News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by wybiral on Thursday November 30, 2017 @10:42AM (#15816559)
Every single video, without exception, that I've uploaded in the past few months has been demonetized within a day or two. Then I request manual review and they're monetized again within another day or two.

My content is clean and all of it is programming/tech related (programming tutorials and some Raspberry Pi stuff).

So if there is an algorithm it's really naive at this stage or it doesn't apply until you request manual review.

Re:YouTube monetization analysis by vbernat on Thursday November 30, 2017 @11:41AM (#15817119)
Some users are publishing the video as a private video first, get demonetized, ask for the review, the video is monetized again and user can publish it as a public video.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by falcolas on Thursday November 30, 2017 @11:50AM (#15817198)
This doesn't help people posting time-sensitive content such as news or reviews. Those who used to fill this niche who have been targeted by the algorithms are seeing upwards of 90% loss in revenue despite having all videos re-monitized after manual review.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by delecti on Thursday November 30, 2017 @11:51AM (#15817209)
Are you sure that's possible? I've heard that a video needs to be averaging a certain number of videos (something like 1000/week) before they'll do the manual review.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by vbernat on Thursday November 30, 2017 @02:22PM (#15818669)
My source is this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IM-gFU74UzA. This could possibly be false.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by benawad on Thursday November 30, 2017 @12:05PM (#15817324)
I make programming videos too, and a similar thing happens to me. The first day I release a video it's demonetized, and even if I don't request a manual review the video will be remonetized a couple days later.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by wybiral on Thursday November 30, 2017 @12:14PM (#15817418)
Interesting. Maybe YouTube needs to adjust their algorithm for that category or something.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by mitchty on Thursday November 30, 2017 @12:38PM (#15817639)
I'd bet this behavior is their algorithm "working as intended".

Aka, advertisers saying they don't want to waste ad spend on worthless programming videos. So they get demonetized for the first few days to reduce the impact of any ad spend on the times that would be most likely to get views, then turn it on so the drip of ad spend can treat the videos like problem children.

Re:YouTube monetization analysis by wybiral on Thursday November 30, 2017 @12:49PM (#15817752)
I'm more inclined to think that the algorithms are just a bit naive at this point. Surely some advertisers out there do want to target that market.

The notice on my videos is: Limited or no ads due to content identified as not suitable for most advertisers[1]. Your video remains fully playable and is eligible to earn subscription revenue from YouTube Red.

[1] https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/6162278?hl=en

Re:YouTube monetization analysis by mitchty on Thursday November 30, 2017 @01:50PM (#15818374)
Sure, just curious that the videos would be monetized after the first few days. From what I've heard the first few days of a video basically makes/breaks a lot of videos as far as monetization goes.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by mintplant on Thursday November 30, 2017 @03:02PM (#15818986)
My guess is at this early stage of deployment, videos flagged by the algorithm to be demonetized (or a sample thereof) are automatically put into some manual review queue, for training and validation, which takes a few days to process through the volume.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by scottlocklin on Thursday November 30, 2017 @07:18PM (#15820909)
Keep your eye on their 10Q statements next quarter. If it is what you say, it should turn up in the financials.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by nym on Thursday November 30, 2017 @03:20PM (#15819140)
Udemy does a lot of advertising.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by bcoates on Thursday November 30, 2017 @07:17PM (#15820900)
If I had to guess, videos consisting of mostly text (screencasts/slide shows) are considered likely to be bad videos (spammy junk and make-money-fast scams) and programming stuff is getting caught in the crossfire
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by RyanShook on Thursday November 30, 2017 @10:45AM (#15816585)
In my experience, Youtube demonetizes based on metadata. So any tags/descriptions with keywords that YT views as “controversial” the system will demonetize regardless of actual content in the video.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by wybiral on Thursday November 30, 2017 @10:49AM (#15816634)
I uploaded a video yesterday that's already demonetized. It's part of a series to write an RSS feed reader in Python (specifically the part about adding static files to the server).

Tags: python, rss, feedparser, feed reader, news aggregator, flask, css, static files

It doesn't seem "controversial" to me.

Re:YouTube monetization analysis by nana_gb on Thursday November 30, 2017 @02:30PM (#15818748)
I'm 99.9% sure it's nothing to do with your tags and everything to do with some sort of speech to text analysis google is doing on your video.

In my case, I have a demonitized tutorial video on how to download and upgrade my software.

I was a bit surprised since it was a basic boring screen share video. Nothing controversial either, until I looked at the auto generated close captioning.

I said "Prosper202" but Google heard "pr0st!tut3" (I edited the actual word just in case HN also has auto block filters) But as you can see, it's obviously a not safe for brands keyword.

