good idea.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by DonHopkins on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:23PM (#15965864)
>If it's an add, it's the most well-hidden ad in history

So well hidden, it's practically underwater.

http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html

Yet in spite of how well hidden it was (or rather, because of), we're now all talking about Mr. Robot, somehow. Funny how that works!

> No, it doesn't [parasitically hook in and waste resources]. [...] since you need [...] a specific and non-documented website to let it display anything

Yes it does hook into and waste resources and potentially display ads on ALL web pages.

Hover text injected into headline on Washington Post #39: https://github.com/mozilla/addon-wr/issues/39

Have you read the source code?

background.js: https://github.com/mozilla/addon-wr/blob/master/addon/backgr...

content-script.js: https://github.com/mozilla/addon-wr/blob/master/addon/conten...

The extension literally injects ads for Mr. Robot in the form of popup tooltips with links on every web page that contains certain keywords. And it also wastes memory, CPU time and battery life for web pages not containing those keywords.

How much more like parasitic adware does it have be before you can see that it walks and quacks like a duck, because its intended purpose is to advertise a television show?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15936727

>It injects a blob of CSS and some JavaScript into every tab, then it does a regular expression search of every text node on each page, filtering out everything but paragraphs, then for each occurrence of a keyword in the text, it creates a new text node to split the current text node, then inserts a new span element between them, containing its own text node, then it creates an additional tooltip element containing six text nodes, five br elements, and one anchor element linking to https://support.mozilla.org/kb/lookingglass , and it also configures css class names to associate all those new nodes it created with the blob of css styling and animations that it injected.

If you wanted to develop your own malicious adware like Superfish that injects your own ads into every web page, this code and the browser hijacking techniques it uses would be an excellent starting point.

Browser Hijacking: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Browser_hijacking

Threat Introduced via Browser Extensions: https://blog.sucuri.net/2014/10/threat-introduced-via-browse...

How to find Chrome extensions that inject ads into any webpage I browse? https://superuser.com/questions/893843/how-to-find-chrome-ex...

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by david-cako on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:36PM (#15956466)
It being installed without user consent is pretty shitty, but this whole time I was under the impression that it was enabled by default, which is insane.

If it wasn't in fact enabled, it's still dumb, but to me a misstep in respecting the user and not a complete breach of trust.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Crespyl on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @11:31AM (#15961338)
Its existence is fine, in fact I wouldn't even mind seeing more collaborations of its kind.

The problem is that auto-deploying marketing software (inert or not) over a channel expressly described as being a tool for development, debugging, and testing, is a breach of trust, and/or an indicator of massive process failure within the Mozilla organization.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by wybiral on Monday December 18, 2017 @08:29PM (#15957055)
The point is that they make a browser. I don't want anyone installing random stuff for a TV show into the program I use to access the internet without my consent.

Another example: https://blog.mozilla.org/press-uk/2017/10/06/testing-cliqz-i...

> This experiment also includes the data collection tool Cliqz uses to build its recommendation engine. Users who receive a version of Firefox with Cliqz will have their browsing activity sent to Cliqz servers, including the URLs of pages they visit.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Sylos on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:14AM (#15957937)
And directly following your quote:

> Cliqz uses several techniques to attempt to remove sensitive information from this browsing data before it is sent from Firefox. Cliqz does not build browsing profiles for individual users and discards the user’s IP address once the data is collected. Cliqz’s code is available for public review and a description of these techniques can be found here.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by blub on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @02:19AM (#15958381)
It's irrelevant whether spyware is open source or it uses anonymisation techniques.

Installed without explicit consent + collecting data = spyware.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Sylos on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:26PM (#15961860)
Retrofitting something into a definition does not help anyone. We have more precision available than calling it "spyware" can deliver, so argue around that. If you think their anonymisation techniques are faulty or you have reason to believe that Cliqz will violate the law by collecting personal data, then bring that forth.
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by niftich on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:53PM (#15956593)
It's unfortunate, I agree; but it's the principle of the matter.

This was the company who extolls privacy, openness, and attracts (among others) the sort of people who are uneasy at competing browsers shipped by advertising companies, or old-guard software shops pivoting into more profitable ways to leverage their installbase. This was the company who branded, then re-branded themselves as champions of a more people-conscious web. The exact company who should've known better.

