News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by r3bl on Saturday November 18, 2017 @10:54AM (#15729427)
I have to ask:

Is there any concrete evidence against Kaspersky doing anything remotely concerning since this whole charade against them started in 2015 or is it still "they're Russian, so they must be doing something bad" scenario?

EDIT: Fuck if I understand why people like JohnStrange, revelation and ryanlol are downvoted in their replies to this comment. They're on topic.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by roywiggins on Saturday November 18, 2017 @12:40PM (#15729894)
The simplest argument to make is that, regardless of whether the top people at Kaspersky are gleefully collaborating with the Russian government, they probably are required to give the Russian security service a backdoor to their networks as a condition of existing.

Given what we know about the feds installing black boxes in ISPs' networks here in the US- a country nominally committed to the rule of law- it seems somewhat naive to think that the Russian government doesn't have access to Kaspersky servers.

Does that make Kaspersky uniquely evil? Probably not. Do the feds have an agreement with Microsoft to take a peek at anything they turn up from a foreign intelligence service? I don't know. It wouldn't be too surprising.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by JohnStrange on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:38AM (#15729645)
I suspect there is a secret background story, like every so often when intelligence agencies are involved. Maybe Kaspersky didn't cooperate with the NSA as much as they'd wished for, or Russian intelligence interfered to prevent this. It looks to me like somebody is holding a very special grudge against this company.

I'm merely speculating, of course. Personally, I never take ordinary public announcements or claims from intelligence agencies at face value, since they have plenty of reasons to lie and disinform. That doesn't entail that their secret reports are bogus, of course, and senate hearings are also reliable. I've followed the senate hearings close enough to be reasonably certain that the US intelligence community is right about the accusations concerning Russian meddling in politics in the US and the EU. But that's a different case, people were testifying under oath in front of senate committees and senators from both parties who went to meetings behind closed doors were also convinced of the (classified) evidence.

As for Kaspersky, the information is unreliable and my personal guess is that whatever happened wasn't their fault. If someone has malware on his machine, it's the job of the antivirus software to detect and analyze it. If at all, the story has increased my overall trust in the technical quality of Kaspersky software.

Another speculation that I find overall credible is that since Snowden's revelations there is some concerted effort to further discredit the NSA in order to weaken their ability to operate. If that's so, then this campaign seems to be quite successful.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by odiroot on Saturday November 18, 2017 @12:01PM (#15729740)
Watching US situation from outside it's seems there's an urgent need for some kind of a bad guy.

Kaspersky is just easy target and apparently three-letter-agencies have means to steer the media to pursue this direction.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by whoopdedo on Saturday November 18, 2017 @01:40PM (#15730093)
Remember last year when Kaspersky accused[1] Microsoft of anti-trust for disabling their antivirus? And Microsoft admitted it was done in the name of compatibility.[2] Something about that seemed fishy to me because none of the other AV venders were complaining. Was Microsoft told to intentionally sabotage Kaspersky?

[1] https://www.computerworld.com/article/3141470/security/kaspe...

[2] https://www.theverge.com/2017/6/20/15836208/microsoft-kasper...

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by londons_explore on Sunday November 19, 2017 @11:00AM (#15734384)
That sounds like a legit software incompatibility to me.

Kaspersky was probably using some private API they shouldn't have been using, and when Microsoft changed the API or changed the way it worked, they had to disable Kaspersky or computers would no longer boot up.

When companies do that, they nearly always reach out to the affected vendors with advance warning so the vendor can do a rushed fix, but repeat offenders, or issues detected very late in the game before release can end up with no notice.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by gspetr on Monday November 20, 2017 @07:24AM (#15739413)
> Watching US situation from outside it's seems there's an urgent need for some kind of a bad guy.

How else would you justify all that Defense budget spending?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bomber_gap

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missile_gap

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by revelation on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:14AM (#15729532)
The best part of all of this is how there is all this media coverage on a fricking antivirus, but nobody seems all too concerned with the NSA losing more secrets.

It's like incident #100, maybe Kaspersky is the KGB, good on them since they are clearly more competent than the NSA. Maybe we can poach them?

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by philipov on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:24AM (#15729580)
Stands to reason that the media coverage is a smoke screen to eat up attention on the issue. Easier to give people a boogeyman so they don't have as much energy to spend on noticing the really important problems.

And our media outlets will happily run with anything that produces those sweet clicks.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by revelation on Saturday November 18, 2017 @12:38PM (#15729882)
Our media outlets will happily run anything the government tells them. Here is the line from that infamous NYT article:

"The current and former government officials who described the episode spoke about it on condition of anonymity because of classification rules."

And now you know why Snowden wouldn't touch the NYT with 10 foot pole. This isn't "current and former government officials" committing a felony and treason to leak information to the NYT, no, they are just telling that reporter the NSA press report with a hushed voice.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by matt4077 on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:06AM (#15729498)
It's a security company run mostly by ex-KGB and dependent on the good will of an administration willing to very publicly murder their opponents[0], and not bound by anything resembling rule of law.

