News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by marsrover on Friday December 08, 2017 @09:15AM (#15878718)
I really enjoy investing in cryptocurrencies. However, I have a lot of doubt this is going to make the world a more fair or better place. It's going to create a wealth gap like has never been seen in first world countries.
Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by simias on Friday December 08, 2017 @09:37AM (#15878844)
It seems pretty obvious to me as well. Given huge speculation surrounding them at the moment I'm surprised we don't hear more people warning about these things. I don't think I want to live in a world where BTC replaces the USD/EUR/...

Untraceable money means that corruption and tax evasion would be easier than ever. Democratic governments would be worse off in dealing with that, because unlike totaliatrian regimes they won't be able to round up BTC-rich people and break their fingers until they give their secret keys.

Deflation means that the rich will get richer doing nothing while the poor won't be able to get a loan to bootstrap their businesses. Forget about trickle down economics, this is downright "trickle up".

I have yet to hear a reasonable rebuttal to these claims. Every time I see these points brought up in the bitcoin community it's met with a bunch of hand waiving and claims that they're "FUD" and that the poster doesn't know what they're talking about. So please, BTC enthusiasts, educate me so that I can stop spreading this "FUD", where's the flaw in my reasoning?

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by knocte on Friday December 08, 2017 @09:53AM (#15878970)
> Untraceable money

Bitcoin is not untraceable money, it can be even more traceable than normal currency. It could be stablished as a law that public money when being spent in the blockchain needs to be auditable by the people (identities of sender and recipient known), and this way you would end up with even less corruption than the current system.

> Deflation means that the rich will get richer

Wrong. Rich people don't have money, they have holdings. Most of the holdings that rich people nowadays have are not money. Deflation just benefits the savers, as opposed to the spenders. Some savers might be rich but not all. Incentivising saving instead of consumption may make the planet a bit greener. Plus, if one day we stop measuring cryptocurrency value with a fiat-unit of measure, maybe we find out that the cryptocurrency value is actually the stable value. The asset that is not stable is the fiat currency because it's being depreciated all the time. The day all stores in the planet denominate prices in cryptocurrency, the bad consequences of deflation (hoarding for the sake of profit) will be almost imperceptible.

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by simias on Friday December 08, 2017 @10:57AM (#15879546)
>> Deflation means that the rich will get richer

>Wrong. Rich people don't have money, they have holdings. Most of the holdings that rich people nowadays have are not money.

Isn't one reason for not hoarding cash (and instead investing it in various holdings, stock market, etc...) is that money loses value? If I was a millionaire in dollars I definitely wouldn't keep that on my bank account, slowly having it lose its value. If I was a millionaire in BTC I'd have a hardware wallet with my secret keys in a safe and that's about it.

>Deflation just benefits the savers, as opposed to the spenders. Some savers might be rich but not all.

Sure, but conversely I can tell you that the people who don't save money are overwhelmingly poor. For a big chunk of humanity saving money is a luxury.

>Incentivising saving instead of consumption may make the planet a bit greener.

Coin mining will take care of filling that gap, don't worry.

If rich people reduce their investments because of deflation how do you redistribute wealth?

>Plus, if one day we stop measuring cryptocurrency value with a fiat-unit of measure, maybe we find out that the cryptocurrency value is actually the stable value.

Well yeah, 1BTC == 1BTC, that's stable I guess. If BTC replaces fiat it'll stabilize eventually but it will still be deflationary. My arguments were about that, not the current instability.

>The asset that is not stable is the fiat currency because it's being depreciated all the time. The day all stores in the planet denominate prices in cryptocurrency, the bad consequences of deflation (hoarding for the sake of profit) will be almost imperceptible.

That's kind of the hand waving I was talking about in my previous comment. I don't see how you can justify you jumping to that conclusion.

How can you assume that switching from an inflationary to a deflationary economy "will be almost imperceptible"?

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by knocte on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:12AM (#15879675)
> If I was a millionaire in BTC I'd have a hardware wallet with my secret keys in a safe and that's about it.

Lending or investing your BTC would always make you net more than just hoarding it (at least when all prices are denominated in BTC already).

> Sure, but conversely I can tell you that the people who don't save money are overwhelmingly poor. For a big chunk of humanity saving money is a luxury.

True, I didn't say that low-class can save. But most savers are middle class IMO.

> Coin mining will take care of filling that gap, don't worry.

Wrong, 2 links:

https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-12-07/bitcoin-i...

https://blog.bitcoin.org.hk/bitcoin-mining-and-energy-consum...

