An alternative solution is to tax the unused value of illiquid capital like land. Unlike income and sales taxes, which act as disincentives on economic exchange, this kind of tax acts as an incentive for exchange, production, and employment: if you own capital which is not being put to use, this tax is either an incentive to put it to use or to sell it to someone who will.
This isn't a new idea. It was put forward by Henry George in Progress and Poverty in 1879: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progress_and_Poverty (Disclaimer: I haven't read the book, but I did buy it recently and it's on my to-read list.)
Also, is there data to back up sales taxes in relation to dampening demand? It's the same tax, just taken from a different place. I find it hard to believe that the common consumer would hold on to money. They just don't do that.
Consider property taxes: if your ranch makes 100k / year many people will haply keep doing that for sentimental reasons, if however the land is worth 50 million and you need to pay 100k in taxes each year you will sell it to someone who will use the resource more productively.
It also eats away at debt. So if say the housing market is under water inflation is going to help people get out from their debt load.
PS: Or consider what happens with 20% deflation, what would you invest in?
Perhaps I'm being thick, but I'm still unsure: when you say, "Actually, this is the argument for low inflation," do you mean that we should focus on maintaining a low level of inflation instead of taxing underutilized capital? or in addition to it? or that, in policy terms, they're two sides of the same coin?
Please be careful to talk make clear whether you are talking about nominal ROI or inflation-adjusted (i.e. real) ROI.
If you have a tame investement with x% real ROI, you will get approximately x%+inflation nominal ROI.
So your argument needs patching up.
It is true, that inflation deters one from just holding onto cash.
> If she rents, her rent is certainly higher because of the landlords property taxes.
But here I disagree, at least somewhat. Property prices and rents are---to some degree---determined by how much people bid them up. Taxes on real estate influence how much of the rent goes to the owner and how much to the state. But the absolute level of rent won't be affected much.
(This is more the the more fixed the supply of real estate happens to be.)
Correction: (The more fixed the supply of real estate happens to be, the more pronounced this effect will be.)
Here is a huge opinion that could be incorrect. Most people work for what they need to live. If it becomes more expensive to live, Sally will want a raise. If it's cheaper to live, she won't be so pissed when she doesn't get a raise. The bottom line is all that matters to most people. Therefore, no matter what taxes are created, purported to be income tax and what not, are paid by businesses.
What does this mean in practice? It means that by having incoming taxes at all, we are encouraging business to hire people outside of the US. The only way to level the playing fields, as far as I can see, would be to shift the taxes from income to sales. I don't know if that is plausible or not, but it's the only way I can see the US government really encouraging job growth here in the US. It would mean that no matter where your company does it's business, if it uses the US market, it has to pay the piper, and would give a real shot to US workers at competing with other world-wide workers.