News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by chiefalchemist on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:45PM (#15828409)
But that's the bigger issue isnt it? That is we keep using bandaids when the root problem is lack of competition.

Has anyone heard if Google is considering restarting Fiber? I was always under the impression that they hope the implied competition was enough. It had seemed to be working. But then it was squashed.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by Denzel on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:11PM (#15828610)
I don't claim to know what Google's motivation is/was with Fiber. But isn't it funny that the company with the most money, one of the best brands, some of the best engineering talent, and access to the deepest bench of lawyers... failed.

You can't align the stars in a straighter line than Google. And yet, they gave up. Why?

At this point, I'm rooting for SpaceX's Starlink. At least they have a chance, and a history of fantastic achievements. I trust them to follow through more than Google.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by StudentStuff on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:25PM (#15828692)
Google wanted a stick to bash Comcast, Verizon, AT&T and Centurylink with, to get them to offer better connectivity to more potential users of Google's services.

Google Fiber ultimately wasn't executed well (with fiber being installed and sitting dormant for ~1 year post installation in many areas). Had Google looked at how other ISPs operate, their ROI would've been much improved and they'd have significantly more customers today.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by pault on Monday December 04, 2017 @09:53AM (#15844218)
If you look at the GF Austin facebook page, there are hundreds of angry comments from people about paying deposits and getting trenches dug and then not hearing anything for a year. Also a lot of complaints about trenches being sloppy and making a mess of the neighborhood, although this could just be the nosy neighbor crowd.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by greglindahl on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:28PM (#15828707)
OneWeb's satellite constellation is ahead of Starlink by a couple of years. Even though I live in an urban area, which will have limited OneWeb/Starlink service due to the density of people, I hope they'll blow the lid off my current cable/phone monopsony problem.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by Denzel on Friday December 01, 2017 @10:39PM (#15829992)
Yes, I forgot about OneWeb. I'm hoping for the same from either company.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by chiefalchemist on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:51PM (#15829829)
I'm not so sure failed is accurate. Ultimately, Google wanted more having ibternet access and faster speeds. That has happened, at least where I live (in NJ near Princeton).

That said, NN is more a political issue at this point and that's Google's kryptonite.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by Denzel on Friday December 01, 2017 @10:43PM (#15830009)
I may be conflating the coincidental timing of two events: I mistakenly thought Google Fiber -- in addition to wanting more internet access and faster speeds from incumbents -- was a response to Google's NN concerns, as well.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by skinnymuch on Saturday December 02, 2017 @10:15AM (#15832140)
Google put fiber up near Princeton? Or faster speeds just ended up coming around? I'm near the area too.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by chiefalchemist on Saturday December 02, 2017 @04:57PM (#15834362)
No to Google fiber here. But FIOS and Xfinity offer gig speeds. It could have been coincidence but neither paid much attention to speed prior to GF.

Comcast also offers special rates for lower income households. Good PR. But it also does play to Google's objectives. I would think.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by marcell on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:15PM (#15828628)
You have to go city-by-city to get approval. It's painful even for a company with infinite money like Google. And Comcast will (also with infinite money) will fight you city-by-city.

Not only is city-by-city approval painful, it is also slow. Think how long it takes a city council to approve an apartment building. Now thing how long it will take them to approve a city-wide project like installing fiber lines.

Look at the Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Fiber It's a list of cities. Each one of which had to individually approve Google Fiber.

This is why there is no competition for broadband.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by xenadu02 on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:08PM (#15828989)
Eh many states passed state-wide franchise laws that eliminated city-by-city rules. It didn't help much.

Installing fiber is damn expensive. It is a hugely capital-intensive business. A sword is constantly hanging over your head as the entrenched monopolies can cut prices to $10/month at any moment in any market where you are laying fiber (trivial when they are bringing in $100/mo per customer where they are the only choice).

The only reasonable solution for natural monopolies is a regulated utility or government-owned infrastructure. Electrical choice is often done via the former, roads and water are examples of the latter.

