News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by conradev on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:05PM (#15827471)
If they switched to using phone calls to discuss sensitive information and didn't record them, would they still be violating the rules?
Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by huac on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:37PM (#15828353)
There are numerous legitimate reasons for wanting to speak out loud for a conversation. But, if they said "let's do a call so that we can avoid putting possibly incriminating material to disk" then that would violate the rules, and is analogous to what is being alleged here.
Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by yongjik on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:16PM (#15828636)
IANAL, but the rule must be more subtle than that, because I lost the count of times I saw "Everyone please stop responding to this email. If anybody has a question please call us." while I was at $(huge SV company). Or something like "This conference will not be recorded due to the sensitivity of the topic."

(Not the exact wording, but the intent was clear. They even educated every employee on the importance of not writing down stuff that may be later quote-mined in a lawsuit.)

Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by tw04 on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:29PM (#15829120)
>(Not the exact wording, but the intent was clear. They even educated every employee on the importance of not writing down stuff that may be later quote-mined in a lawsuit.)

There's a MASSIVE difference between not writing stuff down because you have no idea if your competitors may use it against you in a future lawsuit, and not writing stuff down because you know what you're discussing is illegal.

Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by codedokode on Saturday December 02, 2017 @06:38AM (#15831479)
> because you know what you're discussing is illegal.

How can you know that if you are not a lawyer?

Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by tw04 on Saturday December 02, 2017 @08:42AM (#15831814)
Outside of the fact that's a ridiculous question because I could cite COUNTLESS things the every day man knows is illegal - it's not the point. The point is if you aren't writing stuff down because you BELIEVE what you're discussing is illegal, and it violates your own retention policies - if you aren't outright breaking a law in your state, you're actively engaging in a massive ethics violation.
Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by codedokode on Saturday December 02, 2017 @12:19PM (#15832869)
Then you should from the start make a policy not to keep any logs. The only use of those logs is to prove that you are guilty so it makes no sense to keep them.

Even if you didn't do anything illegal, they can be used against you anyway.

Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by Shoothe on Saturday December 02, 2017 @04:32PM (#15834200)
That's the reasoning behind data retention policies. Lawyers don't see data older than N months. Even if you're not guilty lawyers can be costly when they need to analyze large amounts of data.
Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by paxy on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:42PM (#15828812)
I guess the difference is how obvious it is to everyone involved that you're engaging in an illegal activity.
Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by btian on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:08PM (#15827503)
no. that's why most corporate lawyers prefer you call them instead of email
Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by ryandrake on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:29PM (#15828292)
What is a phone call, if not "a conversation that self-destructs after it's done"?

Not commenting on how the law (which was written before "apps" existed) treats it, but on the true nature of a phone call vs. a messaging app.

Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by DannyBee on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:13PM (#15829668)
There are many many records of phone calls. I can ask your phone provider for them. I can subpoena you and make you testify to their content, etc.
Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by Spooky23 on Saturday December 02, 2017 @12:25AM (#15830336)
If your specific conduct is under investigation, sure.

This stuff is more about opposing counsel searching for keywords and finding something that adds supposed context to whatever they are suing about. If you send an inappropriate picture of a woman and make some crude comment, that can be used to bolster a harassment claim or establish a pattern of boorish behavior. If you make crude comments on the phone, that isn’t going to as easily reappear 5 years later.

Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by spayu61 on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:36PM (#15828350)
I believe the difference is intent--a phone call self destructs by default. They are not meant to be recorded (we even have laws here that prohibit it without consent of both parts). Messaging apps have, traditionally, kept logs, in both ends and in the server.
Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by ISL on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:01PM (#15828542)
Entirely agreed, though it is true that intentionally-private messaging apps have, traditionally, not kept logs. That's a tradition worth keeping!
Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by wglb on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:39PM (#15828375)
No, that is why you see the legal disclaimer--either attorney work product or "privileged communication".
Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by DannyBee on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:31PM (#15829750)
If you are talking with a lawyer, it's different than talking with a non-lawyer
Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by Spooky23 on Saturday December 02, 2017 @12:18AM (#15830309)
IANAL, but have dealt with ediscovery.

Generally speaking you have latitude to do what you normally do within a medium. If you routinely delete mail every quarter, that’s ok. If you routinely record phone calls that’s ok. But there is no requirement to talk or write.

Once you reasonably suspect that you are in the scope of an investigation or litigation, you need to take steps to preserve relevant things. Guidance from counsel is a good idea.

Discovery is a double edged sword. Moving deliberative activity to phone calls or meetings doesn’t mean there is no record of the encounter. To the contrary, one or more parties are probably taking notes that align with their perceptions. (And self interest!) It all depends on the situation.

Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by Zigurd on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:09PM (#15827518)
In most cases no, but the difference is only due to the greater challenge of recording conversations "in the field." There are plenty of cases where phone calls must be recorded.
Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by ggg9990 on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:17PM (#15828188)
The way this works is that the law (lawmakers, courts, police) take a dim view of loopholes, as it's a threat to their own power. So they sit down and decide whhether you were in compliance with the spirit of the law and write laws in a way to criminalize that to the extent possible. It's not code.
Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by joering2 on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:37PM (#15828356)
It depends how important your phonecall is from National Security point of view. If its a matter of bribery or even kidnapping, nothing can be done, but if its about some proven terrorist plot, ATT can recover your calls (so do probably all other vendors; we just don't know the details, aka black boxes)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A

Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by icebraining on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:07PM (#15828577)
Which has absolutely nothing to do with whether Uber itself is required to record them.
Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents by joering2 on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:25PM (#15828694)
for sure more than your comment had.