News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by eqmvii on Friday November 10, 2017 @07:55AM (#15669510)
After the last year, I assume anything WikiLeaks releases is /at least/ contextually misleading.
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by malvosenior on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:18AM (#15669641)
How is releasing factual information misleading?
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by karmajunkie on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:55AM (#15669854)
Because context is everything. It is easy to lead someone to draw the wrong conclusion by only providing part of the picture, when the context would lead one to a very different set of conclusions.
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by appleflaxen on Friday November 10, 2017 @03:49PM (#15672906)
not only has there not been a documented falsehood that WL propagated, but there has not been an example of something leaked to them that was subsequently withheld due to an agenda.

Unless you have evidence of either of these two things happening, you will not change my opinion that they are a force for openness in a very opaque political scene.

The fact that they release more that is anti-whatever says more about who is leaking than it does about WL.

Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by malvosenior on Friday November 10, 2017 @09:26AM (#15670040)
Wikileaks provides context that wouldn’t exist without their exposure of data.

More information being available to the public is a good thing.

Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by karmajunkie on Friday November 10, 2017 @01:15PM (#15671757)
In general, I think most people would agree with a blanket statement like that. But we don't actually know that wikileaks is providing context at all, because you don't know what isn't released. For example, sure, they've got 30k emails pilfered from Clinton. That paints a terribly unappealing picture of the Clinton campaign. But what about emails taken from a GOP-controlled server? What kind of context would those provide? Do they exist? What would they tell us about the other side of that question if they do? And crucially, what would it tell us about Wikileaks themselves if we knew they existed and weren't released?

Because that last scenario is the one I find extraordinarily likely.

Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by malvosenior on Saturday November 11, 2017 @12:25PM (#15677156)
Even if the scenario you describe is true (and there is no proof of that so this is purely a thought excersise), would you rather the Clinton emails weren’t released at all? Was there nothing to gain by learning that Clinton and the DNC worked against Sanders? That they had direct access to a very supportive media? At least we know that now.
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by karmajunkie on Sunday November 12, 2017 @02:48PM (#15682274)
There's not a good answer for that. Given hindsight and the knowledge that releasing them contributed directly to the election of Trump, yes, I'd say that I'd rather that they had not been released. If the opposing candidate had been a sane Republican the calculus might be a little different.

However, I think its self-deception of the highest order if you think either Wikileaks or the supplier of the Clinton emails is not also sitting on a great deal of incriminating evidence from the Trump campaign and/or the RNC.

Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by malvosenior on Monday November 13, 2017 @06:20PM (#15691194)
My values are consistent regardless of who is involved. More information is always better. I also don’t think it’s worth speculating on what information WL may have. That they exist at all is a huge service, that they’re not releasing the kind of information you imagine exists (and happens to help your political goals) doesn’t make the info they do release any less valuable.
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by zdkl on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:01AM (#15669548)
Why is this downvoted? Is there significant evidence to suggest wikilieaks was in fact not compromised?
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by peoplewindow on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:13AM (#15669612)
Why are you asking anyone to prove a negative?

There is no evidence that WikiLeaks has anything to do with Russia. None whatsoever. Whenever I've asked people why they think this, they give two reasons:

1 - WikiLeaks hasn't published leaks about the Russian government.

2 - Assange did some TV interviews on RT years ago.

These are both laughable. Assange himself gave the obvious explanation for (1) - they haven't done that because they didn't receive any. And it's equally obvious why not: WikiLeaks arose to handle leaks of material that the western press were refusing to publish for unsatisfying reasons, like the Iraq war stuff. But the western press would salivate at the opportunity to publish damaging leaks about the Russian government, assuming the original holder wanted the info to appear in the west and not in, say, Russian. So why would anyone with such material care about Wikileaks? There is no reason for them to do so.

Regardless, attempting to divine intent from things that have not happened is hardly a good standard of evidence to use when making serious accusations.

As for the TV interviews, well, RT is a large scale news channel that has interviewed tons of different people over the years. Appearing on a TV channel is hardly evidence of working for the related national government. Otherwise everyone who appears on the BBC works for the British government, anyone who appears on Al Jazeera is in the pocket of Qatar and so on.

Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by altcognito on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:23AM (#15669668)
1. It is disingenuous to say that WikiLeaks doesn't publish bad news about Russia. When panama papers came out they actually attacked the source.

2. They are hosted out of Russia.

3. They actively take sides in political battles. Hardly the stance of an objective "journalistic" organization.

Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by peoplewindow on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:51AM (#15669830)
"They attacked the source"? I had to go look for what you were talking about, I guess it's this:

http://www.aljazeera.com/programmes/listeningpost/2016/04/qa...

