News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by wbl on Saturday December 16, 2017 @07:38PM (#15943186)
We've already got the technology to do that. It's called a train.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by intopieces on Saturday December 16, 2017 @08:30PM (#15943396)
Trains don't pick you up where you live and drop you off where you work. Self driving cars can do this.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by chrisseaton on Sunday December 17, 2017 @06:58AM (#15945403)
> Trains don't pick you up where you live and drop you off where you work.

Trains manage to do that in most countries, given a few minutes walk to and from a station.

I don't commute now but I used to commute two hours in the UK, and I walked 3 minutes to a train station, and then took a couple of trains all the way, and then a 3 minute walk at the other end to my office. And I lived in a small village not a major area.

Why can't they do it in the US?

Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by mainguy on Sunday December 17, 2017 @07:44AM (#15945535)
Because the UK is a bit over half the size of California. Many folks in Europe tend to under appreciate the sheer size of the United States. To your point though...certain metro areas are largely this way...(NY/Chicago)...but others (LA/Detroit) are not... Not sure why some cities invest and others don't.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by chrisseaton on Sunday December 17, 2017 @07:54AM (#15945570)
Everyone says it's due to the size difference. That doesn't make any sense to me!

Take just the Northern California region, then, around the same size as the UK. Now there's no argument about size difference. The population is around a third of the UK, so while that's less and so lower density, it isn't a crazy difference and the major areas of population themselves where you need the stations are high density.

I can go from any city in the UK, to any other city in the UK, via a couple of trains pretty effortlessly. Why couldn't that be replicated in an area of the same size and more of less the same population, in California?

Why can't it be replicated just in the Bay Area even! Why aren't there lots of trains there?!

Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by intopieces on Sunday December 17, 2017 @11:38AM (#15946393)
>Why aren’t there lots of trains there?

1.) The Bay Area is made up of 100 cities and towns and several counties. There is not a single “Bay Area government.” Every single transit project has to be approved by several levels of government and funded by the state and federal government. Moreover, that funding and consent has to last for decades to keep the project on track. It rarely does. Every train line in the Bay Area was the result of a fight.

2.) Trains require density to be feasible. Density increases the supply of housing, driving down the value of existing single family homes. Owners of single family homes store a significant amount of their net worth in the equity of those homes. Municipalities rely on the property taxes from those high value homes.

3.) The Bay Area is not zoned for density. Trains will not catch on here because 60 odd years ago the people who designed the highway system did not consider the possibility that many people would need to live close together to make the place affordable. No one was thinking of affordable housing then.

Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by chrisseaton on Sunday December 17, 2017 @12:04PM (#15946519)
> Trains require density to be feasible

But the density of even the wider Bay Area region (the CSA) is higher than the entire UK! How come that's dense enough for lots of trains in the UK but not dense enough for trains around the Bay Area?

Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by bshimmin on Sunday December 17, 2017 @10:22AM (#15946060)
I think this definitely depends where you live in the UK and how much your local rail network was screwed by the Beeching cuts. I live in Somerset and the two nearest railway stations are more than a 30 minute drive.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by carbocation on Saturday December 16, 2017 @08:34PM (#15943416)
Imagine a combination of self-driving cars and trains. Perhaps the self-driving car can take you to the train station that is nearest, if there is a train that is coming in a reasonable amount of time.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by intopieces on Saturday December 16, 2017 @08:38PM (#15943432)
For trains to be truly useful, we needed to not build our cities around the highway, around sprawl. We didn't do that. So self-driving cars will prove to be far, far more useful than trains, especially since trains require long term public investment, which Americans generally do not favor.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by ecshafer on Saturday December 16, 2017 @09:01PM (#15943529)
We can change that. The current city is built around an combination of parking minimums, subsidized free parking, and a system that supports building detached single family homes and not dense mixed use housing.

If we change the policies that ruin the cities and design them around the human and not the car, we can make transit work more.

Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by intopieces on Saturday December 16, 2017 @10:26PM (#15943888)
We absolutely can change that and we absolutely won't. Rich people don't like transit, they like personal vehicles and sprawling neighborhoods, not loud trains and dense apartment blocks. Rich people write laws.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by wbl on Saturday December 16, 2017 @11:01PM (#15944009)
So no millionaires live in Manhattan?
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by stuxnet79 on Saturday December 16, 2017 @07:41PM (#15943198)
I had to laugh at this. Crazy how car-centric some regions are.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by strictnein on Saturday December 16, 2017 @08:32PM (#15943409)
I'm not sure why the inaccurate statement that a train can pick you up at your house and drop you off at work made you think about how "car-centric" some regions are.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by wbl on Saturday December 16, 2017 @11:00PM (#15944001)
The World Trade Center is over a train stop. A typical Wall Street commute is two five minute walks at either end of a train ride.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by strictnein on Saturday December 16, 2017 @11:22PM (#15944077)
This doesn't improve your argument.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by closeparen on Saturday December 16, 2017 @08:58PM (#15943521)
A train picks you up where you live only if you are a 1%er who can afford the extreme real estate premium for transit access on an infrequently spaced system (i.e. BART), or the train stops so frequency that it barely adds value relative to a bicycle (i.e. Muni).
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by s0rce on Saturday December 16, 2017 @09:15PM (#15943591)
I suggest, if you haven't you visit London, many places, not all expensive, are a 5-10 minute walk to a regional train stop that can get you to city center in 45minutes.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by closeparen on Saturday December 16, 2017 @09:57PM (#15943765)
I will have to check that out! I suspect that these neighborhoods have a level of density that, if proposed in a typical American suburb, would spark cries of "Manhattanization."
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by wutbrodo on Saturday December 16, 2017 @10:32PM (#15943910)
> I suspect that these neighborhoods have a level of density that, if proposed in a typical American suburb, would spark cries of "Manhattanization."

Well yea, density is what enables a transit-centric, and American having an intense phobia of density is part of what makes them so car-centric.

Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by s0rce on Saturday December 16, 2017 @11:03PM (#15944020)
There is a big middle ground between suburban ranch homes on 0.25 acres and "Manhattan", see some nice areas of dense row (aka. townhouses) houses in London suburbs.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by drieddust on Saturday December 16, 2017 @11:03PM (#15944021)
I have travelled in London for 5 years and it is anything but predictable. My commute of 45 minutes would last anywhere between 45 minutes to two hours depending upon the excuses they will cookup. Sometimes my train travel will be converted to a nice picnic on London bus as train will be cancelled abruptly. Their list of excuses is legendary[1].

And then comes these patronising messages "This [Chrismas|Easter|Weekend|Holiday] I am working for you." I saw those messages for 5 years and still saw services going downhill.

One funny anecdote probably illustrates their lethargy. Station I used to board from was upgraded and platform extended to allow boarding from 10 carriages. This happened long before I started living their. But announcement always said only 9 carriages will open. I lived their for two years and same message was played everyday.

[1] https://www.standard.co.uk/news/a-year-of-excuses-to-rail-ag... [2] https://www.networkrailmediacentre.co.uk/news/check-before-y...

Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by drieddust on Sunday December 17, 2017 @10:07PM (#15949099)
Wow, downvotes for stating the facts. I couldn't care less for votes but would still like if someone care to explain what is wrong with my statements?
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by closeparen on Monday December 18, 2017 @12:11AM (#15949593)
I didn't downvote you, but something about systematic on-time performance metrics might have been more helpful than your personal dissatisfaction with delays?

Blaming transit workers for system performance is also pretty controversial; most would probably attribute that to incompetent management or stingy taxpayers?

Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by Terretta on Saturday December 16, 2017 @07:47PM (#15943222)
FTA:

”The train leaves at 4:43 a.m. and Cherry, 60 years old and a couple of years away from retirement, rides it all the way to the final stop, more than two hours away. That’s Union Station in downtown Los Angeles. Scheduled arrival time: 7:05.”

Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by noobermin on Saturday December 16, 2017 @08:18PM (#15943342)
The solution to this is: more train lines, more frequent and faster trains.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by knowaveragejoe on Saturday December 16, 2017 @07:45PM (#15943210)
Not quite, at least not in the US.
Re:Her six-hour commute each day seems crazy, but her afford... by lykr0n on Saturday December 16, 2017 @07:46PM (#15943218)
The NYC/Hudson Valley area has this.