Aside: emergency vehicles in the UK have stopped using the broad-band noise sirens AFAICT, I don't know why but the reason may be pertinent to any attempts to use it here? Actually, they often ride without the siren at all, which is completely ridiculous to me; they put it on at the junction meaning there's no time to get out of the way, if they used it continually you can hear them coming.
When they're putting it on at a junction and you're already in it, they're not expecting you to magically disappear out of their way. They're expecting you to look at where they're going and stay out of their path. This might involve proceeding as you were going to in order to clear it for them. What they really want is to stop anybody else from entering it until they've got through.
Self-driving cars don't have to be better than humans at everything in order to be objectively better drivers than humans. In 2010, 32,999 people died in car crashes in the US [0]. If self-driving cars are on-balance 1% better than human beings at driving, then 329 lives are saved.
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_motor_vehicle_deaths_i...
Seriously speaking from perspective of a truck driver.
The reasons truck driver backed into thing are: He couldn’t see it. It wasn’t there when he started.
Horn and flash of lights would stop a human driver. When I back up a truck I use all my senses, since I can’t see much. Easiest fix for the robot thingy - add horn and lights. (And wait until all residents start complaining)
Some people love driving, and some people love riding horses, but you don’t see many horses on city streets today.
All you have to do to cement a driverless-car hegemony is to stop issuing new driver's licenses. 50 years later: no more drivers.
When the sirens are used it's great because you can tell what road they're coming along (after a while, it was much better with the "squelch" sirens) and anticipate in good time.
Agreed, waking everyone at 2am is not needed generally, but howabout alerting people at 3pm.
You appear to have inside knowledge here, presumably there's been some change in policy on this in the last - I don't know - 5 years, where it's been chosen during normal daytime callouts not to use sirens if at all possible?
So Navya, the French company who has deployed several of these slow moving autonomous shuttle busses does not appear to have such sophisticated behavioral algorithms, in spite of entertaining ambitions of building proper robotaxis.
Perhaps that limitation should disqualify AI from driving cars.
To name just two potential issues that the "bus should have moved" people are ignoring:
1) What if there were pedestrians around?
2) What if moving the bus created an incursion into a stream of fast-moving traffic without warning?
Both of those could result in consequences far worse than the (apparently minor) fender-bender that actually occurred.
I agree that sounding the horn would be a good idea.
I think there are too many possible risks of programming the vehicle to do anything except stop dead in an emergency situation - you rapidly get into very complex programming with all kinds of failure modes - e.g. what if the problem was a faulty sensor? The vehicle might try to avoid a non-existent threat by crashing into something else. Stopping is the safe thing to do. If you want to react, you rapidly have to make lots of moral decisions like (The Trolley Problem).
Briefly sounding a horn in an unexpected emergency stop situation is probably a good idea, particularly if it's a white noise type thing, rather than a siren, so that other road users can localise it's source quickly.