News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by AnthonyMouse on Saturday November 25, 2017 @04:22PM (#15778065)
That's not even half of it. It's just a complete misunderstanding of the problem.

> Meanwhile, our experience of the internet is increasingly controlled by a handful of firms, most especially Google and Facebook. The argument for regulating these companies as public utilities is arguably at least as strong as the argument for thus regulating ISPs

The difference is that the markets are entirely different. It's possible to have a Facebook-like system with no Facebook-like entity in control of it, the canonical examples being email or the web. It's not a natural monopoly.

It isn't even a real monopoly at all. There is Twitter, Tumblr, the Google thing(s), the Microsoft thing(s), actual unaffiliated web pages, email, etc. Most people use Facebook and Twitter. Basically nobody uses Comcast and Charter.

There is a fair argument that we should adopt policies to bolster open systems like web/email over closed systems like Facebook so there is more vigorous competition. But the idea that we should enshrine Facebook as a permanent monopoly and then have the government regulate its content is the complete opposite of that. It's ludicrous.

And that isn't what network neutrality is anyway. Network neutrality doesn't regulate content. It says nothing about what anyone can print, it just says that everyone can buy ink on the same terms.

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by jdoliner on Saturday November 25, 2017 @04:34PM (#15778114)
> And that isn't what network neutrality is anyway. Network neutrality doesn't regulate content. It says nothing about what anyone can print, it just says that everyone can buy ink on the same terms.

What do you make of the case of Gab then? They're a competitor to Facebook, Twitter etc. They're not allowed on either app store and they've had their site taken down by multiple domain registrars. Are they being allowed to buy ink on the same terms? No, they're not, I guess we explain that away by saying: "well... they're hate speech." That's going to convince some people, some other people will take a look at that and say: "Wait, if they're hate speech maybe I'm hate speech too, maybe this whole net neutrality thing isn't actually meant for me." Which is why net neutrality has suddenly become a much more partisan issue.

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by AnthonyMouse on Saturday November 25, 2017 @04:42PM (#15778161)
> They're not allowed on either app store

The app stores are monopolies. The FTC absolutely should be slapping them for half the stuff they're doing.

But the app stores still aren't natural monopolies. They wouldn't be monopolies if people could install apps the same way they do on desktops. There is no need to regulate their content, what's needed is to restore normal competition to those markets.

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by ryukafalz on Saturday November 25, 2017 @06:15PM (#15778519)
>The app stores are monopolies.

Only on iOS. There are several alternative app stores for Android, and you can install apps the same way you do on desktops (after flipping a switch in settings).

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by coding123 on Saturday November 25, 2017 @06:27PM (#15778564)
Still a monopoly like that, see Internet explorer case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor....
Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by xbmcuser on Saturday November 25, 2017 @09:29PM (#15779148)
Would have been true if the largest manfactureres of Android phones didn't put their own browser and other apps. Samsung has its own browser and Chinese manufacturers use Chinese browsers. So chrome is rarely the default in more than half the android phones releases every year.
Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by jdoliner on Saturday November 25, 2017 @05:07PM (#15778263)
> The app stores are monopolies. The FTC absolutely should be slapping them for half the stuff they're doing.

> There is no need to regulate their content

Is there or isn't there a need to regulate them?

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by jacalata on Saturday November 25, 2017 @06:50PM (#15778638)
That is at best a misreading of the parent comment. Try quoting whole sentences and see if you can identify the parts of the argument that you chopped out.
Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by SAI_Peregrinus on Saturday November 25, 2017 @06:42PM (#15778610)
Network neutrality is about networks, not apps. It simply says that you can't block or prioritize traffic purely based on the identity of the endpoints. That's all. It does not regulate app stores. It does not prohibit QoS. It has nothing to do with Gab, that's several layers up the stack.
Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by jacalata on Saturday November 25, 2017 @06:48PM (#15778629)
It does have something to do with Gab- if net neutrality goes away then Comcast can block their site exactly the same way Apple can refuse to put their app in the App Store.
Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by jacalata on Saturday November 25, 2017 @06:46PM (#15778620)
Well, your hypothetical moron is apparently unable to understand net neutrality at all, even the very simple version that "net neutrality means that the ISP can't block one company. If net neutrality goes away. Then it doesn't matter if Gab gets their site registered - Comcast will be allowed to block it. What you are arguing for is extending net neutrality principles to App Store providers and domain registrars, instead of just ISPs". And yes, the existence of so many idiots on one side of politics is exactly why this is a partisan issue.
Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by guelo on Saturday November 25, 2017 @06:37PM (#15778597)
The network didn't ban Gab. Proprietary walled garden services banned them.
Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by rayiner on Saturday November 25, 2017 @05:45PM (#15778403)
> The difference is that the markets are entirely different. It's possible to have a Facebook-like system with no Facebook-like entity in control of it, the canonical examples being email or the web. It's not a natural monopoly.

