Not sure I'd want to be unable to mask the camera and mic being active either.
for your use case, you might consider tape that's the same color as the material surrounding the light. though, that'd be a huge inconvenience to apply in the heat of the moment, and it'd somewhat defeat the purpose of an easy indicator if you had to peel it back every time you wanted to check the light. though... you might also worry about recording when it's in your pocket, in which case you'd still have to pull it out to look at it.
i know that police will often try to interfere with recording despite the legal precedents, but it seems pretty well accepted at this point that recording police activity is completely lawful as long as you're not interfering with said activity. again, i know police have blatantly disregarded that in practice, but it's something.
oh, another low tech option for surreptitious recording: finger over the light. still gotta remember to do it, but again, it's something.
Are we sure mass recording isn't already happening? It wasn't that long ago that the idea of bulk metadata collection was thought of as tinfoil hat material by many.
There are quite a few ways to do it.
IMO, the fight should focus on things like secretly turning on the microphone on your internet connected device (cellphone etc) and listing in. That's the kind of situation where we could get useful long term precedent and most people would agree with the intent.
Because, if we are not careful that can quietly change and AI will make listing to every conversation anyone has in the county a real possibility.