News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by Jach on Friday November 10, 2017 @05:45PM (#15673712)
Relevant video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UUOo8N9_iH0

Of course if we really get to a point where robot uprising / apocalypse is a credible imminent threat, I'm sure most of the threatening robots will have solved this particular obstacle by then...

Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by gooseus on Friday November 10, 2017 @06:19PM (#15673923)
I have very little fear of robots in the near future because my opinion is that the best we'll be able to do is an imperfect copy of us and we're already so laughably imperfect.

Even if someone programs robots specifically to take over the world autonomously, they would need to either encode all the assumptions or else train them perfectly for all situations.

Also they'd have to be able to adapt to all the environments humans can... you make robots adapted to urban warefar environments, great we go to the mountains and develop something to target that design and counterattack.

Obviously if AGI comes about, we could be in trouble, but I don't believe that's around the corner and have doubts about it's feasibility on any timeline.

I would go on, but now I'm cut short by life... would love to hear counterpoints.

Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by tzs on Friday November 10, 2017 @06:39PM (#15674024)
> Even if someone programs robots specifically to take over the world autonomously, they would need to either encode all the assumptions or else train them perfectly for all situations.

Encoding just one assumption will cover a large fraction of situations: anyone that the robot cannot positively identify as being (1) the Evil Overlord, or (2) an employee in good standing of the Evil Overlord, or (3) someone the Evil Overlord has granted an exception for, or (4) someone in a place that the Evil Overlord has granted an exception for may be terminated.

We've got almost 8 billion people in the world now. Most things an Evil Overlord would want to do once in charge, especially an Evil Overlord with good robot technology, don't need anywhere near that many people, so losing 6 or 7 billion in exchange for keeping the robots simple and reliable during the takeover would probably be acceptable to the Overlord.

If the Overlord does have plans that require more people, that can be taken care of after the takeover. Presumably an Evil Overlord would not have any qualms about a forced breeding program to shore up the population.

A lot of problems that we consider to be hard become a lot easier when you are an Evil Overlord.

Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by gooseus on Friday November 10, 2017 @11:33PM (#15675006)
Ok, but how do the robots do the terminating? How do they actually seek and destroy? Do they understand all the different ways humans know how to cloak themselves?

Do they kill everything living, or will they know how to distinguish humans from other living beings reliably?

If even one Evil Overlord robot is captured and studied, how much can be gleaned which will allow them to be exploited? If the Evil Overlord deploys these robots and leaves even one exploit open then the entire swarm is compromised and Evil Overlord is overthrown.

I can see it working if this is a sneak attack and they take a large percentage in a short amount of time, but that would require a lot of build up of technology by this Evil Overlord without being exposed... not impossible, but still implausible in my book.

Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by heroprotagonist on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:49PM (#15674554)
Well, they don't really need to adapt to all situations perfectly. They just need to do well enough. It's not necessary to replace humans in order to get rid of them.

Weaponized flying drones are sufficient for a large number of environments. Even if they limit themselves to wide open spaces on sunny days, with crude sensors that just detect vaguely human shapes that move, they would have a significant impact. A perfect annihilation isn't necessary to crumble society.

The tech is already sufficiently advanced, albeit in several disparate pieces. The will to deploy it and capacity to build it at massive scale is really all that is lacking.

Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by gooseus on Saturday November 11, 2017 @12:10AM (#15675087)
I think this assumes far too much passiveness in the human population and treats the problem of eliminating humans like any other passive engineering problem.

"Good enough" works for UI and database performance, or problems that aren't actively adapting to prevent the solution from being applied.

Nobody in security would apply "good enough" to well-known and high value attack vectors, you need to be constantly adapting and understanding your enemies next move. And in cybersecurity, you really have a limited surface area for attack.

Drones and robots need to apply their solution (getting rid of us) in the real physical world, not the digital one and each one of us is a supercomputer which can adapt to working with other supercomputers very quickly in the face of adversity.

I think they might make a good first push and catch us off guard, but some humans on defense will understand the systems that control the drones and how they collect/process the information. They do not have the same advantage with us.

Designing new camouflage to avoid detection, creating decoys which waste their ammunition/resources or spread their forces too thinly, and various other classic strategies that come naturally to any group of humans with a single strategist amongst them will be well outside of a simple "good enough" drone's ability to adapt and combat.

Anything but a perfect annihilation will only give us time to find exploits and counterattack. The only thing that should be a threat is an AI that has a similar capability to understand the physical universe and adapt faster than us. You might make a robot that understand a whole bunch of stuff about physics and biology and math... but if they don't understand chemistry and the many ways we can deploy it as a weapon against them (think acids and other corrosives), then they're going to be at a complete loss as to how to neutralize that threat.

Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by dogma1138 on Saturday November 11, 2017 @09:04PM (#15679304)
We also have surface to air missiles....

Say some one builds a fleet of 50,000 autonomous drones that fleet goes Skynet and kills a bunch of people but some one would have to maintain, rearm and refuel that fleet.

Even if for some reason the fleet would come with some autonomous logistical capacity it will eventually run out of fuel or munitions.

For a robot uprising to work they would have to have the same agency as the human civilization that built them and that is highly unlikely to ever happen.

Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by nicolashahn on Friday November 10, 2017 @06:26PM (#15673971)
Even if all we can do is create a copy of a human brain, it seems like it wouldn't be an incredibly difficult step (given the traits of current computers) to give that brain 1000x faster thinking compared to us, a perfect memory, and an indefinite lifespan? It seems like a person with those characteristics, if they decided to act immorally, could accomplish quite a bit.
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by brett40324 on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:05PM (#15674402)
1000 times faster is not the incredibly hard part. Its the immense amount of massively parallel signal processing that the neocortex achieves every second.
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by edgarvaldes on Friday November 10, 2017 @06:41PM (#15674031)
>indefinite lifespan

What materials are we talking about?

Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by nicolashahn on Friday November 10, 2017 @06:47PM (#15674072)
Whatever current electronics are made out of? Silicon? It doesn't really matter when you can easily backup data and replace parts. Haven't really figured that one out with human brains yet.
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by gooseus on Saturday November 11, 2017 @12:20AM (#15675114)
Here is a good article describing some of the limitations of sand we may face - https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/05/29/the-world-is-r...

Humans brains replace themselves and the resources it takes to grow a new human (complete with a new brain) are much lower and easier to acquire than any artificial brain we may come up with. It takes awhile to get little humans up to speed, but they'll adapt to any environment you throw at them and in a time of strife will be able to make themselves useful way sooner than they do today.

Any time you start saying words like "indefinitely" you're falling into a trap. We may have "infinite" silicon available on the earth, but it's not equally accessible and it can't all be extracted and refined in the same way.

Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by Johnny555 on Friday November 10, 2017 @05:06PM (#15673456)
That's good advice until opening doors becomes a priority and robots learn (or are taught) how to open them. Or they are armed with 50 caliber guns that aren't stopped by doors.
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by bsder on Friday November 10, 2017 @05:23PM (#15673573)
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by jnwatson on Friday November 10, 2017 @06:05PM (#15673842)
If you want a lesson in humility, try to make a contraption to open a door that has a regular round doorknob. In particular, opening a door that swings toward the opener is a complicated dance of leverage and balance, not to mention the fiddly bits to actually rotate the knob.

Interestingly, US ADA (disability act) requires commercial buildings to use handle-style doorknobs. The robot uprising would have a lot easier time getting through those.

Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by cperciva on Friday November 10, 2017 @06:18PM (#15673917)
Residential buildings in Vancouver require "lever" doorknobs too. When the building code was amended to require that, there were lots of jokes about velociraptors opening doors.
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by michaelhoney on Friday November 10, 2017 @11:17PM (#15674968)
We are so, so early in robot development. Think of how far the Boston Dynamics robots have come in the last few years. Think of the videos of the robots slaying humans at rock-scissors-paper. Realise that immediately after a robot gets as good as a human at anything, it can subsequently exceed that.

They're evolving a thousand times faster than us.

Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by dogma1138 on Saturday November 11, 2017 @08:59PM (#15679288)
They aren’t evolving we are making them better.

There are plenty of robots that already exceed humans at their specific tasks my dishwasher is much better than me so is my washing machine.

Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by thibran on Friday November 10, 2017 @06:46PM (#15674062)
How To Survive A Robot Uprising: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-G3RoBHMu-o
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by sixothree on Friday November 10, 2017 @04:17PM (#15673122)
I envision a day in the near future where robots are used to break into houses and make arrests. Texas has already done some "groundbreaking" law enforcement with robots.
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by AncoraImparo on Friday November 10, 2017 @05:08PM (#15673463)
I watched this happen the other day. Swat team arrived arrived at my friend's apartment complex in Austin. Turns out there was an armed meth dealer holed up next door. SWAT sent a robot in to scope the situation, find him, and then knew where in the apartment he was, so as to work out the safest entry point for the team. Was fascinating!
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by xfactor973 on Friday November 10, 2017 @09:54PM (#15674746)
If the robots could somehow experience pain I think that would be a good motivator. It certainly keeps me from doing stupid stuff :-)
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by bitwize on Saturday November 11, 2017 @06:37AM (#15675942)
But if the robots experience pain, the Terminator won't be able to still go relentlessly after Sarah Connor despite being half blown apart.

I think the answer they'll settle on is selective pain -- pain receptors that can be switched off.

Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by petre on Saturday November 11, 2017 @02:05AM (#15675308)
Just detonate a nuke at high sltitude. That wold fry their circuits. The end.
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by jwilk on Friday November 10, 2017 @03:53PM (#15672936)
This seems to be a non-paywalled copy of the article:

http://news.morningstar.com/all/dow-jones/us-markets/2017111...

Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by dang on Friday November 10, 2017 @04:21PM (#15673149)
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by milansuk on Friday November 10, 2017 @05:49PM (#15673736)
Robots are like vampires. You have to invite them in.
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by jwilk on Friday November 10, 2017 @03:52PM (#15672928)
The submission title ("Robots are brains are primitive") doesn't make sense. Please use the original one.
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by SheepSlapper on Friday November 10, 2017 @04:17PM (#15673132)
It reads like a robot wrote this submission title
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by dang on Friday November 10, 2017 @04:22PM (#15673159)
Changed now.
Re:How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door by aaron695 on Saturday November 11, 2017 @10:45PM (#15679549)
Wouldn't you just design a self replicating nanobot that gives us all cancer? Apocalypse complete.