Re:California Could Legalize Magic Mushrooms in 2018
by scruple on Tuesday November 14, 2017 @06:40PM
(#15700322)
> because their bad effects are few and minor.
I have issues with this. I've personally had very bad mushroom trips that have had effects that lingered for a year or longer. I'm not saying keep them illegal, but I don't for one second believe it's a black and white issue, either.
Re:California Could Legalize Magic Mushrooms in 2018
by uoaei on Thursday November 16, 2017 @05:31AM
(#15711577)
Not necessarily black and white, sure, but there is a threshold defined as the net personal/social benefit of the thing. If this is net positive, there's not enough reason to ban it. If there is net negative, there are reasons to ban it.
Further, the ban/not ban dichotomy is also fuzzier in practice. We can restrict access according to attributes of people, or restrict consumption to private settings, or otherwise. These decisions must be informed by the net benefit.
Re:California Could Legalize Magic Mushrooms in 2018
by SOLAR_FIELDS on Tuesday November 14, 2017 @07:11PM
(#15700474)
Disagree. Mushrooms that have had mold grow on them are pretty much guaranteed to make you sick and guarantee a bad experience. So it is possible to have objectively bad mushrooms in nearly the same way as you can have objectively bad wine.
Mushrooms and leaded wine both have effects that their users long considered good. The difference between them, for purposes of this argument, is that for leaded wine we've since discovered very bad effects that completely outweigh the good effects, whereas for mushrooms we haven't.