I've manually fixed the closed captioning with the correct words, but as of now the video is still demonetized.

So I think there's some sort of blacklist of words said in videos that will auto demonetize videos.

In your case, after watching your video with closed captioning I notice you use the word "explicit" a lot in your video. Once again given the context, it's totally safe. But there's also a very unsafe context that I doubt google is willing to automatically monetize without some sort of manual review. (https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/6162278?hl=en)

You can request a manual review of the affected videos, but only if your video has 1000 views in the past 7 days. For most small channels wrongly flagged, there's no real fix (for the old video).

The only real suggestion to test out is to not say explicit in your next video.

I'm also interested in hearing from others with demonetized videos, that may be suffering from the same auto captioning and blacklisted words issue.

Re:YouTube monetization analysis by londons_explore on Thursday November 30, 2017 @06:00PM (#15820448)
This is correct.

Videos are demonetized mostly on a blacklist of bad words. Run text to speech on the video before upload (preferably upload the audio only on a test channel and download the captions), and edit out all words which have any negative connotation whatsoever.

Beware - the blacklist contains a lot of words which are only bad in a certain language or a certain region or slang you might be unaware of. Use urban dictionary to find the bad words... It seems you can let a few slip through, but if a bad word appears too many times, it causes demonetization.

Re:YouTube monetization analysis by wybiral on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:04PM (#15827457)
That seems like an absurd step to require for every upload. Their algorithm should really give me the benefit of the doubt after having required manual review dozens of times and always having my content remonetized.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by wybiral on Thursday November 30, 2017 @03:19PM (#15819137)
That's a good point. I've seen my captioning be WAY off from what I actually said.

But when I request a manual review the videos do seem to get monetized again within a few days... Even with less than 1000 views.

Re:YouTube monetization analysis by koolba on Thursday November 30, 2017 @11:01AM (#15816749)
You should try making the same video with a parser written in Golang and see if that get's demonetized as well.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by wybiral on Thursday November 30, 2017 @11:04AM (#15816785)
The series before this one was about Golang and they all got demonetized too.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by 1_2__4 on Thursday November 30, 2017 @11:18AM (#15816917)
I'm not sure which is funnier, his comment or your deadpan response.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by lettergram on Thursday November 30, 2017 @10:51AM (#15816658)
I'm wondering if "flask" is getting flagged (as in relation to alcohol.

Or news, because you know - "fake news"

Re:YouTube monetization analysis by wybiral on Thursday November 30, 2017 @10:59AM (#15816720)
Maybe, but the series before that had nothing to do with flask or news.

For instance a video in a series about writing a Go web app had these tags: golang, http, server, redis, gorilla mux, go-redis, web, application, tutorial, howto

And it was demonetized. Every single video I've uploaded seems to have been until I request manual review (which takes a couple of days).

Re:YouTube monetization analysis by londons_explore on Thursday November 30, 2017 @06:02PM (#15820459)
gorilla is a racist term...

The algorithm doesn't understand context.

Re:YouTube monetization analysis by siruncledrew on Thursday November 30, 2017 @03:18PM (#15819123)
With "flask", "python", and "feed" the NLP is assuming you are some kind of alcoholic snake wrangler?
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by burger_moon on Thursday November 30, 2017 @11:42AM (#15817131)
What's a link to your channel? You've at least got me interested in checking it out.
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by wybiral on Thursday November 30, 2017 @11:49AM (#15817185)
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC6tqFmkqznYJTzidBerHA8g

The video from yesterday (08 - CSS and static files) is still demonetized. If that gives you any context.

Re:YouTube monetization analysis by kawsper on Thursday November 30, 2017 @10:53AM (#15816680)
Do you know which excluded_ads labels it was tagged with?
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by wybiral on Thursday November 30, 2017 @11:02AM (#15816759)
For the video I uploaded yesterday, in the source for the video I can see:

"excluded_ads": "46=14_14; 59=14_14; 76=2_2_1,2_2_4; 102=1_1,1_3,2_1,2_3; 106=1_1,1_2_1,1_3,2_1,2_2_1,2_2_4,2_3,14_14,17_2_1,17_2_4"

EDIT: This may just be the generic variable in their source code, I'm not sure how to get the value specific to my video.

Re:YouTube monetization analysis by ocdtrekkie on Thursday November 30, 2017 @10:50AM (#15816645)
Try without the word "news", perhaps?
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by TheCoreh on Thursday November 30, 2017 @10:50AM (#15816650)
Perhaps "news"?
Re:YouTube monetization analysis by superflyguy on Thursday November 30, 2017 @11:02AM (#15816757)
Feedp arse r maybe?