Re:The internet already lost its neutrality
by rayiner on Sunday November 26, 2017 @05:19PM
(#15783384)
> They are different because network effects aren't inherently monopolized.
Natural monopolies arising from network effects aren't "inherently monopolized" any more than natural monopolies arising from high fixed costs. Two of the most powerful monopolies in the last few decades (Windows and x86) arose due to network effects.
> A non-natural monopoly can actually be eliminated and replaced with a competitive market that needs no further government intervention.
Both network effects and high fixed costs can cause an industry to tend towards natural monopoly. The government can split up Facebook, but network effects would cause one of the resulting companies to eventually dominate the others.
They are different because network effects aren't inherently monopolized. Fax machines, email, rail gauge, all have network effects but no one has a monopoly on them. Even the internet itself in the sense that people on Comcast can communicate with people on Verizon.
But the last mile monopoly isn't due to network effects, it's due to high fixed costs.
The difference determines what kind of government intervention is justified. When you have a natural monopoly, the government can't make it go away, they can only regulate it as a utility. A non-natural monopoly can actually be eliminated and replaced with a competitive market that needs no further government intervention.