Many different things give rise to natural monopolies. High fixed costs and strong economies of scale tend to give rise to market power among utilities, while for something like Facebook, network externalities give rise to market power. The two kinds of effects aren’t categorically different. They’re both just features of the market or products that enable firms to exercise market power. It ultimately boils down to a question of how much market power can a firm accrue before government intervention is justified.

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by AnthonyMouse on Sunday November 26, 2017 @11:08AM (#15781488)
> Many different things give rise to natural monopolies. High fixed costs and strong economies of scale tend to give rise to market power among utilities, while for something like Facebook, network externalities give rise to market power. The two kinds of effects aren’t categorically different.

They are different because network effects aren't inherently monopolized. Fax machines, email, rail gauge, all have network effects but no one has a monopoly on them. Even the internet itself in the sense that people on Comcast can communicate with people on Verizon.

But the last mile monopoly isn't due to network effects, it's due to high fixed costs.

The difference determines what kind of government intervention is justified. When you have a natural monopoly, the government can't make it go away, they can only regulate it as a utility. A non-natural monopoly can actually be eliminated and replaced with a competitive market that needs no further government intervention.

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by rayiner on Sunday November 26, 2017 @05:19PM (#15783384)
> They are different because network effects aren't inherently monopolized.

Natural monopolies arising from network effects aren't "inherently monopolized" any more than natural monopolies arising from high fixed costs. Two of the most powerful monopolies in the last few decades (Windows and x86) arose due to network effects.

> A non-natural monopoly can actually be eliminated and replaced with a competitive market that needs no further government intervention.

Both network effects and high fixed costs can cause an industry to tend towards natural monopoly. The government can split up Facebook, but network effects would cause one of the resulting companies to eventually dominate the others.

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by jMyles on Saturday November 25, 2017 @04:26PM (#15778081)
> It's possible to have a Facebook-like system with no Facebook-like entity in control of it

The same is true of the general topology of the internet. We don't need any of these layers (CAs, Room 641As, long bus-runs to carry messages seven times around the country before arriving at their destination).

There are distributed solutions to all of these problems (examples for the above, respectively, including NameCoin, CJDNS, and mesh networking), but legislated "net neutrality" enshrines the current model and blocks these decidedly non-"neutral" alternatives.

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by wvenable on Saturday November 25, 2017 @04:35PM (#15778123)
> legislated "net neutrality" enshrines the current mode

I don't see how that's the case. It doesn't prevent distributed solutions from existing it just makes them less necessary.

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by jMyles on Saturday November 25, 2017 @04:42PM (#15778157)
I don't think that's so. These technologies are decidedly non-net-neutral. A mesh network by its nature most have packet-gnosticism as a first principle.

I think it's very likely that if a "net neutrality" framework becomes US law, that municipalities and small organizations who launch their own mesh networks will be told that, in order to comply with the law, they need to deliver Fox News and Netflix at the same bandwidth and latency with which they deliver locally available curated content.

In other words, I suspect that "net neutrality," well-intentioned as it may be today, will be a way to silence alternative internet topologies tomorrow.

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by wvenable on Saturday November 25, 2017 @05:11PM (#15778277)
> I think it's very likely that if a "net neutrality" framework becomes US law, that municipalities and small organizations who launch their own mesh networks will be told that

That's not how net neutrality works; you're arguing against a straw man. If network operators are blind to the packets on their network -- they have no idea where they came from, where they are going (except to route them to next hop), or what they contain then you have a neutral network. Your argument is participated on the idea of neutrality requiring perfect knowledge but instead it's perfect ignorance.

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by tolodo on Saturday November 25, 2017 @07:13PM (#15778722)
I think it's a legitimate concern that this definition of net neutrality doesn't consider that different networks have different costs associated with them. If a service offers peering for free at the local internet exchange which adds little additional cost for the provider I have a hard time seeing why you should have to treat that traffic the same as the traffic the provider has to pay for.

That means that someone on a community network, that isn't using the Internet very much, can't take advantage of that free peering. Instead they would have to join the same "traffic pool" as heavy users.

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by wvenable on Saturday November 25, 2017 @11:51PM (#15779474)
I completely agree and that's totally fair. What isn't far though is charging more for (or slowing) traffic that could be 20 hops away (and thus not directly connected to your network) just because the packets happen to be labeled "Netflix".

