Coinbase is insured by AON Insurance for their hot wallet balance. However, we won't know how Coinbase/AON will handle that until it happens.
I believe any fiat balance is also insured by the FDIC, but I'm less sure about that.
>2) The exchange can't go down, like at all.
Yep. Crypto trades 24/7. It's really surprising they don't have regular planned downtime to address this.
They can refund in fiat of course, but that's the point. If fiat didn't exist then this would be a potentially insurmountable problem if the theft were large enough.
Now what happens if the thief panics or screws up and deletes their keys. Those Bitcoins are now lost forever. The money supply just went down permanently.
... or ... a really smart thief with enough money behind them might not even need to steal any Bitcoins. They could just destroy cold wallet keys in a very stealthy way and profit from the appreciation of coins they hold elsewhere.
This whole system is just not ready for prime time.
This is a cool idea but I'm not sure it works (or I don't understand it correctly). In order to reduce the supply enough to appreciably increase the value of the remaining coins, you'd need to freeze/destroy a lot of keys, or keys to wallets with large holdings. If the owners of those keys start reporting their losses and the news spreads, people could start to lose confidence in bitcoin itself and move to other assets, reducing demand.
By only promising depositors -- and only having insurance for the case that -- they will pay out some flat USD amount per bitcoin in the case of loss, so that anyone putting BTC in Coinbase wallets knows the possible downside.
Same logic as with most insurance: they don't write policies that promise to get you that a good-enough copy of that neat classic showerhead fitting when your house burns down, only the money to buy a replacement, even if it falls short of the sentimental value.
People lose their bitcoins. It's as simple as that. That's a risk everyone should understand before buying.
They might be compensated in some other way, like fiat, and then the insurance company either picks up the bill or goes under. Then it's just business as usual as far as bankruptcy goes.
So yes, you have every reason to be wary of exchange solvency because of how new they are and how little support is provided to them by government and law enforcement compared to the banks. Every investor should understand that as critically as they understand how important their wallets are.
>This whole system is just not ready for prime time.
Yeah, it's one big experiment. I'm sure these problems were encountered before in economic history, but it seems like they are repeating a bunch of blunders within a short time frame, which to me, smells of manipulation (Satoshi probably didn't invent it to just manipulate people)
/s
Mature markets have thin margins, which is why you see financial institutions salivating over crypto right now. All these risks have been known for years now.
Hence its deflationary nature.
The NYSE is not vulnerable to this kind of attack. Anyone dealing with BTC is.
That's the inherent risk with crypto. You have to resort to "leg-breaking" to get the thief to give up the coin. Otherwise you'd need undue influence on the development and forking of the blockchain to get them back (if I understand it right -- I may not).
That's why many will say to not keep your coins on an exchange, because they are weaker businesses compared to existing financial institutions.
That's not to say you can't secure your investments properly, but to many, it takes a lot of time and effort to get it right.
It really is a "let the buyer beware" landscape.
Insurance policies for bitcoins are very new and very tricky. This is not an FDIC or SPIC insurance unless AON is insuring cash balances you should treat this insurance as you would treat mob protection - hopefuly you won't need it because if you do you are kind of screwed and probably won't be able to collect.
Source: I work for a hedge fund.
Strange comment, I think I've confused you.
All this was about exchanges and what hedge funds expect from them, not guarantees about what hedge funds provide.
And you are right, exchanges do go down, and its news when they do because they are so good at what they do that its very rare.
> I don't know what reality you operate in
I operate in the US Cash Equities and options markets. What I've asked for is par for the course there, in that no one mentions it because its the very lowest base, must have requirements.:)
When was the last time you heard of Goldman Sachs begin hacked and all the hedge funds that use them as a prime loosing all their money?
I used to work for a startup that wrote software for hedge funds (this was back in 05-07). The guys from Fidelity would come in and they'd have a huge checklist of IT best practices that you need to adhere to, everything from security to backups to SLAs with financial penalties for violating them. The guys from Magnetar would come in and be like "Sure, we'll try anything that gives us an advantage in the markets."
I suspect that your idea of what's "par for the course" and the "very lowest base" is pretty far from what's actually the lowest base in the financial industry, and similarly I suspect that brndnmtthws's view of what's typical for a hedge fund isn't typical for all hedge funds.
And yet, it has absolutely nothing to do with what we are talking about:)
Which is what exchanges need to do to get institutional investors;)
Goldman Sachs is not an exchange.
> it has absolutely nothing to do with what we are talking about:)
Exactly. You are confusing others by giving GS as an example, while we're talking about exchanges.
Coinbase right now acts in two ways.
1) as an exchange who allows you to trade on it.
2) as a prime broker who holds your coins. In this capacity they are just like Goldman Sachs who can function as a prime broker for hedge funds.
(a prime broker is like a bank who holds your securities for you). So in this case Goldman is relevant as they do the same function that coinbase does with respect to holding securities on behalf of a client.
