How so? My understanding is that they just won regional elections praised by international observers as free and transparent[0].
Interestingly, western governments/media & opposition claims of fraud (without evidence) directly contradict the findings of the delegation from the Latin American Council of Electoral Experts (CEELA). From the article cited:
The CEELA delegation was comprised of 1300 international observers, including former Colombian Electoral Court President Guillermo Reyes, ex-president of the Honduran Supreme Electoral Court, Augusto Aguilar, and former Peruvian electoral magistrate Gastón Soto.
According to the body’s report, the vote was held under conditions of “total normality” and the right to a secret ballot was “guaranteed”.
I also find this interesting:
For its part, CEELA has reported that it has yet to receive any formal denunciations from the opposition, which has issued its fraud allegations via the media.
President Maduro has requested a 100 percent audit of Sunday’s elections, a call that was subsequently echoed by the [opposition].
Do you mean the fake organization started by Hugo Chavez to legitimize elections in socialist states? The one that doesn't have a website or an organizational charter and gets its funding from Venezuela?
FOH.
If you search "ceela venezuela vote" on Google, the only articles that come up are from teleSUR (a mouthpiece of the Venezuelan government) and Venezuela analysis (another rabidly left organization, the one you cited).
Do you have any fairly impartial news sources you'd care to cite?
Of course, this could all be a plot of the evil Imperialist western capitalist powers to strangle the last peoples' stronghold. /s
From your sarcasm I take it you're unaware of the history of leftist governments in Central and South America?
Even with the term "banana republic" there was an economic endgame in sight (e.g. cheaper fruit).
This current Venezuela farce has absolutely no redeeming qualities unless you're a member of the ruling elite (of Venezuela).
By your reasoning, every economic and/or political collapse in Central/South America can be blamed on the history of United States intervention, absolving the government of all accountability.
That said, I think it's possible the revolution has deteriorated since the death of Chavez and that corruption is indeed rife. I'm just wary given the history of propaganda.
I also think its possible that the administration still has popular support in spite of its real problems, given the violent right-wing nature of the opposition and the apparent lack of credible evidence suggesting otherwise.
> the violent right-wing nature of the opposition and the apparent lack of credible evidence suggesting otherwise.
People in Venezuela have lost 19 pounds on average in the past couple of years. Take a look at the exchange rates. What is the profit for "right-wing" groups?
Looks like the US need some left wing rule. But yeah this is fake news. Don't lie to pretend you have a point kiddo.
https://www.economist.com/news/finance-and-economics/2172028...
The last time I checked, the Economist is a fairly neutral news organization.
Although el gordo Maduro hasn't had too much trouble finding rice and beans, by the look of things.
How do you know that a country lost weight? They didn't show how they got these numbers, just said it as an IMF forecast. This is plain simple manipulation. It is a shame that my first comment got so many downvotes.
If you distrust all news sources that disagree with your point of view, I don't know what else to say.
This study was conducted by Venezuelan universities.
What argument would you want to hear that would make you decide that Venezuela is a hideously mismanaged dictatorship? They can't keep up production of oil, which is their (95%) only source of foreign reserves.
You seem to discredit research done by native institutions and distrust mainstream media.
I hear Victoria falls is really nice. And you can prove all the propoganda wrong. Good luck. Bring some hard currency.
People in Caracas will jack you for a biscuit and 10 (amercian) bucks.
Yes, a Bolivarian paradise. Have fun at Victoria falls.
Btw, I'm more chino than gringo. Just so you know.
The value of a nation's currency is determined by how difficult it is to get vs how much you need to get it. And that is determined by the nation's spending and taxing policies - including the ability to enforce that taxation by force if necessary.
The Bolivar needs to fully float on the international markets like the Egyptian Pound. And then the government needs to start taxing people in Bolivars while not issuing as many by spending.
It doesn't matter than nobody wants to hold Bolivars. It matters that they need to get them to stay out of jail.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2017/08/11...
The former British Labour Party Mayor of London Ken Livingston said the problem in Venezuela was that not enough rich people were murdered:
https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/aug/03/ken-livings...
An important Australian Trade Union pledged support for Maduro in August this year:
http://www.news.com.au/finance/economy/world-economy/austral...
(updated due to the comment below - thanks for that!)
In Australia there is a group called the Australian - Venezuelan solidarity network:
Trying to glue the legacy of Venezuela to Corbyn is silly. I am well aware of Corbyn's admiration of Hugo Chavez defying American intervention in Venezuela.
If the various papers in England want to keep up that theme, they should explore Conservative ties to Saudi Arabia and Pinochet's regime.
All Corbyn has to do is make a statement like "Yes, I supported Chavez but unfortunately his regime wrecked the Venezuelan Economy and his successor has become a dictator".
End of story. He doesn't and he won't. It is apologising for them when you say 'there is blame on both sides'.
The original poster said that people on left having a lot of sympathy for Venezuela and continuing to support the current regime was rare and not seeing it as a cautionary tale. It's not. A few minutes of searching find various examples around the world. There are considerably more.
