News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by Crontab on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:03PM (#15927578)
It's a crying shame when you need a VPN to protect yourself from you ISP.
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by AFNobody on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:31PM (#15927824)
It would be a shame if your VPN was in the slow lane and could only push 56k because fast lane services being sold to "unsavory" businesses were against policy at the 2 major residential ISPs you can choose from.
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by dorchadas on Thursday December 14, 2017 @08:46PM (#15929093)
And only one of which offers reasonable speeds at reasonable prices.
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by Feniks on Thursday December 14, 2017 @06:11PM (#15928179)
Don't worry VPNs will be illegal soon ;)
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by guiambros on Thursday December 14, 2017 @08:52PM (#15929115)
Not illegal; just "+$49.99 for the VPN Package".
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by Doxin on Friday December 15, 2017 @08:03AM (#15931453)
I can imagine a "service fee" for allowing any encrypted traffic at all. They could easily market it as a security enhancing premium feature.
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by smilekzs on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:08PM (#15927634)
> The user should have checked their email spam folder

How about NO?

Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by tehlike on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:13PM (#15927669)
More reasons to use free letsencrypt certs.
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by GCU-Empiricist on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:16PM (#15927694)
This is yet another example of why Comcast could not pay me to use their service.
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by scarface74 on Thursday December 14, 2017 @06:38PM (#15928415)
Many people don't have a choice. Either Comcast or slow DSL from the phone company.
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by 8ytecoder on Thursday December 14, 2017 @06:42PM (#15928455)
This is the sad reality in some cities in the Bay Area (of all the places in the world). With 4k content and at least 10 connected devices in a house going back to a 10Mbps line is a PITA. But a PITA we may have to live with to support local ISPs and express our displeasure with Comcast.
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by steanne on Friday December 15, 2017 @02:11AM (#15930170)
i have the choice of comcast, slow dsl from the phone company, or fiber from the phone company. i choose the slow dsl because that has consumer protections from the state's utility commission. the fiber does not. the phone company is not too happy with me.
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by khedoros1 on Friday December 15, 2017 @04:02AM (#15930534)
I have the choice of Cox (which did this injected pop-up thing a few years ago, and for the same reason), and getting creative with mobile/satellite providers.

Phone company says that I'm too far for DSL, and they haven't deployed fiber to this area.

It would be nice if I had some kind of actual choice.

Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:24PM (#15927768)
I hope the guy at comcast searching through false positives gets paid.
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by steanne on Friday December 15, 2017 @02:18AM (#15930189)
a lot more discussion here[0], including responses from comcast's own jlivingood[1]

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15890551

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=jlivingood

Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by dang on Thursday December 14, 2017 @06:40PM (#15928438)
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by larrik on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:05PM (#15927596)
I love bashing Comcast, but this seems extremely overblown.
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by philipwhiuk on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:09PM (#15927636)
You think it's overblown they are performing DPI and a MiTM attack on content traversing across their network?
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by bigiain on Thursday December 14, 2017 @06:01PM (#15928097)
I'm also somewhat creeped out by the suggestion that "The notice is typically sent after a customer ignores several emails." - so not only are they injecting Javascript into pages you're browsing, but they're doing it in an individually targeted fashion having correlated it with email they've sent you and possibly data sent (or not sent) via tracking bugs in those emails...

And they're getting it all wrong, sending it to customers who's modems do _not_ need upgrading... Doesn't exactly inspire confidence in their ability to manage and secure the Javascript injection mechanism...

Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by kemitche on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:43PM (#15927942)
IF Comcast had actually been legitimately trying to contact the customer via other means (phone, letter, email) AND it was a significant issue (end of life on modem), then it's not unreasonable.

I rather doubt that Comcast tried the phone route, and the article indicates that the modem was not EOL, so overall I think the injection was ridiculous.

Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by pdkl95 on Thursday December 14, 2017 @06:08PM (#15928159)
Willful copyright infringement[1] doesn't go away if you cannot contact the recipient of the unauthorized copy by "phone letter, email". Comcast is infringing the copyright of every webpage they modify without permission.

[1] Modifying an HTML file[2] (or any other protected work) creates a "derivative work"[3\. Without permission from the original author, distributing a copy of a derivative work is copyright infringement.

[2] Any "original work of authorship"[4] gains copyright protection when "fixed in any tangible medium of expression ... from which they can be perceived, reproduced, or otherwise communicated, either directly or with the aid of a machine or device."[4].

[3] "A work consisting of editorial revisions, annotations, elaborations, or other modifications which, as a whole, represent an original work of authorship, is a 'derivative work'."[5]

[4] 17 U.S. Code § 102 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/102

[5] 17 U.S. Code § 101 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/101

Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by nkurz on Thursday December 14, 2017 @07:15PM (#15928684)
Comcast is infringing the copyright of every webpage they modify without permission.

They may or may not be, but you are foolish to assert that they are infringing based on on a few select quotes. Are you also going to assert that it's also a copyright infringement every time a browser caches part of a web page to disk, or when a user runs an script to change the layout of a page? Both arguments have been made, but as far as I know, there is no clear precedent for either. For better or worse, US law is based on case-law, and unless you can point to some previous cases where modifying a web page on the fly has been judged to be copyright infringement, there is nothing open-and-shut about it.

Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by pdkl95 on Thursday December 14, 2017 @08:28PM (#15929023)
> you are foolish to assert that they are infringing based on on a few select quotes

I only included a few quotes for reference. My argument is based on my study of copyright law over the last ~25 years.

