News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by nikbackm on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @07:19AM (#15796526)
Well, surely DRM prevents enough users from copying the product to make it worthwhile?

It does not need to be perfect to achieve that.

Many people will never go looking for tools to break the DRM or DRM-free copies from torrent sites and the like.

But if anyone could just copy what they see on e.g. Netflix with the click of a button, then many more probably would.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by belorn on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @07:41AM (#15796673)
No, the cost of DRM do not repay itself by preventing enough users. There have been tests cases, studies, and the repeated conclusion I keep seeing is that DRM has no correlation to the revenue from individual music, games and films. It has however a correlation to platform and user retention, which is what this article continuously refers to.

To take a few examples, remember when the European Commission hired researches to do a study on the effect of piracy? What about the revenue from itunes after it went DRM free? Sale of music that is available on youtube after it went HTML5? Revenue from music, film, and games on the longer term after aggressive blocking of torrent sites? What about the long term effect from anti-piracy/DRM laws?

The whole EFF article ends on the conclusion that DRM will not exist if their only purpose is to prevents enough users from copying the product. That effect won't be worthwhile enough to pay the cost of DRM. Only a sticky platform that prevent competition will bring the revenue to validate investing into DRM.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by Mindwipe on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @08:16AM (#15796912)
The European commission study you're referring to a) said that piracy did make a difference on Hollywood films (it said it didn't make much difference in other sectors, but for major films it did) and b) had such enormous margins of error it was essentially worthless.

You're not helping your case by bringing up evidence you don't site except for one example where it showed the opposite to your claims

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by belorn on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @09:48AM (#15797673)
The report states:

"In general, the results do not show robust statistical evidence of displacement of sales by online copyright infringements. That does not necessarily mean that piracy has no effect but only that the statistical analysis does not prove with sufficient reliability that there is an effect. An exception is the displacement of recent top films."

The difference is not for all Hollywood films, a finding that I recall other studies have found before the EU one when they looked at movies that got leaked before a cinema release. But comparing Cinema DRM to EME is like Apples to oranges, they are not the same thing. Cinema DRM is not intended for end users.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by tinus_hn on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @09:57AM (#15797756)
So in general it doesn’t show anything, except for top movies.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by simias on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @08:53AM (#15797234)
> Well, surely DRM prevents enough users from copying the product to make it worthwhile?

What I don't understand is that it's not how it works, all it takes is for one single user to make a copy and upload it on newsgroups/bittorrent/... and it's available for everybody.

That means that in order for DRM to work you need a 100% success rate at preventing unprotected copies. This seems absolutely implausible.

Since I'm unhappy with the selection and compatibility of the current streaming services offering I keep pirating all the TV shows and movies I watch and they're always available for download mere hours after their official/legal counterparts. It's not like videogames where intricate anti-piracy measures can take weeks or even sometimes months to break, here it's mostly about the time for the pirated copy to disseminate on the network.

I wonder by which metric video DRM can be said to work. It's a pain for legit users because they can't view their movies and shows on all of their devices easily and it's a complete non-issue for pirates.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by JulianMorrison on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @08:19AM (#15796934)
People don't go to Netflix because they can't get it anywhere else. Bittorrent is still a thing.

People go to Netflix because you pay once and then you can just watch stuff.

So they don't really need any sort of protection to stop piracy. They need it to corner and control the legal market.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by imtringued on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @08:22AM (#15796951)
It does need to be perfect to achieve that. If only one pirate can bypass the protection then everyone can just go to a streaming site and watch the movies without DRM.

Controlling illegitimate users is impossible. Therefore the purpose of DRM is control over legitimate users to the point where they can harm legitimate competitors.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by gmueckl on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @08:47AM (#15797178)
This argument is deeply flawed. It is never about the few people who have the technical skills to circumvent copy protection schemes.

Copy protection needs only to be economic. It works as soon as accepting the copy protection is convenient enough that enough customers prefer it to hunting down an illegal copy with good enough quality and without protection.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by revelation on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @09:19AM (#15797478)
That makes absolutely no sense. You need to pay to access Netflix. What then does DRM on Netflix achieve in making the "customer accept the copy protection"? The customer already fricking paid!

Everything that is on Netflix you can already get on TPB (since the DRM is ineffective to those with technical skills), so how could the existence of DRM possibly have influenced the customers decision to pay vs. pirate?

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by Mindwipe on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @09:32AM (#15797563)
The Pirate Bay is a much higher technical bar for general non-technical users than the average Hacker News poster seems to understand.