Even their apology, though probably sincere, has a tinge of corporate, marketing wishwash. Maybe it's just the title, but a "We Messed Up" would've been punchier without being vulgar, instead of this bury-the-headline-style "Update on..." crap all too familiar from security vulnerabilities.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Sir_Substance on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:47PM (#15956546)
>Which is silly, IMO. What did this addon actually do, besides be installed without user consent?

1) Demonstrated that Mozilla has the ability to silently push addons without any kind of notification to the user that their browser behavior has been patched.

2) Demonstrated (allegedly) that there are privacy and security related preferences in Firefox that are reverting themselves to less-safe defaults without user interaction, aka Microsoft preferences.

3) Demonstrated Mozilla's marketing department lacks the good sense to respect these capabilities for the loaded gun they are

It's not about what they did, it's about what they could do. Mozilla doesn't need these tools, and these tools are dangerous. Why did they make them? Why shouldn't we ask Mozilla to remove them?

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by JoshTriplett on Monday December 18, 2017 @07:03PM (#15956653)
> 3) Demonstrated Mozilla's marketing department lacks the good sense to respect these capabilities for the loaded gun they are

This is the most critical issue, by far. Apparently nobody ran this by any reasonable person or went through any reasonable review process before shipping it.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by weaksauce on Monday December 18, 2017 @08:28PM (#15957051)
They may have some naive people running things. when you have millions of people running your software stuff like this tends to blow up. I personally don't see it as a huge issue of a breach of trust but I don't fault people for being mad about it.

This is nowhere near the level of naiveté that google had when they had a real name policy for some of their services that outed dissidents, LGBTQ people, and other marginalized people. Not even the same ballpark. If Mozilla really wanted to do something nefarious or bad they could have added things into the codebase directly instead of as an adjunct. I still trust Mozilla personally and I believe they are a net benefit to the internet.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by jotux on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:58PM (#15956628)
>Demonstrated that Mozilla has the ability to silently push addons without any kind of notification to the user that their browser behavior has been patched.

If you allow firefox updates they can silently push any code on to your machine, right?

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by itronitron on Monday December 18, 2017 @07:35PM (#15956803)
yes, and most people have grudgingly accepted the semi-weekly FF updates in order to receive the latest security updates... to hijack that update contract to push a marketing agenda is counter productive
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by PurpleRamen on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @05:56AM (#15959294)
Updates are under public view, and users can trust that this process is hard to infiltrate. Silent addon-installations in the background, which appearently can be even pinpointed to specific usergroups, are not. Mozilla can anytime do anything on your system, without anyone watching them, and people just learned the hard way about it.
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Yoric on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @02:08AM (#15958348)
> 1) Demonstrated that Mozilla has the ability to silently push addons without any kind of notification to the user that their browser behavior has been patched.

Wait, did someone assume that Mozilla didn't have this ability? How did people think that they got security updates?

> 2) Demonstrated (allegedly) that there are privacy and security related preferences in Firefox that are reverting themselves to less-safe defaults without user interaction, aka Microsoft preferences.

If that's the case, it's a bug. Bugs happen. Regardless, doesn't seem happen

> 3) Demonstrated Mozilla's marketing department lacks the good sense to respect these capabilities for the loaded gun they are

Fair enough, to some extent.

> It's not about what they did, it's about what they could do. Mozilla doesn't need these tools, and these tools are dangerous. Why did they make them? Why shouldn't we ask Mozilla to remove them?

Wait, what? Why does Mozilla have tools to distribute code? Because Mozilla uses it regularly to fix issues. This has been the case since Firefox 1.0, I assume.

Why does Mozilla have tools that handles and/or updates and/or forgets preferences? Because preferences can't be handled anywhere else, since they are preferences for Mozilla tools. I haven't heard of preferences being force-changed until now, with the exception of fighting malware and switching stuff from experimental to mainstream. But, yeah, bugs happen.

Why does Mozilla have a marketing department? I assume that's not a real question.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Sir_Substance on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @04:06AM (#15958802)
>Wait, did someone assume that Mozilla didn't have this ability? How did people think that they got security updates?

Via an updater that pops up a little window showing you Mozilla is installing stuff, or via an apt-get/yum/whatever command. Point is, it is (and should be) visible when Mozilla is pushing code.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by ajnin on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:03AM (#15959864)
> Wait, did someone assume that Mozilla didn't have this ability? How did people think that they got security updates?

