Cue the rise of one-time-use codes in text books to register required software used for homework. I get that they need to make money, but by God they don't have to be scum while doing it.
Yeah well, I said the same thing about copyright extension and the DMCA... Disney doesn't lose these kinds of battles very often. They've paid a lot of politicians a lot of money to keep getting their way...
https://priceonomics.com/how-mickey-mouse-evades-the-public-...
In a nutshell: first sale doctrine applies to physical goods, i.e., the DVD purchased by Redbox. It doesn't apply to non-tangible goods (specifically, the code that accompanies the DVD) because intangible goods are licensed, not sold. So, Redbox while Redbox can sell the DVDs it purchases without restraint, it has to abide by the terms of the license if it wants to sell the download code.
Companies definitely want to exempt digital goods from first sale, but there’s no logical reason to do so. Hopefully this case helps establish precedent.
Basically, under US and Western law, an intangible good is only "sold" when all of the relevant right to it are sold. If you only sell copies, you are only selling a right to use the copy, which the law calls a license. (The copy doesn't actually exist, by the way, it's just a legal construct, as downloading actually creates a new set of bits.) Since the license is trivially copied, the owner of the good is allowed to control how the license is used.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UsedSoft#ECJ_ruling
But its not applicable in this case, same German court rejected resale of used games on account of identifying them as art and not software.
Or open up a PS4 with a code for a free game in it, and sell the game.
edit: not sure whether this were "established".
That's plenty of precedent.
How did the courts rule on reselling the disks separately?
The difference is, in this case at least, RedBox is buying their movies retail. So Redbox buys Disney movies just like you and I do, from a store shelf.
(disclosure: not legal advice, these things are complex, etc; contributed work on an appellate brief on a related matter)
fixed that for you
I predict Disney will lose.
Big textbook publishers have been trying to pull this crap for years and were finally trounced in the Supreme Court when it was ruled that once a textbook is sold to someone, you don't get to dictate whether and where it can be resold.
Disney is selling a code for a one time download. Once you purchase it, and you haven't used it yet, you should have the right to do whatever you want with it.