Also, the article mentions the de facto centralization of trust in the current cryptocurrency ecosystem - so pragmatically, it's not much better there. From centralized exchanges, to centralized mining cartels, what does something like Bitcoin have left to offer?
The Stellar Consensus Protocol, which MobileCoin say they're using, uses something more akin to a web of trust rather than proof-of-work. You do not need the SGX to get rid of proof-of-work.
Oh, dear lord.
> ultimately not as advanced as its younger brethren.
These must then be simply out of this world. Superwonder technologies. Double digit transactions per second!! /$
The hype around this piece of software is getting out of hand.
Said by a guy you just witness the historical invention of the wheel.
The wheel was, in fact, one of the first instances of a centralized structure replacing an inefficieint distributed structure.
The central "hub" of a wheel bears the load and the "edge condition" is the substantially reduced "rolling friction".
This is in contrast to ye old "distributed load" way of a zillion poor slaves pulling a load.
So as far as the "wheel" goes, VISA is a chariot, and Bitcoin is an army of slaves pulling a wheel-less load.
And in fact, the "facts", prove this. Almost 400 KWh per transaction, and that at the feeble rate of 7 tx/sec.
That is your "technological wonder".
point 2:
"Technological wonder[s]" of this time -- now -- are Machine Learning, CRISPR, etc. These are the "inventions" to pay attention to, not a thinly disguised play by private wealth to finally fully take out the national governments from the monetary system loop.
That CJW -- Crypto Justice Warriors -- like you fail to see this is the actual "wonder".
About the wheel. Rolling friction is less than sliding friction... Regrettably that point is probably over your head.
+1 for your ad hom.
Or do you mean the revolutionary scamming techniques never seen before? /s
Before bitcoin you would be unable to create a virtual currency without a central authority. Satoshi's algorithm was a new invention in 2009, although it's parts - like proof of Work - were invented in 1990s.
Until that happens, there's still money to be made!
Not all ciphers... 3DES and GOST have no practical breaks after 40 years of cryptanalysis (all attacks have > 2^100 time or memory complexity)
Any secure modern 256 bit symmetric primitive is likely safe from large quantum computers.
What will continue to be be broken are encryption protocols and systems that misuse modern secure 256-bit primitives. So we will continue to see things like the BEAST attack because non-cryptographers continue to invent their own encryption protocols with alarming frequency.
In this case you only have one single point of failure: Intel. If that breaks, what then?
From a pure efficiency/centralization perspective, there are likely better cryptocurrencies out there. I think Ethereum's sharding network is interesting, too, and it seems to maintain a high-degree of decentralization, but I don't know how easy it will be to implement:
In that case, one might as well go with any of the permissioned blockchains (such as Interplanetary database where the nodes are run by reputed non-profits for a minimal fee).
I'd say you're being overdramatic here. Mining is still decentralised and if there are any mining cartels, they haven't abused their position yet. It's still possible to buy, sell and spend Bitcoin peer to peer as well.
Controlled by a handful of people is absolutely not decentralized.
They have abused their power. Ghash double spends. Segwit blocked for a year. Bitcoin cash proxy support.
Wait what, no.
Did you read about Ethereum's Casper and proof of stake? Or dpos - implemented in Eos et all?
> This means that the ledger is "public" and distributed to all MobileCoin nodes, but will also simultaneously never be accessible or viewable by humans (even the operators of the MobileCoin nodes) so long as SGX and the MobileCoin software remains secure.
It seems unlikely to me that these two things things will remain the case.
> A client can perform remote attestation to its MobileCoin node before transmitting its keys into the remote enclave along with a short recovery PIN.
And it seems if SGX gets popped the whole thing comes crumbling down.
Quotes from https://www.mobilecoin.com/whitepaper-en.pdf
And to some degree, the success of Signal, or Signal's protocol as implemented widely used services in WhatsApp, supports his approach. If cypherpunk-purists had their way, encryption would still only be a thing exclusively used by a slim minority of nerds who are capable of managing PGP and all the complications that come with its fragile nature.
However I'm not really convinced Signal is all that secure in the Android ecosystem, and I trust Open Whisper Systems even less than bigger tech companies to not fold under pressure.
Bitcoin was designed to be as decentralised as possible. It turns out this has serious downsides and it’s difficult to pursue the sort of financial revolution it aspires to without social revolution.
This currency chooses different trade-offs which the creators believe will make it more popular because most people don’t need or want trustless transactions. People delegate power for finance, politics and computing not because they are stupid or serfs but because they are willing to sacrifice some autonomy for the speed, ease of use and enforceable contracts which come with a central authority.
I actually chose to refer to 'feudal security' as coined by Schneier (at least in the context of computer security), because it is such a compelling and balanced approach to the exact same trade-offs you're describing.
No, an argument is strong or weak regardless of whether you like the words used to express it.
As disappointing as it might be pure logic is rarely enough in the real world.
A manufacturer may 'legitimately' establish an enclave in your most trusted hardware which you may not audit or even measure. And if that security model becomes commonplace, for example when only allowing Widevine DRM inside SGX, you eventually cannot use your self-chosen hardware, but will have to pick a feudal lord from a limited set of 'ecosystem choices'.
[1] https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2013/06/more_on_feuda...