That said, the top brass at the agency/Netflix/etc should be ensuring processes are in place to require obtaining/verifying licences for the images used.
If some idiot designer grabs images from Google Image Search, and fails to inform anyone, it's still management's fault for not verifying those things.
It's not okay, but it's also not a HUGE crime. This is a civil matter, worst case it'll cost some money as they buy a license after the fact... or pay settlement in court.
It's perfectly reasonable to NOT stifle your organization with cumbersome processes to verify licenses.. Because these things rarely happens, and when they do are often worked out at low cost.
The DMCA says to stop infringement upon notification. It doesn't specify unlimited penalties for accidental infringement. If so YouTube and most of the internet would die at the hands of greedy copyright holders.
Forget to do that and now you need to pay out for acquiring the licence afterwards - and you'd better hope there was nobody identifiable in it because getting a modelling release afterwards can be even more expensive (after all, both the photographer and the model know they have you over a barrel).
Also don't bother billing the client afterwards, after that kind of screw up you'll be on eggshells with the client. Do it twice and you definitely won't have a client to worry about.
let's be fair, little harm was done here..
Just to keep things going straight — that's usually an art director's role on such a project. Senior management likely wants nothing to do with tasks like ensuring copyrights and IP issues are paid out. The art directors are usually the ones who know better. Senior-level managers may know, but they may also pay other people to know better.
To people who argue that the person at the agency should have used a microstock agency, the problem is, the image you get from a microstock agency (without an account) almost always has a big watermark on it, so it can't be used to make an acceptable mockup.
To get an image from a microstock agency without a watermark you need an account, and the junior designer tasked with doing the mockup probably doesn't have one, and she didn't have time either to go ask for one.
Bad process? Certainly. But big corporations don't necessarily have good process. They have people sitting around in offices, subcontracting everything to consulting companies who in turn try to have the work done by unpaid interns if possible. Okay, that may be a caricature -- but truer than it sounds.
[ADDED: But, yeah, lots of last minute stuff happens on deadline.]
Wouldn't that make it the perfect mockup material, as in, good enough to preview the finished result, impossible to land in production?
The problem is, if your source images have watermarks and the competing design agencies' don't, Netflix is going to pick your mockups for finishing less often because they don't look as good. The market selects for design agencies that don't use images with massive watermarks in their mockups.
Makes me ponder what other kinds of angles of approach are required to "fix" this problem.
It's only supposed to help you envision the final product, no more no less.
But there is one more if: if the box design was commissioned into the subcontractor chain by Target and not by Netflix (with Netflix only licencing the Blu-ray content), then no company will consider themselves responsible: not Netflix, because they really had nothing to do with the box design and not Target, because the bad PR will appear in front of Netflix's door.
Commercial stock image sites were invented for situations like this. Not having time (or whatever) to pay for your stock photography stops being a valid excuse when you rise above the level of "bake sale flyer".
http://www.gettyimages.com/photos/vhs-tapes?excludenudity=tr...
Copyright is not a small thing, as the MPAA likes to remind everyone.
Also, maybe there is something bigger here: maybe someone scraped the image and resells them through shutterstock.
In any case, the owner is way within his rights. Why not insist on them? If the rubber band was on the other claw, Netflix would not hesitate.
It turned out that the music sounded exactly like Eminem's "Lose Yourself" and he successfully sued them http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objecti...
So while it's fair to say that Netflix probably had no idea it doesn't change the fact that they're using images that were stolen.
I'm guessing you'd have to do something like, require every artist to list the resources they used for their image with some link to the source and license rights. But I'm also not sure how expensive that solution is and how widely it's used.
Anyone know what measures big companies take to ensure they're not accidentally putting themselves on the hook for major IP infringement damages?
The agency asks a junior designer to turn the brief around in a day and says “there’s no budget, but we need to keep this client happy (if they’re the main agency) or we need to impress this client (if they’re a subcontracted agency or an agency not on the clients book).
And that’s where things went wrong. No money. No time. And a junior designer eager to impress.
Then unless there was a meticulous review process, I can see how someone might overlook a very default, straight on view of a generic product.
Quick mockup of how it could look like, but because the client saw this first and said "this is the one I want", they actually like the mockup better than the final version with similar but not quite the same graphics.
That insurance is likely to get a lot more expensive unless Netflix and the agency can come to an amicable resolution with the OP.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:VHS-Video-Tape-Top-Flat.j...
Ignorance does not excuse ones culpability. This will be extremely inexpensive for Netflix to remedy the PR hit will be a little more expensive but not long lasting. Netflix is really the only fish in the pond, so people may care but have nowhere else really to go.
Edit: nvm, didn’t see that the logo work was not his own...
He took a picture of a blank VHS tape that Netflix got from his website and used as the basis for their DVD cover.
I’m not saying it’s ok. But I’d be willing to wager that no one at Netflix had any ideas where those images came from. The design was most likely from a design agency, and even the top brass at the agency probably had no idea where those images came from. At the root of this there’s a designer who’s probably been asked to rush out a design, they’ve taken a shortcut and they’ve been rumbled.
Again, it’s not OK to steal images, but I seriously doubt Netflix knew that’s what they were doing.