In either case one entity should lay fiber to every home, then charge $cost + $expected_future_capital_contribution (and +7% profit if a regulated utility). Any ISP that wants to compete puts in the order and the fiber owner routes a drop to their equipment at the local CO.

Some great new technology enables 10Gbps? Not a problem - your ISP owns the ONT and can swap it out. The utility only maintains the fiber, which unlike copper doesn't have water-infiltration or degradation problems.

Even though I have sonic fiber in SF it is actually a waste: on the poles in front of my house there are three completely duplicated pieces of communications infrastructure: copper phone lines, copper cable lines, and sonic fiber. If ATT ever bothers to install fiber then I'll have duplicate fiber lines. That is a deadweight loss for basically no benefit and only enables 2-3 competitors rather than potentially 20 or 30.

No system is perfect and free markets are simply terrible at handling natural monopolies.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by notyourday on Sunday December 03, 2017 @12:49PM (#15838570)
> Installing fiber is damn expensive. It is a hugely capital-intensive business. A sword is constantly hanging over your head as the entrenched monopolies can cut prices to $10/month at any moment in any market where you are laying fiber (trivial when they are bringing in $100/mo per customer where they are the only choice).

That's not correct. Installing fiber is extremely cheap. DWDM prisms are cheap. Long range 10G optics is dirt cheap.

> Even though I have sonic fiber in SF it is actually a waste: on the poles in front of my house there are three completely duplicated pieces of communications infrastructure: copper phone lines, copper cable lines, and sonic fiber. If ATT ever bothers to install fiber then I'll have duplicate fiber lines. That is a deadweight loss for basically no benefit and only enables 2-3 competitors rather than potentially 20 or 30.

And this "we want perfection", ladies and gentlemen, is why you are not getting telecom competition.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by AlphaSite on Saturday December 02, 2017 @12:45AM (#15830407)
This is basically what BT openreach is. A very heavily regulated utility.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by rayiner on Saturday December 02, 2017 @01:22AM (#15830534)
BT OpenReach is a regulated utility, but not a very heavily regulated utility. Ofcom did what the FCC managed to completely screw up: create an unbundling regime that still made investing in infrastructure worthwhile. The FCC set wholesale rates so low that it killed DSL as a viable competitor. Ofcom, meanwhile, conducted tons of economic analysis before privatizing BT, and set rates high enough where BT OpenReach is actually about as profitable as Comcast or TWC. (Of course, the new government is in the process of trying to completely screw up BT with new universal service obligations).
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by StudentStuff on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:21PM (#15828675)
Google also didn't know how to operate as a communications infrastructure provider. Many of the fiberhuts they built sit with few customers connected today due to poor marketing and long delays to get each customer connected.

Comparatively, Centurylink will have salespeople knocking on peoples doors two weeks after running fiber, with installs occurring a few days later.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by notyourday on Sunday December 03, 2017 @12:45PM (#15838555)
ROW/easement for telecom approvals should be taken away from municipalities all together. You would be amazed how quickly you would get competitors to VZ/Comcast.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by chiefalchemist on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:47PM (#15829815)
So there ya go. They're letting us eat net neutrality when the real root problem goes unaddressed.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by SubiculumCode on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:53PM (#15828473)
It is time it is treated as a utility and price regulated like one.

oh and $66 for the base package cable internet package (for me), way too much.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by jrnichols on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:41PM (#15829211)
> It is time it is treated as a utility and price regulated like one.

Having lived in an area that had Pacific Gas & Electric, who has infrastructure so old and decrepit that it literally exploded and destroyed part of a town, i'm not so sure that I want my internet access being treated like a utility.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Bruno_pipeline_explosion

also, their amazingly out of control prices, rolling blackouts, etc.