I don't see Assange attacking any sources in that Q&A. He does criticise (not attack) the way some journalists handled it, saying they put their own spin on things and that there should have been a bulk release. Otherwise, he argues, the impact would be low. That seems like a reasonable opinion to hold.

2. I looked at their IP addresses. They appear to have three datacenters, at least being advertised to me, one in Russia, one in the Netherlands and one in Norway. From a political perspective having servers in a place unfriendly to America, given how many of their leaks are about the US establishment, seems pretty sensible to me. But saying they are "hosted out of Russia" is extremely misleading, a lie of omission.

3. How are they "actively taking sides in political battles"? They leak what they get. If they didn't, leakers would go elsewhere to get their info out, it's not like Wikileaks has a monopoly on leaking. This is just slander and smearing.

Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by lyschoening on Saturday November 11, 2017 @04:50AM (#15675659)
> #PanamaPapers Putin attack was produced by OCCRP which targets Russia & former USSR and was funded by USAID & Soros.

https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/717458064324964352?lang...

Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by aljones on Friday November 10, 2017 @09:05AM (#15669919)
It is at least a hypocritical opinion. Podesta's emails were not bulk released. Wikileaks did put their own spin on them.

Do you know that they leak what they get? Cause there are credible accusations by former members that they do not.

Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by peoplewindow on Friday November 10, 2017 @01:17PM (#15671764)
Podesta's emails were bulk released:

https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/

You can search by text, attachment filename or email ID. How is that not bulk released?

Do you know that they leak what they get?

It's common sense that they do. These leaks come in the form of digital files, not papers. People give material to WikiLeaks so it gets published. If they gave material to WikiLeaks and nothing happened they'd just find another way to leak the same material - like Snowden when he went to Greenwald and Poitras instead of Assange.

This is why the idea that WikiLeaks is somehow a part of the Russian government is so mind-bendingly stupid propaganda. How would they hold anything back? Not only is there no motive and no evidence with these allegations, there isn't even common sense!

Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by appleflaxen on Friday November 10, 2017 @03:54PM (#15672947)
> Cause there are credible accusations by former members that they do not

that's an unreasonably low bar when they have done more for transparency than most conventional news organizations.

Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by Dolores12 on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:42AM (#15669781)
I don't really care if it's objective or not as long as they expose the truth.
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by alexandercrohde on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:45AM (#15669804)
That provides enough weight to take everything out of wikileaks with a grain of salt.

However, I don't think it's sufficient reason to flag/dismiss anything.

Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by zdkl on Friday November 10, 2017 @10:12AM (#15670347)
Whay about the change of public keys, tampering with pre-release hashes that occured during a time where no-one could reach Assange for about a month? Coincidentally during one of the larger DDOS events of the past year?

I'm stacking the tinfoil pretty hard but ignoring the history/politics you gotta say the technical side behaved in a weird way.

Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by zipwitch on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:38AM (#15669767)
10 years ago, Wikileaks promised an imminent expose on the Russian government. It has never materialized. http://content.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,2028283,00...
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by lyschoening on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:24AM (#15669676)
Wikileaks is compromised. The source of the leaks is beside the point. Their communications on Twitter over the past year or so leave absolutely no doubt that they are willing to bend the truth to support the Russian agenda. Everything Wikileaks and Assange have written on Twitter has been pure unadulterated garbage since the days of the presidential primaries.
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by AliAdams on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:12AM (#15669605)
Don't ask people to prove a negative.
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by zdkl on Friday November 10, 2017 @11:25AM (#15670933)
Ok I'll rephrase. Given the events of last year (the part with message hashes and public keys changing), what gives you faith in wikileaks and Assange?
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by mrschwabe on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:13AM (#15669613)
Julian Assange continues to be a beacon of freedom, accountability and hope to those who believe in a future not run by the military industrial complex. Evidence enough for me.
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by wazoox on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:42AM (#15669786)
No such thing as objective journalism exists, at least nowadays. Surely not in large media editorial lines... They are a crapfest of partisan lies. Reading the NYTimes become harder every day because my eyes keep rolling up in disbelief.
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by brbrodude on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:38AM (#15669763)
My guess, because of cognitive dissonance
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by malmsteen on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:33AM (#15669731)
How can you see the amount of downvotes ?
Re:WikiLeaks: CIA source code leak shows agency impersonatin... by YPCrumble on Friday November 10, 2017 @08:15AM (#15669627)
Why is it contextually misleading? Are you implying something about how they leaked information from Russia to influence the election?