Re:The Golden State’s War on Itself
by WiseWeasel on Monday August 09, 2010 @09:17PM
(#1590105)
I'm quite a fan of the initiative process in California. I mean, sure, it's been abused by short-sighted people, leading to things like three-strikes legislation overcrowding our prisons, but it has also brought us important social progress such as medical marijuana, and any sufficiently unpopular law is only a petition away from redress. It's encouraging that we enjoy the power to reform law from the bottom up in such a direct manner, and I wouldn't want to give up that power quite so readily, as those who toss around that 'out of control initiative process' talking point are so eager to do.
Continuous interference is detrimental to efficient functioning of representative democracy. It is difficult for a government to rule if it is second-guessed by the voters using the initiative system.
California's initiative system creates problems wherein the populace votes emotionally (PROP 8). A lot of times, the initiative system has a weakness in the fact that the voting public is easily swayed by easy simplifications of complex issues and is unable to see the big picture.
Re:The Golden State’s War on Itself
by WiseWeasel on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @10:54AM
(#1591618)
Representatives, on the other hand, are easily swayed by campaign fund contributions, tipping the balance of power away from public interest altogether. The initiative process is certainly a sword that cuts both ways, but I'm glad to have it in our arsenal. It's not for nothing that California is the R&D center of this laboratory of democracy.
Some major problems: California's state constitution is a mess; its initiative process is out of control; conventional tax increases are impossible; Prop 13 distorts incentives. Many of these are structural issues. A bunch of articles have appeared on HN lately about how powerful, complex societies and institutions fail by being unable to flexibly adapt to change. That, in a nutshell, appears to be California's problem, which has been papered over to some extent by Silicon Valley Hollywood, agriculture, and weather. But even those rich sources of income can eventually be exhausted by the infinite demands of special interests and others.