> How can you assume that switching from an inflationary to a deflationary economy "will be almost imperceptible"?

Because when all prices get denominated in BTC, you won't see your holdings appreciate. The only effect you will see, caused by deflation, is that prices of things diminish over time. Which is kind of what happens nowadays with hardware (because it's the goods where the effects of technology improvements are noticed in the most sensible way), however I don't know anyone that hoards their holdings to be able to buy a better and cheaper computer tomorrow.

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by ufo on Friday December 08, 2017 @12:37PM (#15880361)
The problem with a deflationary currency is that prices, wages and income go down over time. Someone borrowing 100 BTC today will have a hard time paying back that 100 BTC one year from now (let alone the interest) because they will be earning less than they do today.
Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by knocte on Friday December 08, 2017 @09:44PM (#15883958)
So loans would need to be short-lived and with high scrutiny, to make sure they are payed back. I consider this a good thing, as opposed to the other extreme: give everyone a loan no matter what (the root cause of the 2008 financial crisis).
Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by knocte on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @09:28PM (#15911547)
> Wrong, 2 links:

One link more:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2T0OUIW89II

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by MintPattern on Friday December 08, 2017 @05:51PM (#15882812)
> The asset that is not stable is the fiat currency because it's being depreciated all the time.

Checking accounts (M1) have grown by (only) 8%/year over the past 2 years.

Savings accounts (M2) have grown by (only) 6%/year over the past 2 years.

Physical cash in circulation has grown by (only) 5%/year over the past 2 years.

Even if we value bitcoin today only by it's future 0% emission rate starting at around the year 2036, bitcoin shouldn't have been rising more than 7 or 8% per year relative to the US Dollar. Anymore is unlikely to be sustainable. Am I missing anything?

Citation: https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h6/current/default.h...

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by lawn on Friday December 08, 2017 @10:05AM (#15879080)
I don't completely disagree but I will try to at least bring up some contrary views.

> Untraceable money

Bitcoin is pseudoanonymous with it's public ledger, hardly untraceable. Look into Monero for a proper anonymous coin.

> Untraceable money means that corruption and tax evasion would be easier than ever.

A contrary point is that today corruption and tax evasion is only for the very rich, see the paradise papers for example. In a sick way this could give the common man more power and maybe make the world a little more balanced.

Also tax collection is already heavily based on social pressure and doing the right thing. It's not obvious that the threat of getting caught, compared to the social stigma, weighs more.

> Deflation means that the rich will get richer doing nothing while the poor won't be able to get a loan to bootstrap their businesses. Forget about trickle down economics, this is downright "trickle up".

I also don't like extreme deflation, but I also don't like the inflation based system we have today.

Inflation basically eats away at your savings. This is a bigger problem for everyday poor people compared to the rich as they have more investment options. Their buffer they hold in banks or in cash is smaller percentage wise, they can more easily invest in housing and they can more easily grow their capital as money breads money. The problem with rich getting richer is already present.

Without inflation loans would harder and would combat the very real problems with too much loans (housing bubble, student loan crisis, ...). It could also help to reign in fractional banking as it would get riskier/harder.

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by simias on Friday December 08, 2017 @10:44AM (#15879441)
>Bitcoin is not untraceable money, it can be even more traceable than normal currency.

Fair enough, how about "trivial to launder" instead? The fact that every transaction is visible on the blockchain means that people who don't bother obfuscating their tracks (i.e. honest people who don't feel they have anything to hide) are the one who risk their privacy invaded: "hey, look, this is the address where we pay X his salary and some of it got transfered to the known address of this sex shop website".

If you want to hide your tracks however it's easy. Say I'm a politician and I want to accept a bribe. I can get a briefcase full of cash, but that's bulky, not very convenient and I could get caught if I try to move it (especially across borders).

Or I could try to open a bank account in some place where people look the other way but it's more complicated, involves third parties who could expose me (panama papers, lux leaks...), leaves a paper trail etc...

With BTC I click "generate a new receive address" in my wallet, give it to my anonymous benefactor and that's that.

Then after that if I really want to make it difficult to follow the money I can split my coin in multiple addresses, do a bunch of dummy transactions to obfuscate where the BTC change hands, go through a bunch of coin mixers, maybe convert to an other crypto (monero for instance?), do a bunch more mixing, and then back to BTC. Good luck unravelling all that.

