News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by ryandrake on Monday December 11, 2017 @09:56AM (#15897321)
Such a long, meandering article, but the meat of it seems to be here:

“The more vanilla the release, the better it works for Spotify. If it’s challenging music? Nah,” he says, telling me about all of the experimental, noise, and comparatively aggressive music on his label that goes unheard on the platform. “It leaves artists behind. If Spotify is just feeding easy music to everybody, where does the art form go? Is anybody going to be able to push boundaries and break through to a wide audience anymore?”

I get that the author wants to listen to "challenging" music that "pushes boundaries" and laments that Spotify's algorithms are surfacing up Muzak instead. But there are other places to go to find your challenging music. For lots of other people, however, music is not some intimate connection with an artist's soul, it's simply something that goes on in the background while you're trying to get something else done or just relax. People seem to want Muzak--who are you to argue with the market when it has spoken?

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by maldusiecle on Monday December 11, 2017 @10:20AM (#15897520)
There's an argument to be made about the payment structure, though. Let's say I listen to music for five hours a day. Four of those hours I'm working, and it's mindless background music. For the last hour, I'm at home, actively listening, engaged.

The music in the last hour is worth more to me than the other four hours, and in an older model, pricing can reflect that. Easy-listening CDs are cheaper, and I buy new ones less frequently (it doesn't matter if they repeat, because I'm not really listening). But in the streaming model, the last hour of music is worth less. It's a smaller span of time, and I'm more likely to vary what I listen to during it (so no one artist gets as much money).

I don't know if I'd call Spotify responsible for this--it seems like an unintended consequence--but it's certainly unfortunate either way.

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by exDM69 on Monday December 11, 2017 @10:25AM (#15897560)
The issue is twofold.

Like you say, most people want their easy music and Spotify delivers. The downside of that is the fact that commercially produced music is now targeting Spotify consumption aggressively and using all those fancy analytics Spotify provides. This makes new music more and more alike each other.

Because of this tight feedback loop on Spotify and the producers, I think it's only a matter of time when they cut out the middle man and start producing music with AI algorithms. I'm sure that algorithms can keep the muzak-consuming masses happy. I've already heard some convincing sounding music (sheet music played with synthesizers) and audio (music produced directly as audio waveforms) produced by algorithms.

The second issue is what's described in the comment you quote. Anyone making niche music is suffering. It was never easy for musicians taking this route but the algorithm based recommendations engines is making it harder to be discovered while taking a bigger cut from the small income.

It's not like there is another viable platform out there. Spotify has a near monopoly and they dictate the terms. People aren't buying a second subscription service or buying songs separately let alone buying a physical album.

I find one positive in this all. Because there's no more income from record sales, musicians are performing live more than in decades. I really like live music, so that's nice.

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by lovehashbrowns on Monday December 11, 2017 @12:36PM (#15898618)
> Spotify has a near monopoly and they dictate the terms. People aren't buying a second subscription service or buying songs separately let alone buying a physical album.

That's not even close to being true. Google Music, Apple Music, Amazon Prime whatever it's called, regular ol' Youtube videos and playlists, services like last.fm or Pandora.. There are lots of ways to discover music that don't depend on record labels and their marketing.

If your music is independent and you want to stay away from the man, you have to put work into marketing your music. That's the step that you'd normally hand off to the record label. At least now you actually have a viable way (lots, actually) of making money as opposed to the past when distribution was much more difficult.

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by exDM69 on Monday December 11, 2017 @12:54PM (#15898760)
> That's not even close to being true. Google Music, Apple Music, Amazon Prime whatever it's called, regular ol' Youtube videos and playlists

The others have pretty small consumer base but more importantly, suffer from all the same issues as Spotify. To reach the widest audience, you need to be with all of those. Most consumers have only one music subscription service. That's what makes it a near monopoly for them.

YouTube is a bit of an exception, and my favorite for niche and rare music and forgotten live performance recordings of more popular music. But YouTube is not very good for providing income for musicians who don't want to be predominantly 'tubers.

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by zaphar on Monday December 11, 2017 @03:46PM (#15900282)

    But YouTube is not very good for providing income for 
    musicians who don't want to be predominantly 'tubers.
The question here is whether it's better at providing income for niche musicians than the alternatives. It has always been hard to make money doing niche music. Youtube has made it much easier. Complaining that it doesn't make it profitable enough is beside the question. Some products are never going to be profitable no matter what the distribution mechanism is. For those products it may be sufficient to make it possible for an artist to recoup some costs for their hobby.
Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by lovehashbrowns on Monday December 11, 2017 @01:22PM (#15899046)
That makes it a near monopoly for whom? Having a big chunk of the industry doesn't mean you have a monopoly, by the way. Anyone can freely choose from a number of music subscription services. There's no monopoly here. The monopoly probably lies in how licenses are handled, and that process comes before Spotify/Google Music/Apple Music/etc. It's an archaic system and what should be the blame here, not the streaming services we currently have. It's always comical to me how people will attack Spotify and co. for things that the record labels are directly responsible for, and after having screwed artists for decades.

> But YouTube is not very good for providing income for musicians who don't want to be predominantly 'tubers.

Okay, this is not a great excuse. I think I understand what you mean by this. But if a musician doesn't want to follow the distribution channels that consumers prefer, then that's on the artist. If you want to take care of distribution for yourself and avoid any big labels, then you take responsibility for the success and failure of your music's distribution.

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by croon on Monday December 11, 2017 @11:18AM (#15897977)
I could've written that piece in high school (and I probably did) about a random popular radio channel, or the billboard top 100. Even if it was big label (and ad) driven instead of algorithm (and ad) driven, I honestly don't see a practical difference.