So yes, it is possible, maybe even likely, that Kasperky is doing nothing shady and has only the best intentions. It's also somewhat irresponsible to entrust them with any data of value. Those two things are not mutually exclusive.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by 55555 on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:51AM (#15729689)
Perhaps I'm confused, but did you mean to add a footnote/citation ([0])?
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by matt4077 on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:52AM (#15729696)
Yeah. Just google for Polonium. They murdered someone, and made sure the victim, and the whole world, knew exactly who was behind it.
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by FeepingCreature on Saturday November 18, 2017 @01:47PM (#15730115)
Usually if you leave a footnote[0], you have to actually include the note in the footer of your comment.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Note_(typography) Like so.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by nasredin on Saturday November 18, 2017 @03:12PM (#15730425)
Probably misspelled, from memory:

Litvienko (Polonium)

Politovskaya (Journalist)

Nemtsov (Politician)

And no, you do not need to leave a note (IMHO) since the fact that Russian government murders its critics is common knowledge.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by syockit on Saturday November 18, 2017 @07:55PM (#15731629)
[0] is just a short form for [citation needed]
[dead]
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by sctb on Saturday November 18, 2017 @07:38PM (#15731558)
We've asked you many times to follow the guidelines. Please re-read them and start posting civilly and substantively or we'll ban the account.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by ctrl-j on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:03AM (#15729485)
> Just as is Russian “collusion” with trump. Absolutely zero evidence at all only unnamed sources and speculation.

Just out of curiosity, what makes you think there is zero evidence?

How would we know what evidence Mueller's team has uncovered?

How do you reconcile all of the interactions between the trump campaign and the various Russian entities involved?

[dead]
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by orf on Saturday November 18, 2017 @12:35PM (#15729875)
> away with Benghazi

Wasn't Benghazi investigated to death by the right for an absurdly long time? Why do you think nothing was found?

I'm not sure if your willfully trolling or actually believe the misinformation you are spreading, and I'm not sure which is worse.

[dead]
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by orf on Saturday November 18, 2017 @01:35PM (#15730076)
> Didn't all the people except Hillary (who lied to the committee) take the 5th?

No.

It's pretty simple:

> Benghazi investigated for years

> Longest congressional investigation in history

> Multiple reports find nothing

> Hillary is guilty she escaped justice!! Investigate Benghazi!!

And at the same time:

> Russian collusion investigated for 10 months

> No published reports, investigation not concluded

> several inditements already

> This is a witch hunt of the highest degree to keep you distracted from uranium, emails and Benghazi!!!!

Wake up.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by weaksauce on Saturday November 18, 2017 @04:14PM (#15730734)
> several inditements already

Several felony indictments at that with some very serious charges filed.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by gozur88 on Saturday November 18, 2017 @10:08PM (#15732043)
When someone says something like "Wake up" it's a pretty reliable indicator they're off in conspiracy theory land. The reason they didn't find anything is Hillary deleted thousands of relevant emails from a server she shouldn't have had and the only person who could call her out on the lying took the 5th.

Wake up indeed. Do you really believe what you write?

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by orf on Saturday November 18, 2017 @10:29PM (#15732101)
> When someone says something like "Wake up" it's a pretty reliable indicator they're off in conspiracy theory land.

I'm saying wake up to the real world. By the way, a statement like that has a lot more impact if you don't immediately follow it with a conspiracy theory.

> The reason they didn't find anything is....

So what you're saying is Mueller has found more solid evidence of improprieties between Russia and the Trump campaign in 10 months than 5 years of politically motivated witch hunting. I'm glad we agree on that, and I'm sure you're far more worried about the sitting President of the USA's Russia links than something so thoroughly investigated as Benghazi or debunked as 'that uranium thing', that even if they where real would be somewhat overshadowed.

Did you believe the Trump campaigns 'lock her up' slogan? Can you fathom why he didn't follow through on his campaign promise to launch a full investigation into her? Could it possibly, just possibly, be because there is nothing and he only banged that drum just to excite people like you?

Indeed, wake up.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by gozur88 on Saturday November 18, 2017 @10:40PM (#15732128)
>I'm saying wake up to the real world. By the way, a statement like that has a lot more impact if you don't immediately follow it with a conspiracy theory.

That's all on the record.

>So what you're saying is Mueller has found more solid evidence of improprieties between Russia and the Trump campaign in 10 months than 5 years of politically motivated witch hunting.

Has he? Exactly what has Mueller found?

By the way, let me suggest to you that if the justice department ever asks you for emails relating to an investigation you'll almost certainly end up going to jail if you delete a bunch of them and then claim you were just deleting private email.

I keep wondering if, as in the case of Bill Clinton, 25 years after it matters Democrats will be willing to admit that yes, Hillary broke the law.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by orf on Saturday November 18, 2017 @10:48PM (#15732147)
> That's all on the record.

Ehh, that's a half truth at best as even a cursory bit of research would tell you.

> Has he? Exactly what has Mueller found?