>It could be stablished as a law that public money when being spent in the blockchain needs to be auditable by the people (identities of sender and recipient known), and this way you would end up with even less corruption than the current system.

Public spending is already supposed to be auditable in the democratic countries I know of (except in very specific cases, like "black boxes" for paying informants etc..). Generally corruption and waste is when people overpay for a service, like say paying 10x the cost for the construction of a new stadium, favouring a contractor over an other etc... I don't think BTC would help greatly with that. There are many, many ways of making "technically legal" purchases that conceal corruption, I don't think it would improve things very much. "Here, have this very valuable painting by Manet as a thank you for your help", "Here, let me make a charitable donation to your foundation", "Here, let me change this piece of regulation that will benefit your company", etc...

Unless you want to force all citizens (in the public and private) to publish their addresses I'm not sure you can really reign that in. And even then, how would you enforce that?

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by lawn on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:41AM (#15879943)
I think you responded to the wrong comment. I would still like to respond to this:

> Fair enough, how about "trivial to launder" instead?

It's absolutely possible to do it correctly. But the number of people who have been caught by blockchain analysis on darknet markets show that it's either not trivial or people are really stupid.

Even after you get your Bitcoin by buying it cash, perfectly anonymously, you can still be caught. For example the person who bought them from can give up some information which may implicate you if they ever mess. You also want to spend your Bitcoins and presumably you might then leave a trace connecting on of your addresses to you. By analysing your address they might find your other addresses and it's game over.

> Then after that if I really want to make it difficult to follow the money I can split my coin in multiple addresses, do a bunch of dummy transactions to obfuscate where the BTC change hands, go through a bunch of coin mixers, maybe convert to an other crypto (monero for instance?), do a bunch more mixing, and then back to BTC. Good luck unravelling all that.

Multiple addresses, dummy transactions and mixers are already being traced through with fair success [1]. Monero gives good privacy, but you might still trip up when you go Bitcoin -> Monero or even Monero -> Bitcoin if you convert very similar amounts during a specific timeframe. And you must always shield your IP and browser fingerprint...

It's possible, but this is not "trivial to launder" for most people.

[1]: https://themerkle.com/blocksci-succesfully-traces-transactio...

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by theorique on Friday December 08, 2017 @09:54AM (#15878971)
BTC is not "untraceable money". Everybody has (or can have) a copy of the blockchain, which is the cryptographically signed and verified ledger.

If anything, it is more traceable and public than physical cash. The difference is that you don't know who 63dca1f6eddfb659d71ec5244ab950a4 or e3557c1e589e2a687f6afe1a253196ca are. But when you do associate a person with a given key, that association probably persists over time.

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by simias on Friday December 08, 2017 @10:55AM (#15879531)
I replied to to this point in the parent comment but to expand on that:

>If anything, it is more traceable and public than physical cash.

That's true, but cash has its own set of limitations. Using cash to transfer large sums of money in not very convenient and good luck explaining to the border police why you have $20 million in cash with you. Spending and laundering large amounts of cash without raising suspicions is also pretty difficult.

>But when you do associate a person with a given key,

s/when/if/

>that association probably persists over time.

How so when you can generate a virtually infinite number of new addresses whenever you like and the current practice is to avoid reusing the same address if at all possible?

Sure if I buy some drugs in BTC and then I see that some money transits directly from the destination address to the known address of some politician then I know that something fishy is going on.

But if the money is then split and merged to a bunch of different addresses, then moved to an exchange in china where it's converted to LiteCoins, then put through a coin mixer, then moved to an exchange in Brazil where it's converted back to Bitcoins then I wish good luck to the IRS employees.

And you can do all of that from the comfort of your home in an afternoon, through TOR, without having to reveal your identity to any 3rd party.

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by russdpale on Friday December 08, 2017 @02:13PM (#15881114)
Bitcoin is not untraceable. It is confidential but it is not anonymous, they are different things.
Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by puranjay on Friday December 08, 2017 @09:58AM (#15879015)
One of the biggest issues I have with cryptocurrencies is how elitist it really is.

If your currency needs multiple 'Explain it like I'm 5' posts, it really isn't for the masses; it's for the world's technocrats.

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by seibelj on Friday December 08, 2017 @09:25AM (#15878757)
I struggle to think of any other way bitcoin could have caught on without early enthusiasts getting a huge number of coins.
Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by bufferoverflow on Friday December 08, 2017 @09:42AM (#15878869)
But this time it's voluntarily. Anybody can get it at any time. I've been telling my friends and family since 2012, and only one of them invested. Those who take risks, get rewarded. You can't win if you refuse to try.

