News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert?

I know that I'm almost an expert in something when, given a task, I only see the annoying small details.

So, I'm curious about how you know you became or are an expert in something.

( 35 comments | 20 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by oscardelben on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @02:19AM (#1570314)
Four stages of competence[1]:

* Unconscious Incompetence: The individual neither understands nor knows how to do something, nor recognizes the deficit, nor has a desire to address it.

* Conscious Incompetence: Though the individual does not understand or know how to do something, he or she does recognize the deficit, without yet addressing it.

* Conscious Competence: The individual understands or knows how to do something. However, demonstrating the skill or knowledge requires a great deal of consciousness or concentration.

* Unconscious Competence: The individual has had so much practice with a skill that it becomes "second nature" and can be performed easily (often without concentrating too deeply). He or she may or may not be able teach it to others, depending upon how and when it was learned.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_stages_of_competence

Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by buro9 on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @05:37AM (#1570636)
The weird thing about unconscious competence, is that when things do become so intuitive and second nature I've personally started to find that I feel as if I don't know something.

If asked... I feel I can't answer. If interviewed I'll probably fail. Yet I also find that when put in front of a problem the solution just presents itself.

What's weird about this is that in feeling I know so little about things that I've 15 years experience in, I feel like I need to learn. So I expose myself to all opportunities to learn only to find that all tell me what I feel is evident and obvious.

This is close to what I take to be the meaning of "forgotten more than I've ever learned".

Whether this makes me an expert is debatable, I'd say no. I'd say that there was a re-learning stage after the last stage in which you acquire the means to understand deeply and to be able to communicate and pass on those skills. I'd say that an expert is someone who can pass on their skills, someone who can mentor others.

(I also find it uncomfortable writing a post implying I know anything)

Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by berntb on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @06:31AM (#1570712)
I have an inverted experience...

I have gone back to unconscious incompetence in some subjects I haven't touched for a decade, that I used to know better than most anyone I worked with.

It is embarrassing sometimes. :-)

I am still happy that I reinvented myself as a script programmer instead of a system programmer; what is fun for me is sitting down and generating lots of functionality in a short time. I can go to work with a smile and low risk of burnout.

On the subject of expert or not: I guess that locally I am considered an expert on what I do, but I don't see me as one because I know how the real experts are.

Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by callmeed on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:36AM (#1570438)
But does Unconscious Competence == Expert ?
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by ErrantX on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @05:49AM (#1570654)
Not always; I can do my job in my sleep but I'm barely expert in it... I think expertise is the next level beyond that - where you are pushing ideas of your own into what you do.
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by hellweaver666 on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:56AM (#1574357)
I think you become an expert when you go from "unconscious competence" to "passionate competence" i.e. you care so much about it that you live it, dream it and think of it every second.

Examples are:

  * Rand Fishkin and his love of SEO

  * Jonny Ive and his passion for design

  * Tony Hsieh and his love of fostering an awesome place to work.
All of these people live and love their chosen area of expertise.
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by MaysonL on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @01:30AM (#1573736)
One job I had back in the 70s, I occasionally would get thanked by the operations people for fixing a problem the night before, of which I had no recollection whatever. Actually doing your job in your sleep is a little bit scary.
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by GVRV on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:21AM (#1570421)
I'm not an expert at anything but I do follow my University's motto 'Ancora Imparo' (I'm learning). I personally think it's difficult for you to know when you're an expert at anything but other people will start labeling you as an expert. They'll ask for your opinions, help, etc and wouldn't mind paying for it. Just do whatever interests you. Share what you've learned. But always know you're just a student of the field, let other worry about how they perceive you.

How did PG become an expert at starting up? He did it himself. He wrote essays about it to share what he learnt. I'm sure he was never trying to be an expert. Even in his essays now, he never makes "expert claims". It's the people who found the advice helpful that labelled him so.

Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by ThomPete on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:25AM (#1570423)
You know you are an expert when you start saying "it depends" to questions you are asked.
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by sesqu on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @06:57AM (#1570745)
I must have been born an expert, then. It's taken a lot of learning for me to answer with "try this", rather than "tell me more about your problem and the parameters of an acceptable solution".

Incidentally, I'm currently doing some research on a problem and it pains me that I have to constantly come up with the justifications to the solutions I find proposed. There's a lot of cookbook math around.

Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by asmithmd1 on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @06:50AM (#1570735)
To spot the expert in a group of people pick the one who says it will cost the most and take the longest.
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by alanh on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @02:26AM (#1570326)
I think being able to disagree with a point most other experts in the field agree upon, with reason, while being able to explain the more common POV, is sufficient but not necessary evidence of expertise.
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by yason on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @04:37AM (#1570527)
I suppose you don't.

By the time you know a shitload in details and depth of some subject, you also know another shitload of related things that you know you do not know yet, so you still keep considering yourself a half-newbie. And because you're interested in things you don't know, you rarely talk about the subject with people who know less than you, which distorts your field of vision.

Indirectly, perhaps you could consider it a sign of an "expert" to have been so alienated from what is generally considered normal that people label you as a geek.

But then again, you can never declare yourself an expert or you're just selling to be something you aren't.

Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by known on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:30AM (#1570428)
"I hear and I forget. I see and I remember. I do and I understand." -- Confucius
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by olalonde on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @06:22AM (#1570698)
I would say it could be when you have to search really hard to find an article/book/course/conference/etc. in your area of expertise that actually teaches you something. It is when the only way to perfect your skills is by yourself, by pushing the limits on your own without relying on others. It is when the only way to get better is not to buy the book but to write it. Anyone agrees?
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by ajdecon on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @02:12PM (#1572088)
"Expert" is a tricky word, and I only know how to measure this in relative terms. For a given area, I know I have a high degree of expertise when colleagues who are working in similar areas begin to regularly ask for my help. That doesn't necessarily say anything about my abilities relative to a different population: I know a hell of a lot about image analysis relative to the other engineers in my group, but I know there are plenty of people who can kick my ass in this.

I suppose I might also measure this based on my own need for assistance, i.e. I am an "expert" when I only rarely need to turn to colleagues or the literature for help. But this isn't a very functional definition for me, as I strongly prefer to be working at the edge of my knowledge; thus I am almost always in conversation with others who know more than me.

Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by econner on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @04:20AM (#1570489)
This seems relevant: http://norvig.com/21-days.html "Teach Yourself Programming in Ten Years"

"Researchers (Bloom (1985), Bryan & Harter (1899), Hayes (1989), Simmon & Chase (1973)) have shown it takes about ten years to develop expertise in any of a wide variety of areas, including chess playing, music composition, telegraph operation, painting, piano playing, swimming, tennis, and research in neuropsychology and topology. The key is deliberative practice: not just doing it again and again, but challenging yourself with a task that is just beyond your current ability, trying it, analyzing your performance while and after doing it, and correcting any mistakes. Then repeat. And repeat again."

Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by Locke1689 on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @06:46AM (#1570731)
According to my experience: never. I'm always surprised when I know something other people don't, but I always seem to know ~10x more every passing year than I did before. Going through theoretical CS papers always reminds me how much I have to learn.
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by hkarthik on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @02:23PM (#1572128)
Most experienced technologists know the real danger in ever claiming to be an expert in anything.

Rarely will two jobs be so similar that the expertise gained from a previous job can guarantee the same level of output in the new job. While its not impossible, its so rare that its not worth the risk in making the claim that you are an expert.

In general, those that ever claim to be experts are using the word to justify a high payrate or lock in an opportunity.

So as business owner, be wary of anyone claiming to be an expert. And as a technologist, be wary of ever claiming to be an expert and risk overselling yourself.

Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by instakill on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @02:02AM (#1573778)
You will never really be able to tell that you're an expert, if you are an expert. One of the reasons for this is because of the Dunning-Kruger effect in cognitive psychology whereby "the highly skilled underrate their abilities, suffering from illusory inferiority". (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect)
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by betterlabs on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:32AM (#1570431)
Ah, I think it would be a mistake for anyone to assume they are an expert unless they are in a field that has nothing left to be discovered (rare!). If you are in tech, then I think "Ancora Imparo" (I'm learning) - as referenced in an earlier comment - is the way to go. If you have anything to do with startups, then I think you should be ready for your knowledge and expertise to be disrupted everyday.
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by elliottkember on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @04:27AM (#1570507)
I think it's relative. Anybody who claims to be an expert is selling you something.

It's not a black and white thing; there are varying levels of expertise. The more people there are that think you're an expert, the more of an expert you are.

Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by sesqu on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @06:44AM (#1570729)
I don't think I've ever been an expert in anything where being an expert is somehow worthwhile.

That said, I'd say you're an expert when you know what the bad parts are, why they're wrong, and why they're there anyway.

Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by invertedlambda on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:49AM (#1570457)
You'll know you're an expert when you don't care about being labeled as such. You know your stuff really well, so well that it's a matter of intuition. If you care about being an expert, you're not one.
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @07:53AM (#1570819)
>You know your stuff really well, so well that it's a matter of intuition.

So experts are people that don't think about what they're doing?

Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by invertedlambda on Saturday August 14, 2010 @07:28PM (#1604246)
Correct, but maybe not in the sense that you are implying.
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by yannis on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:27AM (#1570426)
When people in your field cannot answer your questions, but you can.
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by CyberFonic on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:08AM (#1570399)
An expert is someone who is sought out by others for their skill and paid well for it.
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by arethuza on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @04:54AM (#1570559)
No - that's someone who markets themselves to be an expert. Of course, they might be an expert but I haven't noticed much correlation between claiming expertise (or being paid huge amounts of money) and actual expertise.
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by MaximeRS on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:36AM (#1570439)
I don't think that's sufficient.

Or 'sought out' and 'paid well' has a more restrictive meaning for you than for the thousands of big businesses that spend tons of money on IT Consultants.

Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by psyklic on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @05:12AM (#1570591)
When respected people in the field value your opinion and perceive you as their peer.
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by krainboltgreene on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @05:42AM (#1570642)
Can this really be true and how much respect is required? Consider Zed Shaw, who is quite clearly a very competent hacker.

A lot of people refuse to respect or give value to his opinion, much less see him as a peer.

Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @07:55AM (#1570826)
I was going to say "when someone you consider to be an expert in the field comes to you for a solution [in that same field]".
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by harscoat on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @05:06AM (#1570574)
when you know you'll never pretend becoming one
Re:Ask HN: How do you know when you are an expert? by kasharoo on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @02:18AM (#1570312)
When my karma got to 10, I knew I was an HN expert.