Does that help clear up the confusion?
No, it adds.
> So in this case Goldman is relevant as they do the same function that coinbase does with respect to holding securities on behalf of a client.
Then why did you write in your other message that Goldman Sachs has got nothing to do with this discussion? It seems to me that you are confused. Please decide whether you think the Goldman Sachs is relevant or not before proceeding.
Yeah, no. Tape is reversed all the time in event of oops. Probably the most famous one was when Knight [NITE] had "oops" and started making markets in itself, tanked the stock, had millions of dollars executed against it and got NASDAQ to REVERSE completed transactions, including the ones painted via SOES.
This point may prove to be very sticky.
It might be solvable with smart contracts... consider ethereum's https://www.etherdelta.com, which operates as an auditable smart contract. Your money literally can't be stolen without your private key; even when it's held in escrow by the contract. (Of course, a bug in the contract code could let someone get through; but that's all out in the open, so easier to check for).
I could see something like that being done, with the individual trade data being signed, but held off-chain until the user wanted to make a transfer (then ALL signed movements related to them could be consolidated on the chain).
---
Short of that, a centralized exchange is gonna run into the fundamental issue that cryptocurrencies have value because of a few properties; Chief among them being that they can be moved atomically, and with non-repudiation. Those two alone make theft a LOT easier to get away with once achieved.
Being able to walk back such thefts would require general consensus of the network. For most coins, the majority of participants would see that as a fatal weakening of the protocol's guarantees, and drop out. The highest profile rollback I can think of was ETH's june 2017 DAO incident. Even that proved rather controversial: though the market voted in favor in the end, it was a messy out-of-band solution, which may not work again.
---
Conversely, some lesser coins such as NAV actually formalized "consensus voting" on such out-of-band issues as part of their network protocol. I could potentially see that being used as a final band-aid, though "tyranny of the majority" issues would seriously need solving. NAV uses proof-of-stake, though, which certainly helps keep their voting in the "put your money where your mouth is" territory.
All in all, I think there are potentially some trustless and "semi-trustless consensus" methods that could solve this issue in revolutionary ways. But none of them are tested... Coinbase may just have to get themselves massively insured using traditional methods, at least for a few more years as the tech expands.
Shouldn't be that hard, even using just the features available in Bitcoin today. You'd need a 2-of-2 multisignature wallet for each account holder, with one key held by Coinbase and the other by the user. When the user wants to spend some coins, he or she signs a transaction which Coinbase prepares and counter-signs; neither the user nor Coinbase—or an attacker with access to Coinbase's keys—can transfer the funds unilaterally.
The only thing missing is a convenient UI.
I think the mainly catch would be scaling the speed (etherdelta is limited to the ETH network block rate). I don't know too much about lightning's details, but given that they've demonstrated atomic cross-chain swaps, I bet it's set up to handle something exactly like what's needed.
Which is quite exciting... I just always moderate my enthusiasm because for all complex software projects, the devil (and 80% of the work) is in the details :)
If they can’t insure deposits, then that shows a fundamental weakness in the security model.
(Admittedly the website is housed somewhere, but it's little more than a GUI shell for signing procedure calls, you could run it locally or interact directly).
I think the big issue hindering that model is that they need something allowing users to pipe into traditional currencies. So far all the solutions to that have been IOU tokens like USDT tethers; which end up generating governance headaches of their own, as their value desyncs from their base currency due to arbitrage & supply issues.
I do think the surface area for attack is much more limited, since the code is innately public (unlike centralized trading houses).
That (in theory) should make them more secure, particularly if considered in terms of the transparency provided. I also think theorem proving, and languages amenable to it, can greatly reduce the surface area even further; reducing it down to a matter of reviewing what assertions the theorem prover was handed, along with trusting the VM's implementation itself. (The later is also helped by having multiple independant implementations).
But I don't think the tech is there yet. The languages currently being used aren't the greatest for theorem proving; no one's actually done much of that in practice anyways; there aren't "best practices" for upgrading your smart contract when a bug is found; and there's ALWAYS an assertion someone forgot to add to the test suite.
But I do think smart contracts could remove "server compromise" and "unauditable code" from the list of main dangers of an exchange, which does seem quite useful in the long term (once the ecosystem fleshes out a bit).
It's hard to tell how many layers of security you need when you're holding tens or hundreds of millions of digital assets that don't require a physical breaking and entering, and when the entire blackhat world is eyeing you as a target.
Counterparty risk? What counterparty risk? The minute the funds leave your wallet governed by your private keys then you no longer have control. The moment you transfer funds then they no longer belong to you. By design!
Downtime? What downtime? If individual nodes go offline then the network continues to function. Bitcoin is a decentralized protocol. By design!