> browser caches part of a web page to disk

Obviously not a derivative work as the HTML file is not changed. Also, this is a fair use that doesn't publish additional copies (and thus doesn't impact the market for the original work).

> a user runs an script to change the layout of a page

First Sale doctrine states that the publisher's rights do not extend to how someone uses their (legitimately acquired) copy.

> there is no clear precedent for either

The only part that is at all unclear are the few cases that ruled on the temporary, ephemeral copies that a computer makes during normal use. These cases all resulted in different rulings, but the most recent of which (which may only have limited precedent) came to what should be the obvious conclusion that technically necessary temporary copies were a fair use.

None of this, however, is relevant to Comcast making new derivative works based other people's HTML files without a license and providing a copy of those derivative works to their customers. Providing unauthorized edited copies to 3rd parties has never been argued to be a fair use. ]

Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by nkurz on Thursday December 14, 2017 @08:53PM (#15929116)
Providing unauthorized edited copies to 3rd parties has never been argued to be a fair use.

Well, it's definitely been argued, although you are right that eventually the court decided that it was not fair use to distribute "family friendly" version of movies. Perhaps counterintuitively, despite ruling strongly against CleanFlicks, the judge ruled that the because the changes were based only on redaction, the edited version was not to be considered a derivative work! https://freedom-to-tinker.com/2006/07/10/cleanflicks-ruled-i...

The Family Movie Act of 2005 further codified this right to redact, using the argument that if the edited version was only used for a "private home viewing", it did not violate the right of distribution: https://www.copyright.gov/docs/regstat061704.html.

None of this, however, is relevant to Comcast making new derivative works based other people's HTML files without a license and providing a copy of those derivative works to their customers.

Would a similar argument as to single viewer experience work in Comcast's case? I don't know, but in the absence of settled case law, I wouldn't bet against Comcast's lawyers getting a court to give the answer they want.

But maybe I can make it an easier question: Based on what they've done so far, what are the chances that Comcast will be sued for copyright infringement and lose? I don't have a lot of money to bet, but I think the chances are low that successful lawsuit against Comcast will be brought for what they've done. Do you think otherwise?

Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by nkurz on Thursday December 14, 2017 @06:59PM (#15928574)
Yes, I think it's overblown.

I got what I think is this same message from Comcast a little over a year ago at my father-in-laws house. It alerted me that I needed to upgrade his still working but End-Of-Life cable modem to a newer model to keep continuity of service. I recall being slightly alarmed by the injection, and then somewhat disappointed that they weren't going to continue support for the old modem, but my eventual conclusion was that this was a useful last ditch effort to contact a customer. His contact email for for Comcast is in unchecked comcast.net address, the mailed notifications probably were thrown away as junk mail, he gets multiple spam phone calls per day which he usually ignores, but this message got through.

Surreptitiously modifying web pages would be atrocious, but a last-ditch effort at notifying a customer that they are about to lose service is not the same as Man-In-The-Middle attack for nefarious purposes. I agree that there is a legitimate fear that once it becomes known within the company that this capability exists it will eventually be used for something worse, but (even as someone who despises a lot of Comcast's business practices) alerting customers that they are about to lose service is not something evil in itself.

Everyone technical knows (or should know) that their ISP can modify the content of non-encrypted pages. I can't help but think that most people who complaining about this are actually more distraught at having their illusion of security broken than they are at Comcast's behavior. Getting mad at this is like threatening to sue the locksmith you hired for demonstrating how easily your current locks are easily bypassed with a bump key. The problem is not with the legitimate uses of this sort of injection, but the potential for misuse, which has not yet been demonstrated.

Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by StanislavPetrov on Thursday December 14, 2017 @07:24PM (#15928729)
I completely disagree with you, but all that aside, why didn't Comcast stop sending these messages after the customer contacted them to tell them he had seen and received their message? Continuing to contact and message someone who specifically tells you to stop is the definition of harassment. Perhaps those people being harassed by Comcast should start sending all forms of messages to Comcast executives and board members, until they got the message.
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by nkurz on Thursday December 14, 2017 @08:28PM (#15929027)
why didn't Comcast stop sending these messages after the customer contacted them to tell them he had seen and received their message?

Personally, I'd guess it's because (like far too many parts of the internet) their implementation is subtly broken, and not because of anything nefarious. I don't recall the details of how it worked when I was the recipient, but I think the message correctly went away after I acknowledged it. I'm OK with treating repeated notification as a serious bug, just against equating a failed attempt at customer notification with a man-in-the-middle attack. I'm not universally against flooding Comcast executives and board members with feedback, but I'd prefer to reserve it for the cases where their intent, rather than their buggy implementation, is the issue. Like increasing transparency about how much they spend lobbying against municipal broadband: https://www.publicintegrity.org/2017/06/09/20917/comcast-sha...

Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by carussell on Thursday December 14, 2017 @06:16PM (#15928236)
There are good reasons to oppose what Comcast is doing. It would be nice if we could focus on those then, instead of the kinds of responses that have been appearing. The latter are not just unlikely to get anything to change, but are probably detrimental. The type of intellectual dishonesty present in the article, its headline, and peanut galleries like HN is the sort of thing that could end up inoculating folks like jlivingood on the Comcast end against worthwhile parts of public criticism.
Re:Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: M... by larrik on Friday December 15, 2017 @10:22AM (#15932399)
I do think they should just do the "free wifi" trick of redirecting to a new page.