Enough to get two felony incitements and dozens of sealed ones? I mean, I'd expect you to know this as you care about these investigations based not on party but on their individual merit. So, you must be following this one really closely because that is already far more than the entire Benghazi investigation found and it's just getting started.

> By the way, let me suggest to you that if the justice department ever asks you for emails relating to an investigation you'll almost certainly end up going to jail if you delete a bunch of them and then claim you were just deleting private email.

http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2016/oct/...

All in all, cool, but I care a lot more about the current sitting president of the USA's links to Russia than I do about some deleted emails. And if you don't, then I suggest waking up.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by gozur88 on Sunday November 19, 2017 @01:19PM (#15735077)
>Enough to get two felony incitements and dozens of sealed ones? I mean, I'd expect you to know this as you care about these investigations based not on party but on their individual merit.

So what's in the sealed indictments?

Don't include links to polifact if you want people to take you seriously. Seriously.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by orf on Sunday November 19, 2017 @01:30PM (#15735126)
Don't know, but even a inditement for jaywalking is more substantial than anything the Benghazi investigation found.

Judging by the two unsealed ones though, it's likely more serious than that.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by maskedinvader on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:50AM (#15729687)
There is no justice only the decision of those in power.

-do you really want that power to be in the tiny hands of an orange clown ? #justcurious

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by thatguy0900 on Saturday November 18, 2017 @12:02PM (#15729744)
As much as you may dislike him, please don't use this kind of discourse on HN.
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by maskedinvader on Sunday November 19, 2017 @02:21AM (#15732723)
just to clarify ? the question itself has merit ? no ? the description of the commander in chief however may not have shown respect, for which I accept your comment and take the downvotes on the chin.
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by orf on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:01AM (#15729475)
> Just as is Russian “collusion” with trump. Absolutely zero evidence

Well... not quite.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by ryanlol on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:03AM (#15729484)
Can you link to any evidence suggesting foul play on Kasperskys part?

edit: This question was far more reasonable before the parent comment was edited.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by ctrl-j on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:07AM (#15729506)
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by ryanlol on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:10AM (#15729517)
You could write a very similar article about any AV company.

I've personally been automatically scanning data shared by various¹ AV companies for sensitive documents. I only store files not detected as malware by any scanners, and filter out large usually boring files (i.e. videos, audio). I also make an effort to filter out publicly available documents by googling them. So far I've gathered over 20TB of data.

So far I've found:

  Entire customer database of a Swedish bank
  Thousands of git repositories
  Hundreds of passport scans
  Tens of gigabytes of sensitive medical documents
  Tens of gigabytes of internal government documents
  Payroll data for hundreds of thousands of people
  Entire email inboxes, both government and corporate.
  Hundreds of website dbs in various formats
This is just off the top of my head, I could keep going for a while. I've got a searchable archive of tens of millions of clean pdfs, word docs, excel spreadsheets, powerpoints and so on. All pulled from users computers by their AV software.

¹ Not including Kaspersky, but including many US firms.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by orf on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:29AM (#15729608)
How do you have access to this data? That sounds quite troubling
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by ryanlol on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:30AM (#15729611)
It's readily shared among researchers and "researchers". I'm scraping multiple feeds, but virustotal for example is one of the easiest public ones to access.
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by orf on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:06AM (#15729500)
I was responding to the comment regarding collision between the Trump campaign and Russia
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by forapurpose on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:06AM (#15729496)
[deleted]
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by ryanlol on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:07AM (#15729509)
Really only describes standard AV co practices.
[dead]
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by jonknee on Saturday November 18, 2017 @01:29PM (#15730046)
What's your source for this? I remember they got a lot of flack for introducing race changing filters (AKA digital blackface). Thinking that was a good idea is pretty sickening.
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by cisanti on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:58AM (#15729723)
Why are you downvoting me, people? What is that I said was wrong?!
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by krapp on Saturday November 18, 2017 @12:06PM (#15729759)
I didn't downvote you, but you're responding in agreement to an obvious troll and spreading propaganda about a vast left-wing "witch hunt" which only serves to dilute and further degrade what little intellectual value this thread might have possessed.
Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by daxorid on Saturday November 18, 2017 @04:18PM (#15730760)
> Fuck if I understand why people like JohnStrange, revelation and ryanlol are downvoted

The Hacker News community largely gets its non-hacker news from CNN, the NYT, HuffPo, etc. As mainstream US media parrots whatever the FVEY IC tells them to, it's not surprising that most HN voters end up uncritically believing the Russia-Is-Evil narrative from the same IC that conducted MKULTRA and sold us a war predicated on the lie that Saddam was loaded up with WMDs.

Downvoting any and all dissent from CIA psyops is the natural consequence of this. Because, patriotism, or something.

Re:Kaspersky: Yes, we obtained NSA secrets. No, we didn’t he... by willstrafach on Saturday November 18, 2017 @04:25PM (#15730786)
You really don't believe there is a possibility that some others have assessed all available facts and simply disagree with the conclusion that you've evidently come to?