News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Redbox's Workaround for Stocking Disney Movies Backfires ... by Noos on Sunday December 03, 2017 @08:57PM (#15840934)
They aren't selling a code for the download, though. They are selling you physical movie that comes with code to enjoy a digital copy. It's a bundled service, and I'm not sure first sale allows resellers to strip that and sell for profit, any more than Wal-Mart could order blu-rays that come with a DVD, open them up, and sell both separately.

Or open up a PS4 with a code for a free game in it, and sell the game.

Re:Redbox's Workaround for Stocking Disney Movies Backfires ... by mjmahone17 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @09:08PM (#15840980)
This case is exactly asking whether someone can “order blu-rays that come with a DVD, open them up, and sell both separately.” Intuitively first sale doctrine should imply you can: I can buy a bunch of packs of trading cards, open them up, then sell the cards individually. Likewise I should be able to buy a book, tear it apart and sell one chapter of it at a time. Or buy a gallon of flour and split it into 12-oz containers to sell. This question is the crux of the case, though, so it will be very interesting to see what legal arguments are offered, and what precedent applies.
Re:Redbox's Workaround for Stocking Disney Movies Backfires ... by tedunangst on Monday December 04, 2017 @01:43AM (#15841959)
Actually there have been court rulings that ripping a book apart creates derivative works (what is a single chapter if not an abridged version of the original?), so you can't do that. Although other courts have ruled you can.
Re:Redbox's Workaround for Stocking Disney Movies Backfires ... by rhizome on Monday December 04, 2017 @12:53PM (#15845867)
Interesting. Got a cite for the book-ripping case?
Re:Redbox's Workaround for Stocking Disney Movies Backfires ... by tedunangst on Monday December 04, 2017 @09:40PM (#15849351)
Re:Redbox's Workaround for Stocking Disney Movies Backfires ... by rhizome on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @08:05PM (#15866695)
Thanks! To be fair, it doesn't look like that particular situation is settled law yet.
Re:Redbox's Workaround for Stocking Disney Movies Backfires ... by posterboy on Monday December 04, 2017 @04:08AM (#15842611)
I find the (established?) grammar quite peculiar. Arguments are offered, passively, but precedent actively applies - itself, seemingly - as to distract from any subjectivity because, nobody should doubt, a high court's opinion always applied even before any decision was met.

edit: not sure whether this were "established".

Re:Redbox's Workaround for Stocking Disney Movies Backfires ... by gwbas1c on Sunday December 03, 2017 @09:55PM (#15841159)
Back in the late 1980s and early 1990s games would come with a disk for an IBM-compatible and a disk for an Apple II in the box.

That's plenty of precedent.

Re:Redbox's Workaround for Stocking Disney Movies Backfires ... by gruez on Sunday December 03, 2017 @10:35PM (#15841282)
that's not a precedent unless there was a court ruling based on it.
Re:Redbox's Workaround for Stocking Disney Movies Backfires ... by astura on Monday December 04, 2017 @02:25AM (#15842145)
And...?

How did the courts rule on reselling the disks separately?

Re:Redbox's Workaround for Stocking Disney Movies Backfires ... by toast0 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @09:30PM (#15841067)
Wal-Mart absolutely could do that, but the studios would probably stop selling bundled media directly to them. Wal-Mart is going to have a much harder time stocking their stores by buying from other retailers than Redbox has stocking kiosks by shopping at retailers.
Re:Redbox's Workaround for Stocking Disney Movies Backfires ... by eli on Sunday December 03, 2017 @09:02PM (#15840956)
Wait, why couldn't Walmart do that?
Re:Redbox's Workaround for Stocking Disney Movies Backfires ... by astura on Monday December 04, 2017 @02:27AM (#15842150)
Because Walmart has to play nice with the studios to keep their supply of wholesale movies coming.

The difference is, in this case at least, RedBox is buying their movies retail. So Redbox buys Disney movies just like you and I do, from a store shelf.

Re:Redbox's Workaround for Stocking Disney Movies Backfires ... by Noos on Sunday December 03, 2017 @09:22PM (#15841037)
I'm not sure. I was arguing that if it's feasible, they probably would be doing it by now. My guess is either the UCC or walmart's contract with Disney prevents the breaking apart or reselling of bundled services.