There is, however, a "The Ones That Got Away" playlist, that, while still not heavy on anything particularly popular, could fit in with your experience. Maybe you were looking at the wrong playlist?
Maybe I'm just unlucky to be in a user cohort where promoted songs are inserted into my top 2017 songs (to test how many extra plays they can get this way). It sucks that they do this to paying customers though.
On the other hand, the "ones that got away" playlist is completely filled with pop dreck, scraped directly from top 40 lists, not worth even looking at.
On the other hand, Spotify's description for the "Your Top Songs 2017" playlist doesn't explicitly make the claim that these would be songs I actually listened to; instead it's more vaguely phrased as "songs you loved this year"... So I guess they're just assuming I would love these.
It also helps that Spotify doesn't show play counts, so there's no way for me to verify the actual top list. I'm thinking of buying more MP3s from now on -- files on local disk don't try to actively manipulate me to listen to something else.
I am shocked that this is a thing
Recently they introduced a feature called “2017 Wrapped”, which contains a playlist named “Your Top Songs 2017”. I imagined this list would contain the songs I actually listened to most. Instead it’s biased so that many of my favorites don’t appear, yet there are major label songs that I don’t even remember actively playing.
It’s borderline misleading advertisement to pretend these are “my top songs” when obviously the list is a pay-to-play for labels.