Perhaps instead of trying to hack centralized banking models onto decentralized currencies we should be using decentralized models to fit the currency. Perhaps, instead of Coinbase claiming to hold Bitcoin in the name of account holders, it should facilitate the immediate transfer of Bitcoin to the private wallets of people who are purchasing it and refuse purchases of people without wallets set up. Perhaps Coinbase should allow transaction fees to skyrocket as a result (even more than they have currently), due to not processing transactions off-chain, and that this would be fine, because it would push demand towards cryptocurrencies with lower fees.
Bitcoin exchanges won't mature until they're less like traditional stock brokers and more like BitTorrent trackers - they don't actually host the files or the money, but tell you where to find people who do, who you can exchange with directly in a decentralized way.
All exchanges do this to one extent or another. To minimize risks they would need to accept cash and never accept bitcoins to their own wallet which would cause massive transaction fees.
As you point out, this causes massive transaction fees, but that's built into the model. The transaction fees would be lower if they would increase the block size....
No it is not. Coinbase has clients all over the globe. It is always regular trading hours.
The fact that Coinbase has clients globally is not pertinent to the discussion (or only insofar as the distribution of those clients could influence at what time you'd want to put a daily trading break).
However, granted, a 10 minute trading break daily looks like too much effort to be worth it. A scheduled monthly break of an hour or so sounds reasonable.
If that were peak-trading time for a particular locale that would be unfortunate, but the regularity would be preferred to failing under unexpected load at random times of the day.
Actually, banks get hacked and lose cash. Permanently. It happens rarely, but it happens. For example in this SWIFT hack authorities were able to recover only $18 out of $81 million with the remainder $63 million permanently lost: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bangladesh_Bank_robbery
2. Exchanges do go down, the only question is how often. If the exchange does go down, you want the exchange to say, "We're doing our best, but volume has exceeded our capacity. We'll be up as soon as we can." The alternative is to continue to accept trades and pretend that everything is okay. Honesty is good.
Same with your comment about exchanges - yes the NYSE and NASDAQ can go down. Once or twice a year. For 20 minutes. Coinbase (and Gemini and GDAX and Kraken and everyone) are going down for about x5 times that in any given week. Which is not a "a small qualitative difference". It's an infinite difference.
Getting your Bitcoin back after it drops to $5 isn't much consolation if you were unable to trade at $15,000.
you probably should... but it might haven gotten better in the last couple weeks.
> If you need someone to trust, you’re doing it wrong.
You can't do anything in crypto without having to rely on someone else. Trust is not irrelevant in cryptocurrencies - it matters just as much as in traditional markets.
SIPC insurance will protect you up to a certain amount. Even then, though, you won't have your shares returned to you -- merely the dollar value of those shares will be reimbursed.
Yuck, this blew up and I think alot of people took it the wrong way. I think Coinbase is great, and I'm sure everyone who works there is awesome and terrific at their job.
Anyone who has worked on any half way successful project knows just how hard both uptime and security are and I'm in no way upset at Coinbase for having growth issues.
I've done this for years and might not even get an interview with them. They'll be fine, they're just learning how to deal with alot of hard issues all at once.
The question was posed, what do you need to do to get institutional money and I answered.
To clarify...
Coinbase , atleast from a hedge funds perspective has 2 tasks.
1) prime broker or custodian, from this perspective you just can't be hacked and loose anyone's bitcoins.
Not sure how a hedge fund would tell its clients that they lost any amount of their funds due to an exchange being hacked, this is just so foreign to the way the markets currently work. I don't think the funds clients would be too accepting of a loss of any amount due to this.
2) as an exchange, This is probably easy for people to understand. When the volume picks up that's when you make your money. If Volume causes the exchange to go down, you can't make money.
Again this is very rare for most markets now to go down to volume and when it does it doesn't really matter too much because the concept of having your shares with an exchange doesn't really make sense in the equities market.
You'd just start trading at another exchange and none of your shares are actually held with the exchange, nor do you need to send shares to an exchange to trade, you just trade and settle at the end of the day.
EDIT END
I'll preface this by saying, what I'm asking for is hard, very hard, but being a grown up is hard..... You can't just ask people to invest billions of other peoples money and then claim "best efforts" if your exchange crashes under load.
Well what institutional investors want is pretty simple to understand, though very hard to implement.
1) No counterparty risk. Everyone can get hacked, but coinbase being hacked shouldn't every, under any circumstances result in me loosing any bitcoin they hold on my behalf.
A hedge fund can't just go to their clients and say sorry, lost all our money, coinbase got hacked, the hedge fund itself and its principles would be sued into oblivion.
I mean if the Nasdaq, NYSE or prime broker ever got hacked, no one would expect to suddenly loose all their shares, or cash held with their prime broker.
2) The exchange can't go down, like at all. Once a year for 5 minutes is fine, or every day at midnight for 10 minutes is fine, but during regular trading hours you can't just throw your hand up and say "hey, best efforts here there just alot of volume right now, we'll be up in a few minutes"
Hedge funds make their money on volatility, which means the more volatile and busy the exchange is the more they'll want to trade. Going down when times are busy is just can't happen.