News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What if consciousness is not what drives the human mind? by amelius on Sunday November 26, 2017 @02:16PM (#15782466)
Well, one reason to believe otherwise is the simple fact that we are talking about consciousness.

If consciousness were just a by-product (like steam in your example) then there would be no physical drive to talk about it.

Re:What if consciousness is not what drives the human mind? by whytaka on Monday November 27, 2017 @12:58AM (#15785195)
Right. That we talk about consciousness suggests that the physical drives have feedback of the perceived experience and are able to make determinations about it which is experienced again in perception as thoughts.

I firmly believe that most if not all interpretations of the 'world' is processed and complete before it even reaches perception. How I recognize objects, how I feel at the moment, and my literal thoughts themselves. But I cannot deny that the brain activity that processes stimulus into interpretations into perceived experience is also very aware of the perceived experience.

Perhaps it's as though our brain has a functional programming style in that various stimulus is operated upon somewhat independently by different regions of the brain, but the operation of synthesis takes the previous perceived experience (that is, the output of the previous synthesis op) as part of the input along with the various outputs of newly processed stimulus to create a new synthesized state that has reliable continuity.

Re:What if consciousness is not what drives the human mind? by automoton1 on Sunday November 26, 2017 @02:39PM (#15782564)
I don't see how talking about consciousness is necessarily a limitation to it being a by-product of physical processes.

It could be that consciousness is simply an emergent property (a by-product) of the communication of billions of neurons that are connected in trillions of ways. Where neurons are emergent of chemical phenomena which are emergent of atomic phenomena and so on.

I'm probably greatly simplifying the dependencies of phenomena, but I think that consciousness is most definitely based upon physical processes. The current evidence makes me believe that consciousness is a by-product of evolution, which is a by-product of the conditions on our planet.

So it goes.

Re:What if consciousness is not what drives the human mind? by Viliam1234 on Sunday November 26, 2017 @03:16PM (#15782754)
"Our thoughts have no real impact on the underlying operation of brain" cannot be literally true, if you are able to talk about your thoughts. Because talking about your thoughts means that somehow your thoughts influenced at least the part of your brain that guides your mouth.

Also, how would the ability to think evolve in our species, if our thoughts never had an impact on our behavior? Then they could not provide any evolutionary advantage.

It is possible (and quite likely) that some weaker version of that statement is true; e.g. that there are many things that brain does independently on our thoughts. But claiming that there is "no" impact is just trying to be edgy. Yes, such absolute statement sounds more interesting, but it is wrong.

Re:What if consciousness is not what drives the human mind? by incadenza on Sunday November 26, 2017 @02:58PM (#15782662)
I do agree, but to be fair, Epiphenomenalism makes a slightly stronger point. Not only is consciousness entirely a physical process, but the 'events' of consciousness (any thought, feeling, emotion, sensation you've ever experienced) has absolutely no impact on behavior. There is no feedback loop here. So, instead of

Touch hot flame -> Feel sensation of pain -> Move hand

It's...

Touch hot flame -> brain processes event and sends signals to move hand -> You experience all of this but it had no relevancy to the chain of events.

EDIT: This does beg the question 'why do we have consciousness, then?' or slightly related 'how could we talk about it?'. Which are interesting questions, and probably explained by darwinian processes, but don't really get at the heart of it. My thoughts anyhow.

Re:What if consciousness is not what drives the human mind? by ffwd on Sunday November 26, 2017 @03:44PM (#15782870)
> but the 'events' of consciousness (any thought, feeling, emotion, sensation you've ever experienced) has absolutely no impact on behavior. > or slightly related 'how could we talk about it?'

All of this is at least intuitively easy to explain with added language and complexity in the brain. So like the chain would become:

Touch hot flame -> brain processes event (and then does complicated language processing, and complicated memory and emotion processing) and THEN sends signals to move hand or not move hand -> You experience all of this but it had no relevancy to the chain of events.

Where I would ponder the relevancy of consciousness is when it comes to attention and remembering things. Just from personal experience, I can read a book, watch a movie or listen to music and I will not remember a thing if I wasn't aware of it. Is awareness and consciousness the same thing? I don't know, but at least we are conscious of everything we are aware of, by definition, and not necessarily vice versa.

Re:What if consciousness is not what drives the human mind? by ThomPete on Sunday November 26, 2017 @06:25PM (#15783683)
That assumes that consciousness is a thing we correctly pointing to. As far as we know it might as well be a completely ignorant idea.

Some questions can't be answered through language they can only be conceptualized through language and that's a very important distinction IMO.

Re:What if consciousness is not what drives the human mind? by psyc on Sunday November 26, 2017 @06:29PM (#15783699)
That's very arbitrary. We talk about everything we notice, external or introspective. There's no infinite regression, either. Consciousness notices itself. That's kind of one of its hallmarks.