There are lots of people who can right click save as who will never, ever, ever torrent.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by depressedpanda on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @12:10PM (#15799095)
That argument is flawed. To prevent the plebs from right click-saving, it's enough to add some Javascript. If they have the skills to work around that, they have the skills to torrent.

So what does DRM solve again?

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by jtuente on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @05:55PM (#15802704)
Side-stepping a little bit of javascript is something that can be taught trivially, avoiding malicious sources is not.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by pavelludiq on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:15AM (#15797945)
Considering torrenting is the preferred method to view online content at least here in Bulgaria, and I assume in most of the rest of the non-western world, I would advise against underestimating the technical abilities of most internet users.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by briandear on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @11:33AM (#15798733)
You’ve never had to answer tech support tickets for a SME SAAS product, clearly.

“How to I reset my password?”

“Click ‘Forgot Password’”

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by revelation on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @01:48PM (#15800141)
This isn't an answer why DRM is making these customers choose Netflix over piracy. These people don't even know what DRM is.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by Mindwipe on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @11:59AM (#15798972)
> Considering torrenting is the preferred method to view online content at least here in Bulgaria

You're really getting "my own peer bubble" and "the general population" mixed up.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by Mediterraneo10 on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @03:12PM (#15800979)
Next door in Romania, I agree with what he says. Using torrenting or other pirate source is standard practice for anyone under the age of 35-40. It is by no means limited to a niche demographic of tech anoraks. A decade ago in my city, before the big ISP mergers, when you signed up for broadband internet our local ISP would actually give you the username and password for an eMule server where you could quickly share films and music with other people in the city.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by simion314 on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:08AM (#15797867)
It is not hard to find a illegal copy of a movie, you just need to know how to google, eventually you will find a website that embeds the video, no need for torrent application, downloading and running software.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by gmueckl on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @12:53PM (#15799565)
So tell me again why I should fire up Google, look for some shady website with dubiously dangerous ads to download or stream a movie when I can just fire up the Netflix app, tap the movie I want and start watching?
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by simion314 on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @01:06PM (#15799721)
I think you did not understand my point, I have a steam and gog account, I pay for Intellij so I am not advocating for piracy, my point is that DRM does not make piracy super hard that only developers and linux users can pirate movies, I gave an example that you can watch a movie just by knowing how to use google, I am also sure that children in schools will teach each other how to get latest cartoons via torrent or website. If you go on gog.com you will see a large number of games, DRM free, music is now mostly DRM free, again my point is that Netflix offering a DRM free stream will not cause the number of subscribers to drop, because piracy is not that hard as the previous comment said it is. I agree with you 100%, I would pay the subscription to Netflix to avoid those websites, but it would be cool that I would not have to buy special hardware for it. P.S. I do not use or considered using Netflix because of my Internet speed.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by gmueckl on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @01:57PM (#15800226)
And you misunderstand my point. DRM plays into many other measures to provide a sufficient incentive to seek commercial offers over piracy. DRM makes the initial copying hard. This pushes illegal copies into the dark corners of the web because of their lowered availability. At this point DRM was already successful.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by simion314 on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @06:38PM (#15803085)
I did not notice any change since DRM was implemented for movies, piracy was illegal before and piracy is not much harder with DRMed videos, you can watch Game of Thrones immediately as it is released. Maybe you think is harder now but is easy to pirate and easy to find the pirated content with google, then click play and done. If you have time I recommend reading gog.com page on wikipedia and also find the interviews with CD Project Red devs about DRM.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by gmueckl on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @04:31PM (#15811056)
And then there are publishers that experiment with DRM. I distincrly remember one older case where the add-on to a game that contained copy protection sold more copies than the base game without protection. How do you explain that?
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by thinkMOAR on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @08:11AM (#15796885)
As long as there is a moment where you properly show content to a user, there is a moment he can copy what he sees perfectly too, therefor DRM will never work.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by icebraining on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @07:41AM (#15796671)
If it's just to prevent that, you could just have a "copy=false" attribute on the tag, which browsers would respect. No need for proprietary encryption nonsense.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by Mindwipe on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @08:16AM (#15796917)
Browsers didn't respect Do Not Track.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by icebraining on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @08:18AM (#15796927)
I don't understand what you mean. DNT is a flag supposed to be respected by web services, not by browsers.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by logfromblammo on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @09:52AM (#15797712)
Some versions of some browsers turned DNT on by default. Respecting DNT in this instance would have always made this flag a choice by the user.

There is still room to argue that the user's choice was to install a browser that made DNT the default option.