Here is another bit of support for them getting upset with Corbyn for not providing more support for Maduro.
http://www.socialist.net/corbyn-ignore-the-hypocrites-and-sa...
Blaming the Venezuelan government and left wing groups for all of the recent violence is too general. In this case there really is blame on both sides.
I was recently reading https://www.jacobinmag.com/2017/07/venezuela-maduro-helicopt... , which condemns the Maduro government, wealthy right wing Venezuelans, and outside corporations who really wish Maduro would hurry up and leave so they can start trading in Venezuelans mineral and fossil fuel wealth.
The Conservative papers are totally trying to glue, at least in the minds of UK voters, Venezuela to Corbyn! I remember headlines like 'Corbyn's future plan for the UK: VENEZUELA'
There is no "apologism" in the link you posted, which is actually pretty balanced. If anything, it shows how Corbyn's position on Venezuela has evolved. He does not support or apologise for Maduro.
> The former British Labour Party Mayor of London Ken Livingston
Actually Ken Livingstone won the mayoralty as independent; the Labour candidate was Frank Dobson, Livingstone had previously been expelled from the Labour Party. The Party only endorsed him for his second mandate, revoking his expulsion by popular demand. He is currently suspended from the party again, thanks to one of those silly media storms only political hacks care about.
The Lord Mayor's a completely different, ceremonial role. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lord_Mayor_of_London
No, "we" not. Maduro/Venezuela is a teather of war the same way NK, Syria, Ukraine and Brazil are. Keep it up with the revolution, Maduro! Lula is coming back in Brazil to help you.
I've never seen anyone, even the most die-hard leftist (a species headed to extinction by the way) support Maduro policies. Only some leftist parties giving oficial statements of support, but even than with the majority of their members, not supporting it, and going against the official statements.
So i dont know in what reality you are living on.. but im sure is not the same as mine.
HN has always been, a place of good and clear information, so please, lets keep it that way.
The truth is that every major left party in Brazil supports Maduro (PT, PSOL, PCB, PCdoB, PDT, …). Sure there are dissidents, but it’s a unpopular opinion on the left-wing.
For example, take a look on this post from the leftist congressman Jean Wyllys criticizing Maduro[1]. The vast majority of comments are from leftists backlashing him or trying to argue about why Maduro measures were good and necessary.
http://www.psol50.org.br/blog/2017/07/31/secretaria-de-relac...
https://www.reddit.com/r/brasil/comments/6qw61v/secretaria_d...
In the last couple years with the things going even more south in Venezuela, sure, there's been some dissidents in some of the leftist parties, but most of them still refuses to acknowledge that.
Actually PSOL is unclear wether they endorse or reject Maduro after the National Constituent Assembly. For a Maduro supporter like you, it means that PSOL reject him. But the fact that there is discussion about it means that there are supporters within the party. The main argument was to show that there are people who support Maduro, which parent commenters doesn't believe.
The strange thing is, Brazilians is in most part conservative people, mainly in small citys, likely because the catholic background, but even so are problably the most unrepresented people in politics.
I think the so called "centrão" is very conservative with the "bullets, bovine and bible party" (Bancada BBB). The majority of the right wing (led by PSDB) is liberal and the left wing (led by the aforementioned PT - Worker Party) is progressist with a touch of liberal in the southeast and a lot conservative in the northeast.
Side note: nobody here is talking about the scandal happening in Honduras right now with the right wing government frauding the election and clashing with the population.
One was a girl, used to be afiliated to the PCdoB (brazilian communist party), wich I wold never comment about politics around, because she was not a very controled person.
Another was a guy I work with now. His parents were militnats of the Workers Party. Guy go visit Cuba every now and then, and sing the praises of Fidel Castro e Maduro every week or so... Its true, people in Brazil are now less leftist that they used to be. I think the last events, with all the corruption scnadals throwed a lot of people to a more moderated left, but you still find a lot o hardcore leftists, expecialy online.
But your comment make it look like, you cant even walk in Brazil, without finding a leftist in every corner, supporting Maduro policies.
That was i were addressing about. I generally dont bother to comment this type of comments here on HN, but i thought that in your parent comment, you were overreacting. And mind you that this for many, its their first experience to this sort of information. And giving information here tend to be more scientifically focused, more based on samples, and carefully elaborated, what you say in this forum weights much more than in other places that are already used to hiperboles.
Particularly i find good when different points of view can coexist in a democratic society.. communists, anarchists, conservatives, etc..
For me the problem is actually when there are too many of them (whatever the ideology is), believing in the same thing, because there is only one point of view.. no more dialog, or a dialetical relationship with the social status quo.
The social network mirror that says we are becoming radicals and more polarized is wrong, i dont buy it, because its not really reproduced in other environments.
90% of Brazilians don't really have a political position. Most of them just follow the media. And the national media goes from liberal left to liberal/conservative right all the time.
But if you look at the 10% of brazilians that are politically engaged, 90% of it will be left wing. 10% of it will be libertarians/free market zealots.
Communism may have lost the economic batle, byt they sure won the cultural one.
Did it? Communist China says otherwise.
Stay away from this.