News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Golden State’s War on Itself by WiseWeasel on Monday August 09, 2010 @09:17PM (#1590105)
I'm quite a fan of the initiative process in California. I mean, sure, it's been abused by short-sighted people, leading to things like three-strikes legislation overcrowding our prisons, but it has also brought us important social progress such as medical marijuana, and any sufficiently unpopular law is only a petition away from redress. It's encouraging that we enjoy the power to reform law from the bottom up in such a direct manner, and I wouldn't want to give up that power quite so readily, as those who toss around that 'out of control initiative process' talking point are so eager to do.
Re:The Golden State’s War on Itself by adharmad on Monday August 09, 2010 @09:42PM (#1590157)
Continuous interference is detrimental to efficient functioning of representative democracy. It is difficult for a government to rule if it is second-guessed by the voters using the initiative system.

California's initiative system creates problems wherein the populace votes emotionally (PROP 8). A lot of times, the initiative system has a weakness in the fact that the voting public is easily swayed by easy simplifications of complex issues and is unable to see the big picture.

Re:The Golden State’s War on Itself by WiseWeasel on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @10:54AM (#1591618)
Representatives, on the other hand, are easily swayed by campaign fund contributions, tipping the balance of power away from public interest altogether. The initiative process is certainly a sword that cuts both ways, but I'm glad to have it in our arsenal. It's not for nothing that California is the R&D center of this laboratory of democracy.