Seeing people say that they want the internet treated like a utility kind of scare me.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by dave5104 on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:23PM (#15829464)
I think that's a bit too apples-to-oranges. The internet "pipes" won't explode if they're not maintained properly.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by beached_whale on Friday December 01, 2017 @11:50PM (#15830221)
Also an example of ineffective regulation.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by jrnichols on Sunday December 03, 2017 @06:30PM (#15840275)
no, they'll just decay to the point of being unusable.

just like our copper wire infrastructure has done.

yet the telcos/etc will collect billions from us and the government and will build nothing. :/

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by rayiner on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:36PM (#15829171)
Wireless is going to make all this moot: https://www.seattletimes.com/business/americans-abandoning-w....

> And 15 percent of households earning more than $100,000 are mobile-only, versus 6 percent in 2013.

These are households who can easily afford wired broadband. But a growing number of people simply find wireless to be fast enough and place a high value on mobility.

5G wireless is going to make wired broadband obsolete, and also solve the competition problem. Unlike laying fiber, it's easy to have several different competing 5G networks in the same place. Once you get above about 100 mbps (and LTE-A is already there in some places), the mobility advantage is going to totally dominate any incremental improvement in speed for 80% of people.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by 0xcde4c3db on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:41PM (#15829790)
I'd guess that most of those households are still getting a cable or satellite TV package. My OTT-exclusive household routinely breaks 100GB/month, and we aren't even very heavy TV watchers by American standards. To get that at equivalent speeds is an order of magnitude more expensive from every wireless provider I've checked, after eliminating the ones that don't even offer an equivalent combination (e.g. ~$700/month from Verizon, ~$1000/month from a local WISP). I'm not a metro-scale wireless guru, but I have a hard time believing that any realistic 5G deployment is going to have enough capacity to handle a large-scale exodus from wired connections.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by chiefalchemist on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:53PM (#15829842)
Yes. But who often provides that? Verizon, and now Comcast as well. Same players, slightly different service.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by notyourday on Sunday December 03, 2017 @12:50PM (#15838578)
Bawawawhahahaha.

You realize that the more wireless you have the more fiber backhaul you need with the towers and fiber everywhere?

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by veidr on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:25PM (#15829095)
> But that's the bigger issue isnt it?

Yes, but so what? There is no chance we're going to get meaningful competition among Internet providers in the USA.

So you can choose an imperfect but helpful solution that exists today, or a perfect theoretical solution that doesn't and won't.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by chiefalchemist on Saturday December 02, 2017 @07:52AM (#15831674)
But it's not a solution to a problem. It's a solution to a symptom. We do this all the time and then wonder why we waste so much time revisiting things.

Or. You can "accept" NN in the short term knowing it's going to cause a negative reaction in the market. That tension will build, the market will become more aware, and then demand the problem be addressed and solved.

The point is, the current solution being proposed by so many actual keep the powerful status quo intact. They win either way. Is that a win for the rest of us? I think not.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by msla on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:11PM (#15828606)
We can't focus on fixing a root problem so intently we fail to fix an immediate problem.

Lack of NN is an immediate problem. We must fix that. If we don't, we lose, and we might not be able to win the bigger fight, against monopolization, for a very long time.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by wmf on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:52PM (#15828876)
Or is competition a bandaid for a lack of neutral service? Which is the means and which is the end?

My impression is that Fiber's implied competition only worked in cities where Google got pretty far along. Prices in other cities don't seem to be affected.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by allenz on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:18PM (#15829055)
I think that they're independent goals. I don't think that competition would guarantee NN. Competition promotes better customer service and faster internet at lower prices, which is also good.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by chiefalchemist on Saturday December 02, 2017 @07:48AM (#15831666)
Could be. But the threat also moved slow and never really became a real enough threat. Also, I believe Googe was ultimately pushing for speed and availability; price and NN less so.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by jlarocco on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:11PM (#15829009)
Google already has a history of favoring their own products and services, and I don't trust them to be neutral if they're acting as an ISP.

Without a law mandating neutrality, no ISP is going to ignore the possibility of making extra money selling preferred bandwidth. Maybe they wait until the uproar dies down, but no doubt they'll look into it eventually.