News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by osrec on Thursday December 14, 2017 @03:14PM (#15926505)
If I was Facebook, I'd start to think about how to add more value to people's lives. Their monetisation strategy is becoming increasingly annoying and their service is not adding enough value to counter that. People will eventually leave if you irritate them enough (see also comments on https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15922022)
Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by Balgair on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:04PM (#15927584)
This was the plan from the start though. Zuck took all that money in 2005 from VCs and the like specifically to corner the market on Social Media (or at least be #2 in the space). The entire idea with these start-ups is to become a monopoly by being really good at it, and then when the competition is dead, crank up the money making portion of the service to the point at which people will just not use it. These are 'Unicorn' investments, they are there to make a billion dollars so that the VC is still solvent (1 unicorn covers the 99 other investments). Becoming a monopoly and then 'boiling the frogs' was the entire idea.
Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by osrec on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:23PM (#15927756)
This is really sad. Makes me want to start a lean, open source social network that keeps the good stuff and does away with the bloat. I bet it could be popular with intelligent people! Anyone interested, email me (see profile) :p
Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by Nition on Thursday December 14, 2017 @07:24PM (#15928726)
Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by droopyEyelids on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:54PM (#15928047)
Intelligence is orthogonal to the basic desires Facebook uses to addict its users
Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by osrec on Thursday December 14, 2017 @06:30PM (#15928345)
That's the point; it'd be nice to have something similar to Facebook without all of the addictive trash. In my opinion, the concept of a social network in itself isn't bad - it's just the monetisation bit that they've got terribly wrong, along with the use of addictive media to bolster ad revenues.
Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by Balgair on Thursday December 14, 2017 @07:08PM (#15928629)
I'm less bullish on that idea.

The issue is the cost of the service. You have to pay for those servers somehow and for updating the site to the latest versions of iOS or Windows or whatever.

There have been MANY attempts at implementing a 'paid FB' or just a straight attempt to tackle FB outright (Ello comes to mind). None have thus far worked. Not saying you can't try, but talk to the other creators out there first to learn from their mistakes.

Again, the issue is that servers cost money and you have to find the funding somehow. Ads are good at that. Subscription services aren't thus far, but Patreon may be changing things.

Still, with NN out the window now, I'd chill and wait to see how the dust settles.

Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by osrec on Thursday December 14, 2017 @07:27PM (#15928740)
You're right, but I'm tempted to do it anyway! Who's with me? Anyone? Guess it's just me!

Seriously though, I know monetisation is tricky, but there must be a better alternative to ads. I'm thinking something which can perhaps enrich the quality of a user's experience for a fee, rather than earning via ads while annoying the user.

Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by chiefofgxbxl on Thursday December 14, 2017 @09:59PM (#15929363)
In some ways I think Americans are cheap. I'm imagining a paid FB-like service in the range of $5-10/mo, considering ISP packages can easily run up to $80/mo, and a FB-like site should ideally only consume a portion of that.

But I think you really need to re-think the core concept of a social platform. Can't find the comment on HN, but someone a few days ago mentioned: social platform vs. social technology. A social platform is likely to be closed; Facebook only wants you to communicate via Facebook, same with Twitter, G+, etc. If you decide to email your friends instead of using FB, they lose out. A social technology, however, doesn't care about other providers as much. Think about a telephone company. They obviously want you to use their service, but they don't care if you call someone who has a different carrier. Likewise, they won't listen in to the content of your calls to tailor their service to you, because them providing you phone data and the contents of your calls are completely orthogonal.

Try thinking along the lines of a social technology, rather than a social platform. E.g. my friends want to put together a movie/pizza night so they go to Facebook to create a poll to decide on a movie and pizza toppings. Why can't that be part of an SMS standard?

It seems to me like SMS has a lot of potential for future iterations. Right now you can send texts and images to one or more people. Why not bake in other features like polls, appointments, etc. It truly has frustrated me that my friends will use Facebook to organize something that could easily be done over SMS if it just had a few extra features.

Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by osrec on Friday December 15, 2017 @12:35AM (#15929862)
Interesting points. I'm not sure if SMS is rich enough to support a full fledged social tech, but I kind the idea of keeping the technology open. I will definitely keep thinking about this!
Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by chiefofgxbxl on Friday December 15, 2017 @11:19AM (#15932846)
Right, SMS probably wouldn't be able to bear that full weight of a whole social tech, but I believe with just a few additional features added to its spec (or a fork), the effort-to-payoff ratio would be large, if your goal is to help ween people off of sites like Facebook. There's no reason why I shouldn't just be able to use my phone to invite a bunch of friends to some event, and have them indicate with a checkmark or red X whether they will be going or not.

I have some other ideas that I was going to formally write up and thinking of submitting it to Mozilla. Feel free to email me (email in my profile) to discuss more if interested.

Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by felipeerias on Thursday December 14, 2017 @10:36PM (#15929511)
You don't even have to be "really good at it" to end up a monopoly when your competition needs to make ends meet and you don't.
Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by kleer001 on Thursday December 14, 2017 @04:44PM (#15927384)
If I was Facebook, I'd start downsizing my company to a slim and trim archival service, maybe even start charging a fee for executive functionality (like what? I dunno) to help support server costs. Maybe even go distributed content where everyone hosts (encrypted) content and shares bandwidth.

IMHO online social networks have a 5-7 year half life, after that they stagnate and die because the company tries to chase ad dollars (the easiest dollars to get) and step by step degrades their usefulness.

For some reason we don't model business on natural systems (birth -> growth -> reproduction -> death). Seems to me that'd be a good idea if we want to be around in a million years.

Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by a3n on Friday December 15, 2017 @01:42AM (#15930074)
> If I was Facebook, I'd start to think about how to add more value to people's lives.

Harvesting value from people's lives seems to be working really well for them at the moment.

Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by fpisfun on Thursday December 14, 2017 @04:19PM (#15927161)
I think Google realized this a long time ago and it's also part of why they failed with Google plus. They just weren't willing to go down into the gutter the way Facebook is and try to suck up people's time to a ridiculous extent. They have remained too concerned, if you will, with providing actual value and Facebook, from day one, has never had that as a concern as their only concern is getting you to use the app as much as humanly possible.
Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by Terr_ on Thursday December 14, 2017 @07:37PM (#15928797)
One factor that turned me away from Google+ when they were hyping it was their usage model. Having context-sensitive associations "circles" was nice, but they ruined it by not also having context-sensitive identity. Instead there was all that stuff about requiring real names everywhere.

In the real world we traditionally rely on other factors to keep out identities separate. A dirty joke told to some friends doesn't get archived and indexed and re-shared with metadata back to your boss. It gets forgotten or attributed to "a guy I know." So it's relatively safe to give your real name in both contexts, and maintain the separation between studious-worker in one context and bawdy-clown in another.

But online, maintaining that "freedom to be a different kind of person" isn't reliably safe when both things come from the same user-ID.

Re:Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long ... by znpy on Thursday December 14, 2017 @06:56PM (#15928556)
> If I was Facebook, I'd start to think about how to add more value to people's lives.

Thst would be pointless as people do not pay to be on Facebook. And people aren't paid to be on Facebook. People are the product being sold.

Proof: this last move tries to improve the product (people's time) for its actual customers (advertisers).