Of course, there are truly poor people out there who can't have a dollar to spare, but it's mostly due to geography, corruption or war, not evil capitalists.

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by adjkant on Friday December 08, 2017 @09:48AM (#15878921)
Most of these people are likely affected by capitalism to an extreme: imperialism. Much larger of an injustice than anything you listed.

The people who are most able to take risks (in the investment sense) are those with the most. An exponential growth system such as this only widens the gap, voluntary or not.

Everyone can get in, but the benefit is unequal. You need money to make money. This does not solve any equality issues on the grand scale, and only elevates a few lucky ones. To expect people to educate themselves on cryptocurrencies and understand the market when half the people in tech don't know what's going on is not reasonable.

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by bufferoverflow on Friday December 08, 2017 @09:54AM (#15878976)
Imperialism is not capitalism, they are orthogonal concepts.

You're right, imperialism did cause problems, but the extreme poverty has been shrinking. And now we have the mechanisms for almost anybody to get out of it. I grew up very poor, as in barely enough money for basic food and new clothes once-twice a year. Now I'm in the top 3% of US earners (not counting Bitcoin).

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by open_bear on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:15AM (#15879701)
Imperialism is the final stage of capitalism.

> but the extreme poverty has been shrinking

Indonesian 12 y.o. who makes Nike sneakers for 1$ a day will probably disagree. Humanity as a whole have made tremendous advancements in medicine, engineering and agriculture, technology as a whole have been advancing in giant leaps, yet benefits of those advancements are largely felt by 10-20 countries and 3-5% of the population. Even in the US some people cannot afford insulin and other types of basic healthcare. Workers's wages are stagnant for the past 50 years, while their productivity was steadily rising (https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/02/why-the...).

> And now we have the mechanisms for almost anybody to get out of it. I grew up very poor

Survivorship bias, "if I've made it, then anyone can".

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by adjkant on Friday December 08, 2017 @10:06AM (#15879083)
> Imperialism is not capitalism, they are orthogonal concepts.

I would argue they are very tied, but that is a much larger argument not needed here. To give the short and incomplete version, they are both derived from the idea of exploiting others for profit. The level of exploitation is just much less in capitalism and masked behind the guise of fairness, ignoring power dynamics, original capital, and exponential growth considerations, etc. Again, this argument is very incomplete as stated here, but they are not orthogonal concepts. How much of a connection they have is a very valid debate, one not needed here fully though.

> extreme poverty has been shrinking. And now we have the mechanisms for almost anybody to get out of it.

Getting better does not mean that everyone can get out of poverty. We also haven't gotten that better. Most of Africa is still being exploited and most living there do not have any realistic means to get out of it. The countries as a whole still struggle on a macroeconomic level to get out of poverty due to the exact exponential growth issue seen in Bitcoin but with general investment.

The US is not representative of the rest of the world, and also is still far from equal opportunity. While we're on that subject, good luck easily buying cryptocurrencies (accessible to a non-tech audience) while living outside the US. Even my Canadian friends struggle getting Coinbase to let them.

Bitcoin is only really accessible to the tech community, an already privileged community.

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by bufferoverflow on Friday December 08, 2017 @10:20AM (#15879210)
I think you're a hypocrite. If you think people in Africa aren't getting paid enough, why are you not selling your PC / smartphone to help them out? It's easy to tell other people how to spend their money helping the poor, but when it comes to your own wealth, you're still typing into this tech forum.
Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by adjkant on Friday December 08, 2017 @10:26AM (#15879269)
> If you think people in Africa aren't getting paid enough, why are you not selling your PC / smartphone to help them out?

Because that would not solve the problem, and it's quite naive to think it would. This gets into lots of debates in ethics that are far from solved.

I do however donate regularly to groups that do economic development in African communities across the world though (more than the cost of a new iPhone annually), so no, I am not a hypocrite (fully at least).

In fact, if you want a great non-profit idea, make a company that translates bitcoin profits into economic development in those communities. My donations have recently been coming from said profits.

---------------------------------

Regardless of whether I am a hypocrite or not, it does not change the facts of the world and bitcoin. Just because my actions do not match perfectly does not mean they shouldn't. That's not a valid argument against my ideas, just against me personally.

> you're still typing into this tech forum

I didn't know using technology is immoral now if others are suffering injustices. Not to mention that there's plenty of utilitarian arguments about cascading effects of convincing others.

