Mushrooms and leaded wine both have effects that their users long considered good. The difference between them, for purposes of this argument, is that for leaded wine we've since discovered very bad effects that completely outweigh the good effects, whereas for mushrooms we haven't.
I have issues with this. I've personally had very bad mushroom trips that have had effects that lingered for a year or longer. I'm not saying keep them illegal, but I don't for one second believe it's a black and white issue, either.
Further, the ban/not ban dichotomy is also fuzzier in practice. We can restrict access according to attributes of people, or restrict consumption to private settings, or otherwise. These decisions must be informed by the net benefit.
There will always be irresponsible people, however we shouldn't intrude on the freedoms of everyone for the faults of a few.
The fallacies in your conclusion are:
> freedoms of everyone
> faults of a few
Whether intoxication leads to freedom is debatable.
Secondly, casualties from alcohol abuse are hardly "a few".
You say people susceptible to the detrimental effects, perhaps from a preexisting tendency for lack of inhibition and aptitude are responsible. Whereas they are literally irresponsible. Further, your comment in response to my question could be understood to uphold the right to a buzz over thousands of deaths a year.
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2173580814...
Do you have any other examples on the thousands of years timescale?
Well, the Wikipedia page says that lead was being used as a sweetener as late as the 1850s, and this page suggests that we have records of the practice going back to at least 160BCE, so "thousands of years" doesn't seem inaccurate?
http://penelope.uchicago.edu/~grout/encyclopaedia_romana/win...
> Do you have any other examples on the thousands of years timescale?
Off the top of my head, tobacco? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tobacco#Traditional_use
Opium? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opium#Ancient_use_.28pre-500_C...
Bloodletting? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloodletting#In_the_ancient_wo...
I dunno, I'm not an anthropologist, but I'm not trying too hard...
The risk of using the wrong item is separate from the risks inherent in the genuine item; in that context, it makes sense to use "safe" for the genuine item as a rhetoric device.
Of course, none of these mushrooms are safe; there are unsafe doses of their ingredient.
Nothing is safe without reference to dose; not water, not salt, ...
I don't have a position on legalizing psychoactive mushrooms, but I don't think this is a good argument.
For example, humans also used lead to sweeten wine for centuries, but that's not evidence that lead is harmless.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead(II)_acetate#Sweetener
I'm sure we could come up with many more such examples.