I always prided myself (this is a remorseful confession, not a boast) in discovering small bands no one had heard of, either later becoming big or not, this going back to the 90s and back. I also took issue with hipsters becoming a term in the mid oughts, because I thought they made me look like a douche (which I saw no irony in).

But to my point: I see absolutely no difference in now and then in the music stage, other than global scope since the rise of the internet. There is of course a lot of stuff that isn't on Spotify, but the barrier of entry to their service seems minimal, as you can regularly discover bandcamp level indie music on there. I can listen to bigger names now on account of being mature enough to acknowledge good music wherever it comes from, but I generally still scavenge blogs, bandcamp and Spotify's discover weekly (which I feel matches what you feed it through play history). I'm inclined to say that Spotify is providing a higher yield than other venues in regards to quality discovery for me.

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by nradov on Monday December 11, 2017 @10:44AM (#15897709)
Which noise music artists actually broke through to a wide audience before Spotify?
Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by santaclaus on Monday December 11, 2017 @12:30PM (#15898571)
Merzbow and Lou Reed come to mind.

Edit: Yoko Ono

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by salmonfamine on Monday December 11, 2017 @01:38PM (#15899171)
I had an earlier reply to this, but upon re-reading it, I thought it came off as a little inflammatory, which I did not intend, so I deleted it.

But I think it is a little disingenuous to call those artists "noise artists" insofar as their mainstream success is concerned.

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by meo4 on Monday December 11, 2017 @05:41PM (#15901343)
black dice?
Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by mental1896 on Monday December 11, 2017 @10:16AM (#15897480)
One thing I didn't see mentioned was how a song's "radio" seems to just play popular titles by bands in the same genre. When I first saw the feature, I was hoping it would be a successful implementation of Pandora's "Music Genome" promise, but it sounds like the same old market-driven gentle nudging toward what's popular, instead of what I actually wanted.
Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by KozmoNau7 on Monday December 11, 2017 @02:00PM (#15899347)
I mostly listen to metal, not big popular metalcore and radio metal, but plenty of death metal, thrash metal, that sort of thing.

The discover playlist, radios and daily mixes have been absolutely awesome for me, when it comes to discovering new bands. Sure, it generally sticks to the most popular songs by said artists, but 1) they're the popular tracks for a reason, and 2) it gets me to explore the rest of that artist's discography.

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by MisterTea on Monday December 11, 2017 @04:14PM (#15900500)
I listen to similar plus black metal and found spotify to be decent enough. But as you pointed out, popular songs by popular artists. I have a beef with this, especially when you said: >1) they're the popular tracks for a reason Yes, popular because that's all anyone ever hears. That feeds into the same mindless pop music mentality of distilled top hits playlists which shackles the people themselves, the art, and the artist. Honestly I've found underground and promotional channels on Youtube to be much more explorative and satisfying. Odium Nostrum and Black Metal Promotion have been two very solid channels to follow who feature content that I enjoy which isn't on spotify.
Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by KozmoNau7 on Monday December 11, 2017 @04:42PM (#15900743)
Sure, there are recommendations for the obvious popular bands, but I've also gotten ones for bands I'd never heard of before, like Heptaedium, Mist of Misery, Ashbringer, Vector of Underground and Kyy. Not all of it is good, but it is definitely interesting.

I think it's important to take an active role and explore related artists, instead of only seeing the recommendation playlists.

Outside of Spotify, I follow Toilet ov Hell and my friends' recommendations.

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by coldtea on Monday December 11, 2017 @01:58PM (#15899341)
>People seem to want Muzak--who are you to argue with the market when it has spoken?

A person that understands that popularity doesn't settle much?

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by ryandrake on Monday December 11, 2017 @02:49PM (#15899754)
> A person that understands that popularity doesn't settle much?

Then why are they using Spotify? That's like eating at McDonalds and complaining that the food is bland and un-challenging.

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by longerthoughts on Monday December 11, 2017 @04:42PM (#15900752)
Not quite - the McDonalds of music might have the most plays on Spotify but there's plenty of challenging niche music as well (even if it's mostly neglected). It's more like Spotify is a major city full of diverse cuisine but 95% of its residents eat every meal at McDonalds.
Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by icebraining on Monday December 11, 2017 @03:17PM (#15900047)
What they're complaining is that McDonalds is bad for the nutrition of the overall society.
Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by coldtea on Monday December 11, 2017 @05:05PM (#15900953)
I don't think their complaint is about what they listen to. Rather it's a lament at what crap gets popular.
Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by wastedhours on Monday December 11, 2017 @11:12AM (#15897940)
It's always a common complaint of appealing to the "mainstream" that people neglect to mention has become the mainstream because it appeals to the desires of a lot of people.

There's the feedback loop of creating something people will like based on what they liked previously, which can be self-limiting, but also appeals to the demands of those consumers.

We should broaden our experiences regularly, but for me with all the other things I could challenge myself with, music isn't something I care deeply enough about to, well... care.

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by meo4 on Monday December 11, 2017 @09:05PM (#15902509)
there are other places to go to find your challenging music

what are those? I have to work hard to find interesting music, so I'm curious if I'm ignorant of some really huge obvious places for music discovery.

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by thirdsun on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @01:59AM (#15903542)
For me it's Bandcamp as well as independent online record stores like:

- Piccadilly Records

- Norman Records

- Boomkat

- Red Eye Records

- Bleep

Some of these stores offer digital, lossless purchasing options, but more importantly all of them feature staff curated recommendations and featured releases, which are, to me, more effective than Spotify's algorithms. I can't count the number of times Spotify recommends songs I clearly already know and have been listening to via the service before.

Re:The Problem with Muzak – Spotify’s bid to remodel an indu... by maxscam on Monday December 11, 2017 @11:30PM (#15903009)
I personally use bandcamp. You can see best sellers from basically any super niche or not so niche genre