The difference is that in one case the updates are released following a public process, with bugzilla entries, proper review and engineering practices, while in the other case it's pushed with no oversight, secretly, by some guy in marketing. It's like Google Tab Manager in your browser. Browsers are too sensitive, too central in people's lives nowadays to allow such things.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by revelation on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:37PM (#15956478)
It was activated, but not activated-activated (in that the addon gracefully decided to not do anything). But obviously we can't delegate that decision to the addons, that's why the addons pane exists after all.

Which begs the question: if you had to do something to activate it anyway, why abuse the "studies" sidechannel to install something that is deactivated, when you could just as well prompt to install it when it's meant to be activated?

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by DonHopkins on Monday December 18, 2017 @07:54PM (#15956910)
The "studies" sidechannel is the ideal place to distribute a deactivated plugin if you want curious people to activate because they want to test out new features. People subscribe to the studies sidechannel BECAUSE they want to try out new features, and those people tend to know about and use about:config, so it's likely many people will enable it, to see what it does.

And here's a bug report about something it does:

https://github.com/mozilla/addon-wr/issues/39

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by stordoff on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @01:06AM (#15958131)
> People subscribe to the studies sidechannel BECAUSE they want to try out new features

AFAIK, you are opted-in by default - I recently had to disable it on a clean installation.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Crespyl on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @11:44AM (#15961467)
You're right that "studies" is designed for distributing/testing experimental features, among other development and debugging uses.

I'd dispute any characterization of LookingGlass as a FireFox feature though, and feel very strongly that using Studies to distribute marketing software (inert or not) was an entirely inappropriate use of the tool.

Mozilla being willing to use Studies (or having a process that allows for it to be used) in this way means that, although I was fine with the extra telemetry, debugging, a/b testing, etc., I cannot trust Studies to be used strictly for development related things.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by wnevets on Monday December 18, 2017 @08:34PM (#15957072)
I kinda agree, I feel like this very important detail is being overlooked or out right ignored for the sake of raising pitchforks.
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by jacquesm on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:42PM (#15956510)
What it did is that it broke user trust, something that Mozilla used to be quite big on. Very bad mistake imo.
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Yoric on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @02:00AM (#15958317)
How did it break user trust? I mean, I see that some people are unhappy, and I can't say that this stuff was thoroughly thought out, but this was an add-on whose only effect on user's computer was... nothing, by design, unless you opted-in.
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by jimktrains2 on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:36PM (#15956470)
> Which is silly, IMO. What did this addon actually do, besides be installed without user consent?

Should be

> Which is silly, IMO. What did this addon actually do, besides break a trust and confidence that's been hard won over many years?

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by notatoad on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @02:40AM (#15958456)
If mozilla is willing to ship adware in their browser, how can i continue to trust them? the fact that this advertisment was innocuous is totally irrelevant, the problem is that there's nobody in the chain between marketing and product release that had the sense to say "hey, that's a terrible idea, we shouldn't do that to our users".
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by aaroninsf on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:34PM (#15956455)
Add-on was also closed source.

"Here, let me push closed source partner marketing materials on your bandwidth to you."

Directly contradictory to espoused values they trade on. Shameful.

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by jotux on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:41PM (#15956504)
>Add-on was also closed source.

What made you think it was closed source? The source for the add-on: https://github.com/mozilla/addon-wr

Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by tomc1985 on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:41PM (#15956505)
Not very different from Pocket nor Hello?
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by Sir_Substance on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:48PM (#15956556)
Neither of which should have been included in the core browser (even though I quite liked hello, and have been using appear.in, it's more stable cousin, for years now)
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by cuckcuckspruce on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:37PM (#15956474)
It's almost worse they didn't make any money for it. Shows what price they put on your privacy and autonomy.
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by wasted_intel on Monday December 18, 2017 @11:29PM (#15957768)
How can that possibly be a downside? If they had made money, people would be even more up in arms. If anything, this reinforces the “Easter egg” intent of the extension; it serves no other purpose.
Re:Update: Looking Glass Add-On by ovao on Monday December 18, 2017 @06:50PM (#15956577)
"Even when turned on no user data was collected or shared."