But it's a moot point, since the sort of web services that were in mind when DNT was proposed largely ignored it. They never set the evil bit in their responses, either.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by shmerl on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:54AM (#15798320)
> Well, surely DRM prevents enough users from copying the product to make it worthwhile?

It surely does not. DRM is broken (by any skilled pirate), and the rest of pirating users can get it without said DRM after that. So let's make it clear. Usage of DRM has nothing to do with piracy.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by mtgx on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @09:24AM (#15797507)
No, not really. You're thinking that every user has to copy a movie from the browser. But only a very tiny percentage of the people wanting to see the latest Game of Thrones episode need to steal it so that everyone else who intended to pirate it can watch it as well.

Whether or not DRM exists for those other 99.99% of the people is completely irrelevant. The show is already on torrents put there by those who could bypass the technical protection of DRM. So now those 99.99% of users can watch it for free, too, without having to know how to bypass DRM themselves.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by rhino369 on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:58AM (#15798371)
You drastically underestimate the amount of piracy that occurs from just “cntrl c cntrl V”ing files.

The goal is just to make it just hard enough to pirate that the masses don’t spend the time to figure it out.

My mom and her friends pass around cds and rip them on iTunes. Because it is easy. She’s pirated hundreds of cds. She didn’t know what what.cd is. She doesn’t know what the new version of what.cd. I don’t either.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by logfromblammo on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:18AM (#15797974)
The more difficult it is to strip DRM, the fewer pirate captains there are. You don't need to take out every pirate to end piracy; you just need to take out every captain.

So if only Paisleybeard and VikingVik can crack the GoT DRM, you maybe only need to get cooperation from the Croatian and Swedish police for a few weeks, and then you get some amount of time when pirated shows are no longer available. But then Swashbuggerer and NotSoJollyRoger and Plaidbeard step up, and the pirate crews flock to their standards. But for a time, some people who might have otherwise pirated may have paid. But then you're back to talking to the American and Filipino and Scottish police. And if one of your captains is in a non-extradition country, you may have to talk to Pinkertons or ex-military contractors.

If it is trivial to crack the DRM, everyone can be a pirate captain if necessary, with a crew of only themselves. You will never, ever stop piracy for longer than a few minutes in any pirate-friendly household with that kind of DRM. That's like the difference between posting your property and putting up an actual fence or wall. It is just a virtual boundary that has legal consequences in the out-of-band enforcement system.

And don't forget that when pirate captains voluntarily retire, or are forcibly retired, they can still publish "how to be a pirate captain" guides for the media-seas they once sailed. They can distribute models for 3D-printing your very own pirate ship. So the DRM-makers have to put constant effort into changing tactics and updating technical countermeasures to fight that kind of fight. It gets to be expensive, because the defense has to be perfect, while the offense can breach it through any ant-sized hole. Furthermore, the analog hole will always be there, and every paying customer has the keys to your fortress gate.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by simion314 on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:27AM (#15798045)
You do not need DRM to put people in jail for pirating, this thing happened before DRM.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by logfromblammo on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @12:56PM (#15799599)
You do need DRM to strategically put specific people in jail for pirating, in a way that would not be dismissed by your consumer base as either petty or draconian.

You need the DRM to go after one Kim Dotcom, instead of getting civil judgments from a thousand unremarkable people who were just doing the same thing that hundreds of thousands of other people do routinely and innocuously, without ever getting caught. You need it to narrow down the size of a class of people until it is safe to demonize and turn into examples, without alienating your potential customers.

Without DRM, when grandma gets sued for $10000 because she sent a copyrighted video to all 8 of her grandkids, the rights-owner looks like a bad guy. But when a nerd cracks the DRM and seeds a torrent resulting in thousands of downloads, prosecutors can pile on the computer crime charges, and it looks like the hacker is a dangerous criminal, who was probably stealing your identity and browsing through your cloud photos, too.

It's all about public perceptions. Shooting people in the head is somehow less acceptable if you didn't draw a line in the sand first. People get distracted from the main issue--which is people getting shot in the head--if the victims could have made some choice that would have yielded a different result. The public then gets fixated on where the line should be drawn, rather than taking away the shotgun from the homicidal maniac.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by simion314 on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @02:33PM (#15800597)
I agree with you that this law is harder then copyright law, but your comment is not clear what is your opinion if you think it is justified to have such a law.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by logfromblammo on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @03:56PM (#15801509)
My opinion is that DRM-supporting laws are not only unjustified, but their existence is also an impediment to true copyright reform.