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by bufferoverflow on Friday December 08, 2017 @10:48AM (#15879476)
It would not solve the problem globally, but you can feed a person making a dollar a day for a long time. Yet you're not doing it. And that's why I'm not buying your argument. You want the redistribution of wealth, but not your wealth.
Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by adjkant on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:12AM (#15879678)
Again, that argument doesn't work.

Let's look at an example of Bill Gates - if instead of investing any money or time in Microsoft, he gave away everything he could, he would not help as many people in the end. Again, you need money to make money. Of course you need to also consider the other effects of Microsoft in the calculation, which is no easy matter, but the general point is that investment by him eventually led to greater helping of those suffering injustices.

This does not consider that subsidizing someone's current lifestyle doesn't nearly have the impact of helping them develop economic means. It's a classic give a fish versus teach fishing.

And again, someone being hypocritical is not an argument against the logic. It just means that person is selfish and hypocritical. I don't claim that solving these problems is easy or not in direct conflict with human instincts.

There are also issues of fixing injustices justly. It's hard to give up x% of your wealth for a good cause when others are not. I would love to see something like a global 5% reparations tax (scaled by income, benefit from injustice, etc) that I would happily pay because it would be just for all. Of course, getting that to happen is kidding yourself at best.

All of your flawed arguments are still based on you assuming that I'm a hypocrite and no information that I gave you. I would call double BS on your reasoning for disagreement given that you had no knowledge of it when you took the position. Your argument neither had the knowledge nor logic to stand even with the knowledge present.

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by lucozade on Friday December 08, 2017 @09:57AM (#15879007)
> But this time it's voluntarily

Gambling's rarely been mandatory. If you were going to recommend your folks to have a punt, wouldn't a casino be better? You know the odds then.

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by bufferoverflow on Friday December 08, 2017 @10:00AM (#15879032)
No, casinos have the edge, it's almost never mathematically sane to engage with a casino.

I considered what would happen if something like bitcoin would become a global internet currency, and any way I sliced it, the upside was too huge not to try.

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by adjkant on Friday December 08, 2017 @10:29AM (#15879306)
I don't think you're being creative enough with your slicing. Consider what happens when 90% of the primary world currency ends up concentrated with a few thousand - 100K people in the tech world and if that's really any sort of upside for the world.
Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by sooheon on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:09AM (#15879648)
BTC's deflationary nature appeals to type of people who enjoy getting in at the top of pyramid schemes (and then shouting down that anyone can bootstrap it too)--I suspect GP simply wishes he were one of the 100K.
Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by bufferoverflow on Friday December 08, 2017 @01:59PM (#15880977)
First of all, I don't think 90% will get concentrated between just 100K people by the time cryptocurrencies actually do take over (and they will, in some form). And then I don't mind money being more concentrated among tech people, they are generally more rational and tend to spend on important things.
Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by adjkant on Saturday December 09, 2017 @12:03PM (#15886682)
We're on track for that concentration right now.

> I don't mind money being more concentrated among tech people, they are generally more rational and tend to spend on important things.

Yeah, I don't but that at all either. Even so, you are basically advocating for an oligarchy led by tech and removing autonomy from everyone else in the world. That's a terrible dystopia.

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by jrochkind1 on Friday December 08, 2017 @09:43AM (#15878886)
You know what "risk" means, right?
[dead]
Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by jrochkind1 on Friday December 08, 2017 @10:41AM (#15879412)
You seem to be talking about it like it's a sure thing. "Those who take risks, get rewarded." Or lose all their risked money. shrug. If it was a sure thing, it wouldn't be a risk. Generally if a market if functioning theoretically optimally, you can't make a lot of money on this sort of "investment" unless you've also risked losing a lot of money. Whether the BTC market is functioning rationally/optimally is another question, but the answer probably doesn't reduce your risk.

Generally anyone that tells you that you can make an unusual amount of money on an investment (or, um, MLM business) without risking losing a lot is trying to scam you (even if they believe their own scam).

Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by charlesdm on Friday December 08, 2017 @09:32AM (#15878797)
It's redistribution of wealth. Old money being transferred to new owners. New fortunes are being made ever day. It doesn't matter.
Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by russdpale on Friday December 08, 2017 @02:12PM (#15881104)
I dont believe so. The network can align the interests of the users properly.
Re:The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of th... by golergka on Friday December 08, 2017 @12:59PM (#15880515)
Are you implying that more fair is more equal? Why?