As it is everyone pays for their own connectivity. Netflix pays to connect to their ISP. You pay to connect to your ISP. The ISPs pay to connect to each other. They have agreements on traffic levels and bandwidth. But an ISP shouldn't be able to double-dip and "tax" certain services for which they have no direct connection with. It effectively amounts to extortion.

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by dwringer on Saturday November 25, 2017 @06:03PM (#15778472)
> if a "net neutrality" framework becomes US law,

"net neutrality" is the term for the body of existing law, as it has been enforced for the past couple of years since classifying ISP's as "title II" common carriers. That classification was to clarify and enable enforcement of already-existing law, and had bipartisan support. The FCC is currently in the process of dismantling existing policy to abandon "net neutrality".

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by jMyles on Sunday November 26, 2017 @01:20AM (#15779684)
Well, I don't agree there either.

"Net neutrality" is a concept that long predates anyone dreaming of ISPs as title II.

My concern is that "net neutrality" as a topology concept - important as it has been to the growth of the internet so far - may be both subject to deprecation in favor of something more anarchic (ie, better) and at the same enshrined by law as the result of the current zealotry.

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by dwringer on Sunday November 26, 2017 @01:01PM (#15782112)
Perhaps I did not word my comment clearly - I was trying to emphasize that the existing body of law, going back for many years, is all considered to be "net neutrality". That is the way it has been discussed by journalists, lawmakers, and pundits for years (It is true that some agitators have tried to make the definition so broad as to include both sides of the argument, presumably to confuse voters). Courts had difficulty enforcing laws in some jurisdictions, and the title II classification two years ago enabled these arguments to be put to rest (thus making "net neutrality" a legally unambiguous interpretation of existing law). Current efforts by the FCC, under the current administration, are to remove that classification and make it once again impossible to enforce existing neutrality law as it has been understood by lawmakers and which "long predates anyone dreaming of ISP's as title II".
Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by Dylan16807 on Saturday November 25, 2017 @04:55PM (#15778214)
> they need to deliver Fox News and Netflix at the same bandwidth and latency with which they deliver locally available curated content.

Why would the speeds be different? If it's because longer links are more saturated/throttled, and nothing else, that's valid in the presence of net neutrality. Is there any other reason that should be protected?

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by candiodari on Sunday November 26, 2017 @12:30AM (#15779562)
Because ISPs, faced with a lack of direct network power, simply refuse to turn up physical interconnects, a power they decidedly still have.
Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by Dylan16807 on Sunday November 26, 2017 @12:46AM (#15779609)
I asked for something they should be able to do, that net neutrality regulations would stop. You answered with something they shouldn't be able to do, that net neutrality regulations wouldn't stop?
Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by jMyles on Sunday November 26, 2017 @01:22AM (#15779686)
See, it depends on what we mean by "neutral."

I think that a misguided or malicious regulator might certain be able to read that physical interconnects represent a "non-neutral" topological configuration, because they allow neighbors to share with each other at speeds faster than those outside their subnet.

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by AnthonyMouse on Saturday November 25, 2017 @04:51PM (#15778193)
That doesn't make any sense. To violate network neutrality you basically have to be either turning away peers or sticking them up for money. A mesh network wouldn't be doing either. If Fox News wants to plug a local node into the mesh network so their viewers have lower latency, you just let them. Why wouldn't you?
Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by jacalata on Saturday November 25, 2017 @06:51PM (#15778644)
> A mesh network by its nature most have packet-gnosticism as a first principle.

Why?

Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by jMyles on Sunday November 26, 2017 @01:23AM (#15779688)
Well, because the way that mesh networks (at least mesh-toplogy networks) function is to route packets to neighbors. Nodes don't blindly and neutrally route packets along; they select specific packets to route to specific neighbors.
Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by jacalata on Sunday November 26, 2017 @03:37AM (#15780028)
Any useful network uses routing. Comcast is not defying net neutrality by delivering all the packets addressed to your IP to you. Net neutrality is not breached until Comcast or your mesh network starts handling the packets differently based on who they came from and the business decisions about that source.
Re:The internet already lost its neutrality by jMyles on Sunday November 26, 2017 @10:22AM (#15781231)
Right, sure. But on a bus, routers blindly route all packets. They don't discriminate.

On a mesh (at least in OSLR or BATMAN), nodes only route certain packets. They are also free to drop packets for any reason, be they geographical or economic. Nobody can demand that a node perform routing.

I can absolutely imagine a malicious regulator claiming that the law requires every node on a small-town mesh to cart Fox News to the other side of town with just as much priority as packets originating from within the town. And that's not really sustainable for a mesh.